When is the right time to retire my horse?

Joined
20 October 2016
Messages
20
Visit site
I bought my horse a few years ago with the intention of getting back in the saddle, doing some schooling, hacking, clinics and dressage. Over the last few years we have done just that! He's quirky and hasn't been an easy horse, but I achieved everything I wanted to with him.

He's a large horse (WB) at 16,3hh and has always done a job. He was a show jumper for many years and competed up and down the country (jumping large tracks).

He is now 16 and we have had an up and down year of veterinary issues. He had stifle problems that were treated with stem cell therapy and rounds of cartrophen, plus rest. I brought him back from that (following the rehab plan strictly) and we went on to do some more clinics etc over the summer. Though signed off by the vet I always found he still was never 100% behind. He has always found collection very easy, but I found he was wanting to be on the forehand more and struggled to collect in the canter (which was always his favourite thing to do)!

He was then diagnosed with some mild (as the vet puts it, very mild) navicular and collateral ligament changes in front. This was treated again with steroid, cartrophen, rest and remedial shoeing (he is now shod with heart bars and pads for support). He came back from that fine and we continued to have fun.

We continued to plod along, hacking, clinics etc, with some competitions booked. He has then injured himself in the field (despite me asking and asking for the fields to be rolled before the summer, they were not rolled. Vet thinks he stepped down a rut, in a very rutted field). He now has swelling of the SDFT and the vet has noted annular ligament swelling. We are currently going in to week 3 of box rest and in hand walking. I agreed with the vet that I can turn him out in the arena for half an hour every morning (as he doesn't tend to run around - just eats grass from the edges, and has a roll). So he gets half an hour out while I muck out etc. I then in hand walk him (bandaged up, as suggested by the vet) for 20 minutes every evening, and he gets some hand grazing. Surprisingly, he is being such a good boy! And has company in the barn all the time, so seems quite content. I have a very large stable. Vet is coming back to review in 6 weeks. I don't know what I'll do about small area turn out, as I don't have that option on the yard I'm on. So may need to look at moving to somewhere were I can gradually get him back out. Not just turn him out with a large herd and undo all of our rehab!

All of that I can deal with, I don't mind rehabbing again and if I have to move yards so be it, I just want what is best for him. I said to my vet that I don't care if he doesn't come back competitively or if he becomes a hacking horse, as long as he is comfortable and happy. The vet said he is not ruling him out as a competition horse, but we do have a collective range of issues that could go at any point. Though the vet agreed, that keeping horses fit and in work is always helpful.


Where I am struggling is me. I don't know if it's because he is off injured, or because I have a lot of other things going on in life, but I have lost all interest. Not in him I must add - he is my world, and I love him to pieces. I have lost interest in riding full stop. I have a busy career, my own business that is just taking off, and kids at home. It seems I've lost all interest and confidence when it comes to riding. I don't have the desire that I used to have. In the past I've been so excited to get my horse fit again and the idea of competing again was all I focused on, yet now I'm happy not doing that (which I suppose meant another stint of rehab didn't hit me as hard this time.....).

I will do everything it takes to get my boy sound and happy, but I suppose what I'm asking, is, is it selfish to retire my horse because I no longer have interest in riding? Does that sound awful? Is that a reason to retire him?
I keep thinking about it. Maybe it's just because of where we are at right now? And I'll get back to wanting to ride again?
I've ridden for 30 years, competing, working in the industry etc. But now it feels like I'm moving in a different direction and that desire is no longer there.

Maybe someone can advise. It seems my mind is all over the place at the minute! My horse is 16 (which I know is by far still young enough... but he's done a job, hence the veterinary issues we have had)
 

94lunagem

Well-Known Member
Joined
6 August 2023
Messages
3,980
Visit site
I will do everything it takes to get my boy sound and happy, but I suppose what I'm asking, is, is it selfish to retire my horse because I no longer have interest in riding? Does that sound awful?
Not selfish at all. At the end of the day, he’s your horse and it’s nobody else’s business.

But given you’ve asked for thoughts, you sound like a thoroughly loving owner and have clearly taken wonderful care of him through his past injuries. This is a horse who has had his veterinary issues and doesn’t owe you anything. If you are in a position to continue looking after him there is no reason he can’t enjoy a happy retirement that suits both of you.

It’s hard to admit to yourself when life and priorities change. I had it when I lost my last competition horse, admitting to myself that I didn’t actually want another felt completely alien after having ridden for 30 years. I now have non-ridden ponies and I don’t miss riding at all.

16 isn’t all that old, but personally I think of it like people. If you’ve had health problems throughout your life you’ll probably age quicker. I lost one at 28 (suddenly) who I could count vet visits on one hand in the 22 years I’d owned him. And another at 19 but he’d been a walking insurance claim from day 1 and retired at a similar age to your boy. I’m not saying your boy won’t have long and healthy retirement, just that they’re all different.

