popsdosh
Well-Known Member
I think there is a difference between over handling and miss handling.
Over handling is miss handling!!
I think there is a difference between over handling and miss handling.
Over handling is miss handling!!
This. With the corollary being that someone who is good at handling will be able to see if what they are doing is benefiting the horse's behaviour and stop well before it becomes too much.Over handling is a form of poor handling .
Agree with this, plus the manner of the handling is vital imo. The people who bred my older Appy were real horsepeople, 'imprinted' but maintained disciplin at all times, the problems come with novices and the 'my little pony' mentality.This. With the corollary being that someone who is good at handling will be able to see if what they are doing is benefiting the horse's behaviour and stop well before it becomes too much.
But therein lies the crunch and I'm afraid I have to agree with Popdosh that the answers you have been given by the more professional of us (by that I mean those that earn their living from handling horses day in day out so know from experience what they are talking about) are not what you want to hear.
Nowadays with so many novices taking on and breaking their own youngsters, I would hazard a guess that less than 50% of them actually have the knowledge to do so which means an awful lot of horses are being badly handled and broken hence why you see so many posting about problems they are having which are totally elementary problems that would not have arisen if the animal concerned had not been over handled by someone who did not know what they were doing in the first place.
None of us mean they should run wild as in feral but that the minimum of teaching the basics which, well taught will last them all of their lives is totally sufficient; to do more runs the risk of them becoming too 'immune' and losing their respect for their handler. The old saying of don't ask a boy to do a man's work is as true for their state of mind as their limbs and it behoves everyone to proceed with caution unless you want to spoil them forever.
But what you're saying there doesn't contradict what I wrote - you as professionals are likely to get the difficult horses to deal with. The ones that have turned out well are likely to continue their training at home......
This is an interesting thread for a cold Sunday afternoon - I'd like to ask some advice.
Got a late 2014 foal still with mum (no weaning facilities so waiting until she can go back to stud) and haven't done much with him yet. He was unhandled at stud so he found it hard when he came here.
He now stands for the farrier (just!) and I lead him in and out to the field with his mum, although occasionally have got her in and gone back for him so he leads on his own for a short distance. He likes a good scratch but that's about all I do with him - should I do more?
In the field he has a couple of small 3 year olds to play with and gradually I have turned out some of the older geldings so they go out as a herd. I had intended to keep the geldings away but the herd seems to work - foal plays with the older geldings as well as the 3 yr olds and they are all very patient with him.
I wonder if it's mum keeping a beady eye on them that stops them being a bit tougher on him. He rarely stands with mum now but wanders off and pesters the others for long periods and I love watching the herd interacting. So when I take her away, is it likely the others will still be patient with him?
What I can't stand is seeing novice owners with young horses stabled rather than out in a herd environment. Then seeing these stabled horses being fed on buckets full of feed, stables full of every stable toy & lick known to man, rugged to the eyeballs, booted up, quarter marked, hoof oiled & plaited to walk up the lane, rubbed over with plastic bags and umberellas twice a day, and made to walk around some silly assault courses in the arena everyday. Just turn the bloody horse out in to a field to enjoy its self!!
This (again). Proper socialization is essential for young horses. The younger they are the more important it is, but the process goes on for years.Best not to overlook the role of the rest of the herd. During this time of 'minimal' handling, the young horse is learning much more from the other horses than a human can ever teach. They need to be out with well behaved, older horses whose attitude will rub off.
It's a terrible shame to label everyone who stables a young horse as a "novice"
I didn't label Everyone who stables a young horse as a novice!! I said I can't stand seeing novice owners with Young horses stabled!!
IMO and its only MY opinion if u can't keep a young horse as it should ideally be kept ie in a herd environment with others of a similar age and older babysitters until at least 2.5 years you shouldn't have a young horse. This does not mean out feral it means out but coming in for good quality, experienced, necessary handling
It's a terrible shame to label everyone who stables a young horse as a "novice"
I didn't label Everyone who stables a young horse as a novice!! I said I can't stand seeing novice owners with Young horses stabled!!
