Why are people so pig headed about castration?

If they are not being breed from they are better off done - as they get older they may be more prone to womb infections so end up being speyed then anyway. Is better for them as it takes a couple of days to recover then they can walk every day without being bothered by dogs etc
 
I deliberated a lot about getting my puplet castrated, at almost 3 he does remain entire, even though I have no intention of ever breeding from him. On the one hand I see the benefits in removing urges he is not allowed to act on and in removing the chance of tumours, but on the other I just felt why put him through an unnecessary operation when his behaviour is never a problem - he never chases bitches, humps anything or roams.

My vet was very non committal when I asked her for advice and said that she felt it was a personal decision and that if the dog's behaviour was not a problem then I probably shouldn't worry about it. (this surpised me as I expected the hard sell on it from the vet) His groomer is a very old school showing type and he says that if I had him done he would not groom him anymore as it ruins their coats - I am never sure if he really means he would turn me away or if he would just have a big moan about it! But then he detests backyard breeding and his desire to let males hang onto their bits is not related to a corresponding opinion that they should go forth and conquer. :P

So yeah...this all combined has meant puplet remains with his danglies. I feel that I am still a responsible owner, and I feel that I am far removed from the type of dreadful behaviour the OP is witnessing with her acquaintance.
 
I dont normally post in here, but I was having a conversation with someone at the weekend and felt it might be worth a post just to see whether I am alone in my 'rage' over this issue...:confused::D

A friend of mine was telling me about someone they know who has a one year old mongrel. He's very cute, and has a lovely nature, but he's pretty scruffy to look at and has a very dodgy back end - a definite mish mash of breeds! This person lives in the countryside where there are about 6/8 houses within a mile. The dog is still entire - because one day the owner says she would like to breed from him (why!?!?) - and he has recently taken to wandering off for days on end - the local animal shelter have taken him in several times when he's been picked up from neighbouring villages, and the RSPCA have picked him up twice. The dog has already impregnated a bitch belonging to someone living about a mile away - the owner had simply let the bitch into the garden for a wee last thing at night when she found her tied with this mongrel, who had jumped into the garden.
I do not know whether the mongrel's owner has offered any financial assistance with vet fees (bitch's owner did not want pups so paid for injection) but I suspect not. The woman told my friend that 'other people shouldnt let their bitches out if they dont want them pregnant - it's their responsibility, not mine.' And this bit takes the biscuit - my friend asked the woman whether she had contemplated having the dog castrated as it may calm his wandering instincts down and would certainly stop him sh*gging anyone else's poor bitches, and the woman said no way - she'd rather rehome him than castrate him. WTF???? If she rehomed him through the RSPCA or similar then the first thing they would do would be to castrate him anyway...

In my opinion, no dog should be left entire unless it is an excellent example of its breed, and if it is expressly intended to be used for stud purposes. It really, really narks me that some people refuse to have their dogs castrated purely because they feel 'it isnt their responsibility'. In the horse world, people in general seem to be a bit more sensible - ok there are a few manky stallions around for some reason but not many. Why hasnt this mentality transferred through to the dog world? I have known many male dogs in the past - both castrated and entire - and the ones who have been done are far nicer as family pets - and far less of a liability.

As the owner of a Lab who was twice 'caught' at the age of eighteen months and then two years by a neighbour's wandering dog when we had simply let her into the (secure) garden, this is something I feel very strongly about. Our bitch is now spayed, as will be any dog we own in the future. And dont even get me started on cats - IMO anyone who keeps a cat un-neutered - whether queen or tom - is utterly irresponsible.

Right - I've had my rant! How do other people feel about this?

I'm with you on this next doors dog's in for the snip if I can get a hold of him - I have had to have one of my bitches injected because of him - next door the other way had their bitch caught by him and needs injecting! I wouldn't care if it was a breed but its a bloody mongrel and who the hell wants to use it at stud! I don't want it over my bitches - who might I add are good quality examples of their breed and if they wern't would be spayed!
 
Quartz, I would definitely have yours done. As has already been said you can have pre op bloods to check they are fully fit before surgery. Older bitches are definitely more prone to pyometra if not spayed, which can at worst be fatal, or at best they will need to be spayed as an emergency op when ill, far better imo to have it done when they are fit and well.
 
Yes same with bitches they can get pyometra and thats nasty if not got at quick they also can get mammary gland tumors too if they get these they have to go through a big op its really not worth it everyone should get there dogs done. Its not major money to get there dogs done but if they have a problem and there not done its can cost a hell of alot and put the dogs life at risk.
 
I am talking to the vet this afternoon. I have been in tears with frustration this morning as the neighbours dog is on heat and of course opened the door to get something and out he snuck. I knew he was gone straight away, but was not dressed yet, as well as my 4 year old and 5year old children. While I was getting us all dressed as fast as possible the neighbour brought him back, not very happy of course (the neighbour that is not the dog). I feel awful and just cannot take it anymore. He is a pedigree but I know we will not, purposfully, breed from him so its time. Also the problem with our house is the windows are all floor to ceiling doors so you cannot open them unless you want a door open if you see what I mean. I will also talk to vet about booking the bitch in. Again she is pedigree but I doubt we will breed with her, personally I would just prefer peace of mind and a peaceful life!!!
 
My old dog wasn't done until 8, I wish we'd had it done earlier as we had lots of complications and I am sure this was down to the family stupidity of not getting him done when he was a pup.

My Roly was done at 7 months or so and it was a very easy simple op and he recovered perfectly.
 
I wish we had done him before, but men seem to have a funny view about doing this to a dogs manhood. I'm all for it, just a shame it took me 7 years to force the issue.
 
Otto was done at 8 months, despite having all the promise of being an outstanding working dog (he has the natural ability to be brilliant, just wasn't trained properly!) I couldn't bear the thought of little versions of him going to pet homes.
If Otto hadn't ended up with us, he would either be in a rescue or be dead, I have absolutely no doubt about that! So creating lots of little versions of him would seem like a recipe for disaster!

I only wish castrating him made him less active and prone to weight gain :rolleyes:
 
GOOD breeders will take the pup back if the new owner gives up on it, but most of the backyard breeders don't want to know, so the dog ends up in rescue.[/QUOTE]

A very important and often overlooked point.
A responsible breeder considers themselves responsible for the dogs they have bred whether they are puppies or in fact adults!
As for blokes not wanting their pet dogs castrated, it`s ignorance, I`m a complete male yet I have the benefit of education :D

One fact always baffles me, anyone can have kids, own a dog or horse etc yet you legally need a licence to catch a fish ;)
 
What about female dogs? Is it better to get the female done too? Thanks

It's alot more important to get the female done, she will ineviatebly egt as suggested by other users a pyometra when she is older, her seasons will become irregular and basically her uterus will fill with push, this puss is very toxic and can kill a bitch in the msot horrendous way, it's also a hell of alot more expensive to have the operation at this stage than a spay, so please get her done, also if the male is indeed stressing at the time next doors bitch is in season, then get him done, I never understand anyone who comments that thier dogs personality changes, I have neutered a heck of alot of dogs and I have no less than 9 dogs of my own ever:eek: and none have ever changed and non are over weight, my own vets(work) are over the moon with my rottis weight and very impressed she is the leanest rotti they have ver seen and they can use a normal X ray plate on her:rolleyes: cos she is not hefty as hell, dogs will never not want to exercise through neutering, they will gain weight, but thats why we reduce food, alot of these over weight neutered dogs, jsut as there are plenty of entire ones get too much food and not enough exercise.
 
Top