Do what suits you and your horse.
 

setterlover

Well-Known Member
Joined
2 August 2023
Messages
547
Visit site
I don't think horses mind if they are ridden or not though most do like contact
After a horrendous couple of years personally.My best friend is now paraplegic after a fall riding and my sister was killed after a fall on the road riding.
I cracked ribs after a fall from one of mine badly spooking I have hung up my riding boots. I lost the will to ride and became constantly worried about an accident.
The remaining 2 horses are 20 and 25
I keep them at home they live out 24/7 they have a huge pole barn with free. access they get no hard feed and are unrugged haylege is put out am and pm and they are perfectly happy .
I get them in to lightly groom them and handle them but like you I have no inclination to ride and it's been a year now and I don't miss it at all .I love getting out and about with my dogs and travelling the UK with my dogs .I have an excellent horse sitter so go abroad 3 times a year.I love this life.
If you want to retire your horse do so I don't regret it at all.
These will be the last horses for me.
 

Abacus

Well-Known Member
Joined
17 February 2011
Messages
2,370
Visit site
Maybe it would help to set down the options and try to decide which works best for you. A simplified version which I am sure you can be more detailed about:

1: Work towards getting him turned out and comfortable enough, and retire - and see how he goes, and if he takes to it.
2: A version of the above - but review in 6 months, both his soundness and your motivation - see in spring, if you feel that if he could be made fit and sound, and you'd like to carry on doing something with him (and there are options again within this, from gentle riding to competition)
3: Crack on with more rehab including any treatments that are necessary/affordable and try to get him sound, again with the view that your motivation might improve with his ability to work. If he doesn't stand up to work, then revert to (1) or (2).

None of these is wrong, and your own feeling about riding plays a large part in the decision. Not many horses mind being retired from work. Plenty of horses are working still beyond 16, but not all of them make it that far, so don't be too set in thinking that 16 is young for retirement. We've all seen stories here of the great lengths we go to to keep a horse sound and working, and its ok to stop doing it at the point that suits you.

A personal opinion from me in terms of getting him sound is that if working a horse is impossible or for some reason unmanageable (including zero motivation to do it), then field rest is the next best thing.
 

CJoe

Well-Known Member
Joined
20 July 2018
Messages
176
Visit site
I could have written this! my lovely boy is now 17, was a showjumper but diagnosed with navicular after a couple of odd stops which is unheard of. I dont think he will jump again and he doesnt need to, great results over the years, nothing to prove. Tried injections, didnt work. Tried a few other things, he is comfortable but did end up taking his shoes off a few months ago, has boots now and he is sounder than he was pre boots and being shod.

He won't retire gracefully as he just doesnt understand not working, so he is now a happy hacker, walk and trot always sound, canter not always, so I play it by ear and let him lead the way.

If your horse wants to work in some form, then it may be happy hacker is the way to go, its a tough one as I was happy to retire mine but he was just so angry at not doing anything, I rested him for a few months and brought him back slowly, took the shoes off etc and now he is really comfortable and chirpy again. The pressure of keeping him ultra fit is nice not to have!

On the lost interest bit, I went off the boil completely, however a few months on and having bought a youngster (to divert my attention somewhat from the devastating news of my boy) I have got some mojo back!

There is nothing to say if you retire him that you cannot bring him back as a hacker later on down the line if you miss riding? A year off may do him the world of good perhaps? I know the rest certainly helped my lad. If he has happy retiring you are absolutely not doing him any harm at all! - as long as fed and needs met, and he isnt desperate to be working, there is no issue and you should certainly not feel any guilt!

Perhaps test the waters, give him 6 months off and see how you feel after that?

Wishing you the best xx
 

3OldPonies

Well-Known Member
Joined
25 March 2013
Messages
1,621
Location
Berkshire
Visit site
I've always found they tell us when it's time, if we listen.

I think your horse is shouting as loud as he can "can we stop now I keep hurting myself". Why not give him and you some guilt and pressure free time off over the winter, then when you're both feeling in a better place, see how you feel? When the pressure to be competing, doing clinics, etc is gone you might find that a plod around the lanes in semi-retirement keeps you both happy. If the odd plod is still too much given the veterinary issues then perhaps it is time to think of full retirement.
 

Birker2020

Well-Known Member
Joined
18 January 2021
Messages
10,549
Location
West Mids
Visit site
When I was no longer advised to continue jumping Bails due to her reoccurring suspensory branch injury I was devastated but I thoroughly enjoyed hacking and schooling, and I did continue to pop the odd tree trunk of fun rides, probably two jumps in every three fun rides. But I suddenly really looked forward to hacking.

I'd moved from a really great hacking area back to my old yard where the hacking wasn't so good so arranged with the woman who ran the pub in the area I was previously stabled in to be able to park the trailer there early on Sunday mornings so I could still hack out. I loved hacking round my old haunts and so did Bails. Gradually I came to terms with not being able to jump anymore (which was my whole life really) and we spent many happy years hacking instead.
 