IMO and its only MY opinion if u can't keep a young horse as it should ideally be kept ie in a herd environment with others of a similar age and older babysitters until at least 2.5 years you shouldn't have a young horse. This does not mean out feral it means out but coming in for good quality, experienced, necessary handling
I do understand where you are coming from - however if you cant afford a ready-made horse, but equally dont have the 'ideal' facilities then are you saying everyone in this position should remain horseless forever?!
I have a rising 2 year old, bought when he was a yearling. I am fortunate enough to have him at a yard that offers grass livery so he lives out 24/7, however the only horse he can live out with is a rising 9 year old gelding who is not particularly well behaved - so there isnt a large herd for him to live with and the horse he lives out with isnt the greatest role model! However for a horse of his breeding there is NO WAY ON EARTH I could ever afford him once he gets to 3 or 4, I had to buy him as a yearling.
If we followed your theory I should not have purchased him and instead spent my small budget on what? I have ridden everything and anything put my way over the last few years, learnt loads but I want a serious dressage prospect and the only way to get something with quality is to buy a youngster. For the money I spent I could have purchased another horse, but it wouldnt have any quality breeding, would not have been a purpose bred dressage horse and I'm 99% certain it would have had many issues (behavioural and probably health) as almost all horses I see for low budgets have something wrong with them.
So I appreciate that youngsters do need careful handling and if we lived in an ideal world then they'd all be living out in a lovely big herd and growing up in the best possible way. But for those of us in the real world where we have to make small compromises we are doing the best we can - my boy is not stabled and has lived out all through the winter, and I was lucky enough to buy a yearling with a temperament to die for which has meant he has not picked up bad behaviour from the 9 year old, instead he is sensible enough to recognise the 9 year old is an idiot and he often leads him up the path from the field when 9 year old decides to have a special moment.
I am completely in agreement that overhandling is one of the worst things you can do for a youngster, my boy is markedly better behaved than the rising 3 year old that is living in a stable, bathed daily, hooves oiled, bandaged to go out for a walk etc. I've seen first hand the silly behaviour from overhandling with some of the youngsters on our yard (there are 2 3 year olds and my 2 year old - I'd love them to live out together but their owners would keel over at the thought of precious baby being out in the cold at night!).
Lets just all keep an open mind - daily handling in a fussy way (i.e. bandaging, bathing, loads of groundwork etc) is the most obvious cause of the problems. If you dont have facilities to have the horse living out then you can still have a well-mannered horse you just need to be careful of not doing too much beyond brining in/turning out. And if your youngster lives out then occasional handling is not going to be detrimental as long as its done properly.
My boy was handled a bit when I first got him (taught him how to tie up, lead, pick up feet etc), he learnt quickly so left him alone after that, havent done anything since apart from usual farrier/vaccs/worming etc, he still remembers everything from last year so I've left him alone over winter. He is miles away at the bottom of the field anyway, too far away to be messing around with in this weather!
One final thing to remember....everyone was a novice with youngsters once, we all have to start somewhere - this is my first youngster and I'm sure I'll make mistakes along the way but I have great supervision from Y/O who has bred horses for decades so providing you have support around you, I dont see why 'novices' cant buy a youngster if they cant afford the ready-made all singing all dancing version. I dont mean a 'novice' in the sense of someone who has never been near a youngster before or someone who wants a youngster as their first horse....I know there are some people that really should not be going near youngsters but for someone like myself, who has worked with horses before (only in my spare time at weekends) and has ridden every kind of problem horse going I dont see why buying a youngster is the wrong thing. In my situation it was the best option to get a quality horse that will be my forever horse.
I do understand where you are coming from - however if you cant afford a ready-made horse, but equally dont have the 'ideal' facilities then are you saying everyone in this position should remain horseless forever?!
I have a rising 2 year old, bought when he was a yearling. I am fortunate enough to have him at a yard that offers grass livery so he lives out 24/7, however the only horse he can live out with is a rising 9 year old gelding who is not particularly well behaved - so there isnt a large herd for him to live with and the horse he lives out with isnt the greatest role model! However for a horse of his breeding there is NO WAY ON EARTH I could ever afford him once he gets to 3 or 4, I had to buy him as a yearling.
