Update on that rottie case

How can they tell that he had a stroke before he was attacked, rather than had a stroke while being attacked????

Also, not sure if I would be impressed with a dog attacking my face if I had a funny turn!!!!
 
its a natural reaction of an animal. the dog would probably have started by licking to get a response, then nipping and eventually biting. Its something they do to their young as well should one be stillborn.
 
Fair enough.... still wouldnt fancy a kiss from that dog though
tongue.gif
 
im glad it was proved the dog didnt kill him maybe people will give the dog a break now although again too late for the dog as it lost its life being loyal to its owner.but im sure certain people that are against rotties on here will argue with the professionals and still think the dog killed him

RIP owner and dog.
 
Very sad incident for both the man and his loyal dog. The dog was only reacting in a natural concerned doggy manner.
frown.gif
 
I may be wrong, but I have a feeling that the body follows a sequence of events which happen as a result of individual traumas - where the investigation of the body actually tells the story of what moment certain things happened?

Most dogs who have strong loyalty to their owners will react in this manner if faced with concern over why the owner has dropped to the ground. It's quite natural for them to try to rouse the person.
 
Tia, whatever the man actually died of he was taken to hospital with severe head and face injuries caused by his dog. are you really saying that its natural for a dog to do that if someone has collasped ? what if someone faints, has a fit or falls off their horse or whatever would you expect their dog to attack ?? would you be so understanding if it was somebody you knew ?
 
for gods sake bonny just accept your wrong the dog did not attack it was nibbling and pawing the man which would cause injuries the dog was not acting in an aggressive manner otherwise if it had the man would have been taken to hospital in bits!!!!!you just seem to want to pick a fight with everyone ifyou had any dignity you would just accept rotties aint mean killing machines like you wish to believe!!!!!!!
 
I was asking Tia a question and you are talking rambling nonsense. Can a person not have a different point of view to you without you taking it personally?
 
[ QUOTE ]
Tia, whatever the man actually died of he was taken to hospital with severe head and face injuries caused by his dog

[/ QUOTE ]
I suspect the man was taken to hospital because he was injured/sick/dying.
[ QUOTE ]
are you really saying that its natural for a dog to do that if someone has collasped ?

[/ QUOTE ]
As I said above, yes of course it is natural behaviour for a dog, true and loyal to it's owner, to do this.
[ QUOTE ]
what if someone faints, has a fit or falls off their horse or whatever would you expect their dog to attack ??

[/ QUOTE ]
As above.
[ QUOTE ]
would you be so understanding if it was somebody you knew ?

[/ QUOTE ]
Yes of course I would be; I understand dog behaviour. People who do not understand the loyalty a dog shows it's owner obviously can't; I guess you have no comprehension of dog behaviour.
 
I can't believe you really mean that, are you saying that anyone who has collasped is liable to be attacked by their own dog ? I do understand dog behaviour, i have had dogs all my life and worked with them and would not expect one of my dogs to bite someone for any reason. What about people who have epilepsy, or who are prone to fainting , do they just not have dogs ?
by your reasoning we are all at risk of attack by our own dogs !
 
Yet again you have read something and leaped to conclusions which fit your own opinions. How do you know he didn't have a stroke and incur injuries whilst falling? There is no reference to the dog causing the injuries, or if it did bite him, which appears to be in question, whether it caused severe injuries.
Can just see you in a lynch mob Bonny.
 
what about all the witnesses and if the dog did nothing aggressive why the armed police ? or do you think thats normal when somebody collaspes in the street ??
 
Not sure why you think I am being critical?
confused.gif
I'm simply saying that, having read a number of your posts, you do appear to be quite uninformed (ignorant) about animal behaviour in general.
 
I didn't think you were being critical, I thought you were being personal ! why don't you answer my questions instead ? I assume by you thinking me ignorant about animal behaviour you are referring to my aggressive pony question ?
no one and I'm including you has come up with the answer to him. I have had horses adn worked with horses for more years than I like to think and I've never come across a pony like him. That aside that had nothing to do with me wondering why you thought it ok for a dog to bite if someone had collasped.....
 
Umm, I have answered your questions. Not answering you again as you clearly as not listening AT ALL to anything anyone has previously said to you.

Perhaps looking up a dictionary to find out the meaning of the words "personal & critical" and "ignorant & uninformed" would be of interest to you.

As to your pony - you give it treats when it attacks you, I'll say no more.
crazy.gif
 
HMMM Am trying so v hard not to post but after a couple of glasses of vino... what the hell! Distinctly remember bonny saying in previous post that it was FACT that the dog had killed his owner, Many many people argued that this what not the case & the dog was showing "extreme" but typical dog behaviour in response to his owners collapse. And hear we are again.... It has now been confirmed that the dog played no part in his owners death & still bonny refuses to accept this.. the term flogging a dead horse comes to mind! Now im all for "each to their own" but ide just like to say if i held an opinion & then discovered that so many other people thought i was wrong, personally i would start to question wether or not my view is biased or down right wrong. This is not to be confused with strength of conviction! more an intelligent weighing up of all the information at hand. Why wont some poeple accept the fact they were wrong??
 
"I'll say no more" - you never said anything in the first place !!reference to the dictionary is just pointless and I hardly said i give the pony treats when he attacks - i said i only gave him treats when catching him in the field because it is the only way of avoiding being bitten.
if you have nothing useful to say then why not say nothing - I take it you can't come up with any answers to my questions and so resort to being personal again. No need
 
I'm no more wrong than you are - we just have different opinions, whats so wrong with that ???
If you want to argue that I don't know all the facts of the case then that must be true of all of us on here !
 
Dissagree! I never claimed one way or another to know any facts about what happened between man & dog. You however did. I repeat you said... FACT that the dog had killed its owner. It has now been proved not to be the case. You were Wrong FACT! Not arguing any other points or differences of opinions, end of!!
 
Yep I do have to wholeheartedly agree with the previous poster; flogging a dead horse.

[ QUOTE ]
I take it you can't come up with any answers to my questions

[/ QUOTE ]

Umm. As I said a moment ago - I already did. Just how many times do you want me to repeat my answers? Here you go, once again, just for you. Last time, mind you.
wink.gif


[ QUOTE ]


Tia, whatever the man actually died of he was taken to hospital with severe head and face injuries caused by his dog


I suspect the man was taken to hospital because he was injured/sick/dying.

are you really saying that its natural for a dog to do that if someone has collasped ?

As I said above, yes of course it is natural behaviour for a dog, true and loyal to it's owner, to do this.

what if someone faints, has a fit or falls off their horse or whatever would you expect their dog to attack ??

As above.

would you be so understanding if it was somebody you knew ?

Yes of course I would be; I understand dog behaviour. People who do not understand the loyalty a dog shows it's owner obviously can't; I guess you have no comprehension of dog behaviour.

[/ QUOTE ]
 
Very good point Liveryblues.

I had forgotten that it was bonny who declared that it was a FACT that the dog had killed the man.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top