Last edited:

slimjim86

Well-Known Member
Joined
5 May 2010
Messages
517
Visit site
I retired mine younger than that because I just wasn't enjoying riding ( she didn't even have any veterinary issues to factor in). There's nothing wrong with saying you will give him the winter off and decide how you feel in the summer, if mine was 1 that you could jump on and take for a hang once or twice every few weeks maybe I would have considered doing that but she's just not one thar settles without a routine.
 

irishdraft

Well-Known Member
Joined
13 November 2009
Messages
1,836
Visit site
No your not selfish to want to retire your horse, you sound like a very caring owner. I had to retire my horse at 12 as he was injured, soft tissue injury in the hoof & never came right, I can honestly say I don't think he has been happier, I've owned him since a weanling and is now 17. He has same routine as my ridden mare so still has attention etc and is not ignored. I actually think my mare would love a retired life as well, possibly some horses wouldn't enjoy it but both of mine can be anxious, stressy types so just being at home suits them.
 
Joined
20 October 2016
Messages
20
Visit site
Thank you all for your input. It’s so appreciated 🥰
I am liking the idea of resting over the winter and reassessing next spring.
Just not sure how I go about turning him out with the others, in case he makes the injury worse
 

Polos Mum

Well-Known Member
Joined
22 September 2012
Messages
6,149
Location
West Yorkshire
Visit site
I often find motivation hard over winter.

I would chat to your vet and see whether there would be any ill effects from giving him a good 4-6 months off in the field and then picking him back up in spring - IF you want to.

I had one (a high mileage competition horse) who did a tendon and I did months of box rest and rehab - to the T of the vets instructions. Came back into work but 9 months later it went again. That time I chose to just pop him out and see. Within 6 months he was back better and stronger than all the rehab stuff and with 0.2% of the stress on both of us.

I give mine at least a month off every year - it seems to iron out all the minor niggles and I'm itching to ride again when the time comes
 

blitznbobs

Well-Known Member
Joined
19 June 2010
Messages
6,639
Location
Cheshire
Visit site
Meh he could give a flying fiddle de Dee… he is a horse - he likes food , horses and a bit of company … it sounds like a ‘get out of jail free’ card to me — retire him and live your life
Also I agree 6 months in the field fixes a host of things that vets fail to
 

Pedantic

Well-Known Member
Joined
3 November 2007
Messages
7,582
Location
Derbyshire
Visit site
Horses are designed to be out in the open, in a herd, eating and pooing and pro creating, yes I'm sure most enjoy their job if working, as long as it's stimulating and not ridiculously hard, but they wouldn't care if they didn't work, so I wouldn't stress over it, just enjoy the looking after grooming etc and Bond x
 

AutumnDays

Well-Known Member
Joined
30 August 2020
Messages
547
Visit site
Not selfish at all, he sounds like he wants for nothing. I have one who is retired from riding (rescue) at 13, and I have my just turned 5 year old who retired at 4 and a half because of a field accident giving her sacroiliac issues. I handle them, spend time with them, go for walks now and again... They don't really care they aren't ridden, they are happy as long as there is food and attention!
 

Fjord

Well-Known Member
Joined
19 July 2009
Messages
2,560
Visit site
He'll be happy just living a life of leisure, so don't feel guilty. Maybe let him have winter off and reassess in the spring?
 

Abacus

Well-Known Member
Joined
17 February 2011
Messages
2,370
Visit site
Possibly, if he has a giddy moment. But you can minimise the risk in some ways - start with sedative/small paddock and when turned out in company make sure they are quiet and not too dominant. I tell myself that if you do all this and he does re-injure himself then he’s probably not going to withstand work, either.
 
Joined
20 October 2016
Messages
20
Visit site
Update:

I’m really struggling with the best options for my boy. It’s causing me so much stress

My current yard has a very large, aggressive herd (many keep getting injured), a very rutted field (which is how he did his SDFT injury in the first place) and they are not willing to let me have small paddock turnout to begin with.

I’ve been asking around for weeks for another local yard but there is nothing. If further away I would need full livery, but I can’t afford that. I’ve had him on diy for years.

I’ve even considered retirement livery somewhere, but not sure I can trust anyone. He’s not an easy horse to do, which is why ideally I wanted him to retire with me


This is so heartbreaking 💔
 

Abacus

Well-Known Member
Joined
17 February 2011
Messages
2,370
Visit site
My current yard has a very large, aggressive herd (many keep getting injured), a very rutted field (which is how he did his SDFT injury in the first place) and they are not willing to let me have small paddock turnout to begin with.

I’ve been asking around for weeks for another local yard but there is nothing. If further away I would need full livery, but I can’t afford that. I’ve had him on diy for years.

I’ve even considered retirement livery somewhere, but not sure I can trust anyone. He’s not an easy horse to do, which is why ideally I wanted him to retire with me

Where in the country are you?
 

Polos Mum

Well-Known Member
Joined
22 September 2012
Messages
6,149
Location
West Yorkshire
Visit site
It's a tricky time of year because lots of people move yards coming into winter it seems.

Perhaps ask around (some of the best yards don't need to advertise) ask your local riding club, instructor, farrier - they may know of retirement type yards (without facilities like school) that would suit him but might not be common knowledge.
Or someone might want a companion at a private yard and be happy for DIY basis.

I would keep looking if you're not happy that where he is will suit this next phase of his life.
 
Top