Which type of towbar?

holeymoley

Well-Known Member
Joined
18 November 2012
Messages
4,859
Visit site
Need to get the towbar put on my new car pretty soon as it appears we'll be attending the vet school sooner than thought.

Previous car had a standard flange towbar. Any difference between flange type and swan neck other than visually?! Just in case I'm missing anything obvious.
 
https://www.pfjones.co.uk/tow-bar-types-explained.html

Here you go. I went through all this pondering when taking over my Dads car following his death and having a tow bar fitted. THese aren't the people I chose to use - I used CDF Towbars in Coventry, the price was £175 from memory for supply and fit at my premises - I went for the flange one in the end. I have used CDF twice previously and was delighted with their service if you want a recommendation although I'm not sure where you live!
Need to get the towbar put on my new car pretty soon as it appears we'll be attending the vet school sooner than thought.

Previous car had a standard flange towbar. Any difference between flange type and swan neck other than visually?! Just in case I'm missing anything obvious.
 
https://www.pfjones.co.uk/tow-bar-types-explained.html

Here you go. I went through all this pondering when taking over my Dads car following his death and having a tow bar fitted. THese aren't the people I chose to use - I used CDF Towbars in Coventry, the price was £175 from memory for supply and fit at my premises - I went for the flange one in the end. I have used CDF twice previously and was delighted with their service if you want a recommendation although I'm not sure where you live!

Thank you, will have a look at that. Crikey, I've been quoted £300 for a swan and £385 for a flange! Didn't think I was that dear with my old car but I suppose you pay for the name.
 
Thank you, will have a look at that. Crikey, I've been quoted £300 for a swan and £385 for a flange! Didn't think I was that dear with my old car but I suppose you pay for the name.
It pays to shop around, I did just that when CDF quoted me originally as it was an additional £100 more than I had paid the time before. But other prices were astronomical and they certainly ended up being the cheapest by far. I think its a Witter tow bar but not entirely sure. There's not much info on their website.
 
There's a bit of difference between flanged and swan neck but they both operate the same way. You can't fit a protection plate with a swan neck, or one of those bike carriers that has a plate for the uprights to fit into. Your main choice is between fixed and detachable. Detachable are much more expensive but don't spoil the look of the car once removed (that may or may not be an issue for you). Be aware that the tow bar can interfere with reversing sensors if you have those fitted (it doesn't always, and is less likely with a swan neck). Some cars can have the sensors programmed to cut out when a trailer is attached, but that usually only happens if you have a tow bar fitted by the car manufacturer. Check with the tow bar fitter. If you are the area of South Staffordshire, West Midlands I can recommend All-Fit in Lichfield (http://www.all-fit.co.uk/)
 
Hubby and I were both separately advised to get a swan neck towbar, as the standard type would affect the rear parking sensors.

It has been used both to tow a horse trailer and for a thule bike carrier.

We definitely didn't go for detachable though, I don't trust them.

Fiona
 
There's a bit of difference between flanged and swan neck but they both operate the same way. You can't fit a protection plate with a swan neck, or one of those bike carriers that has a plate for the uprights to fit into. Your main choice is between fixed and detachable. Detachable are much more expensive but don't spoil the look of the car once removed (that may or may not be an issue for you). Be aware that the tow bar can interfere with reversing sensors if you have those fitted (it doesn't always, and is less likely with a swan neck). Some cars can have the sensors programmed to cut out when a trailer is attached, but that usually only happens if you have a tow bar fitted by the car manufacturer. Check with the tow bar fitter. If you are the area of South Staffordshire, West Midlands I can recommend All-Fit in Lichfield (http://www.all-fit.co.uk/)
My particular car has reversing sensor but it also has a button on the dash that you can press to temporary stop the reversing sensors from working thus making the noise, but I'm not sure if all cars have this format. And like you say it only comes on when you reverse which isn't very often in the scheme of things although I do admit its a bit of a distraction when it does happen. I used to have a plate on the tow bar of the previous car but not on this one, I could do with knocking one up and getting my mechanic to fit it to save the body work in case of accident! Its extremely annoying when you misjudge the distance and cars these days have body work which is so fragile, I have one of those electric handbrakes that mean hitching up can be a bit of a nightmare as he car does tend to leap back a small distance when you reverse and go past the 'biting point' on the clutch (unless of course you then override the electric handbrake) which I've not managed to figure out how to do cleanly yet.
 
Top