Which bit to try next…

equidstar11

Active Member
Joined
30 April 2024
Messages
45
Visit site
Hi all,

I have a bitting question (which I know is entirely trial and error, but some advice on where to try first would be helpful)!

Said horse (large Warmblood) is currently jumped in a Winderen Butterfly Flip (curb bit) with their firm plastic ported mouthpiece - previous to this he was in a very slightly ported mullen metal pelham (short shank) with curb. He has always worked fairly well in these, however I feel they are bit strong for him (hence why I went to the plastic butterfly from pelham, but it’s still a bit much) - when taking a half halt into a fence he can overreact, and just feels all a bit too uptight, and not willing to take me into a fence (very bouncy and loses rhythm, also throws head into the air). The issue is he can get fairly strong/excitable at shows/when jumping. These two bits have helped pull him off the forehand (I know pelham/curb is usually the opposite of an elevator but they have worked for him) and not tank me along, so something in the middle would be a nice medium. I have tried using a flexi mullen Winderen mouthpiece with D cheeks for jumping, and this is what I flat him in, but he tends to lean on this and pull onto the forehand, including into jumps (and yes, we are doing millions of walk/trot/halt/canter etc transitions a week alongside lots and lots of hill work). I did also try an NS verbindend loose ring & also the NS D trans angled bit, neither of which I had particularly good feeling with.

I have had someone offer me to try their ported mullen Trust combination bit (short shanks), which has a fabric curb which he may like but also uses some nose pressure. I have used a hackamore in the past which worked to a point, I don’t think it was quite enough brakes to contain him at a show.

Other than that, any suggestions? I want him to feel he can take me to a fence, without tanking off and me being able to make small half halts without him reacting too harshly. I also don’t want to lose steering.

I would prefer a less is more approach - I don’t use a martingale as I don’t like the effect it has on the bit and I don’t like standing martingales as I feel they restrict movement over a fence.
 

Ratface

Well-Known Member
Joined
23 September 2021
Messages
3,477
Visit site
The far-too-much-forn-me Egyptian Arabian that I bought as a terrified walking skeleton from the Belfast marshes eventually became more manageable when he was introduced to a kimblewick bit. Using that, he responded to a light sqeeze on the rein to come back to me, rather than the fight that he put up against all versions of a snaffle. He's now with a friend in Lincolnshire and still in a kimblewick, doing everything (jumping cross-country, endurance, hacking across farmland, riding club stuff) and she has no trouble in managing his still onward-bound enthusiastic behaviour. Perhaps try a bit bank trial first?
 

gallopingby

Well-Known Member
Joined
17 January 2009
Messages
1,885
Visit site
One of the Bit Banks would be worth a trial, although it may seem expensive if you don’t find one first time it’s definitely worth getting in touch with them.
 

equidstar11

Active Member
Joined
30 April 2024
Messages
45
Visit site
Out of fashion but what about a kimblewick? You can get slotted versions to increase the action if needed, i would also try a chain cover to soften the effect of the curb
I believe the butterfly RnF I currently use is a Kimblewick. I don’t use a curb chain, just a nice width leather strap, none of it is tight/harsh inc the plastic mouthpiece - in fact I was rather shocked when I first tried it as to just how sensitive he was in it, considering there isn’t very much leverage and the curb is soft.

I did manage to try the trust combination bit today (with sheepskin on the nose and the fabric curb) and he was far better, still had control and took a rhythm into a small fence. I have a jump lesson soon at my local venue which I’ll give it a try there.

I would however like to explore more simple options and move to a snaffle type mouthpiece when his training increases. What would be good to try then?

I know the Pelhams have some height above the shanks like a hanging cheek (and the Pelhams etc I’ve tried are very small levers), so I could try a hanging cheek with a Mullen mouth as he has right now.
 

avthechav

Well-Known Member
Joined
26 May 2008
Messages
1,064
Location
Cotswolds
Visit site
Have you tried a trans universal with a backstrap? The backstrap made all the difference to my horse. I think it helped to stabilise it and stop mine from over reacting.
 
Top