If we followed your theory I should not have purchased him and instead spent my small budget on what? I have ridden everything and anything put my way over the last few years, learnt loads but I want a serious dressage prospect and the only way to get something with quality is to buy a youngster. For the money I spent I could have purchased another horse, but it wouldnt have any quality breeding, would not have been a purpose bred dressage horse and I'm 99% certain it would have had many issues (behavioural and probably health) as almost all horses I see for low budgets have something wrong with them.
So I appreciate that youngsters do need careful handling and if we lived in an ideal world then they'd all be living out in a lovely big herd and growing up in the best possible way. But for those of us in the real world where we have to make small compromises we are doing the best we can - my boy is not stabled and has lived out all through the winter, and I was lucky enough to buy a yearling with a temperament to die for which has meant he has not picked up bad behaviour from the 9 year old, instead he is sensible enough to recognise the 9 year old is an idiot and he often leads him up the path from the field when 9 year old decides to have a special moment.
I am completely in agreement that overhandling is one of the worst things you can do for a youngster, my boy is markedly better behaved than the rising 3 year old that is living in a stable, bathed daily, hooves oiled, bandaged to go out for a walk etc. I've seen first hand the silly behaviour from overhandling with some of the youngsters on our yard (there are 2 3 year olds and my 2 year old - I'd love them to live out together but their owners would keel over at the thought of precious baby being out in the cold at night!).
Lets just all keep an open mind - daily handling in a fussy way (i.e. bandaging, bathing, loads of groundwork etc) is the most obvious cause of the problems. If you dont have facilities to have the horse living out then you can still have a well-mannered horse you just need to be careful of not doing too much beyond brining in/turning out. And if your youngster lives out then occasional handling is not going to be detrimental as long as its done properly.
My boy was handled a bit when I first got him (taught him how to tie up, lead, pick up feet etc), he learnt quickly so left him alone after that, havent done anything since apart from usual farrier/vaccs/worming etc, he still remembers everything from last year so I've left him alone over winter. He is miles away at the bottom of the field anyway, too far away to be messing around with in this weather!
One final thing to remember....everyone was a novice with youngsters once, we all have to start somewhere - this is my first youngster and I'm sure I'll make mistakes along the way but I have great supervision from Y/O who has bred horses for decades so providing you have support around you, I dont see why 'novices' cant buy a youngster if they cant afford the ready-made all singing all dancing version. I dont mean a 'novice' in the sense of someone who has never been near a youngster before or someone who wants a youngster as their first horse....I know there are some people that really should not be going near youngsters but for someone like myself, who has worked with horses before (only in my spare time at weekends) and has ridden every kind of problem horse going I dont see why buying a youngster is the wrong thing. In my situation it was the best option to get a quality horse that will be my forever horse.
What an intelligent post.![]()
One final thing to remember....everyone was a novice with youngsters once, we all have to start somewhere -
While I totally agree with this (rest of post was very good too but this stood out for me) the pity nowadays is that far too many novice horse handlers are doing this without a clue how to plus many of those same people have the 'my little pony' attitude which is why we see so many bad mannered horses. It's not the horse's fault, it's the handlers.
While I totally agree with this (rest of post was very good too but this stood out for me) the pity nowadays is that far too many novice horse handlers are doing this without a clue how to plus many of those same people have the 'my little pony' attitude which is why we see so many bad mannered horses. It's not the horse's fault, it's the handlers.
Totally agree with you on this - the reason why I took the leap and bought my yearling was because I'd worked as a groom at weekends at a professional DR yard where I'd handled the rider's 2 and 3 year old's (who were cooped up 24/7!) and found the experience enjoyable, that gave me the confidence that I am capable enough to handle youngsters. Plus my Y/O is very experienced with breeding and handling youngsters so I have support from experienced people around me to help when I'm not sure what to do. Then I've bought a hell of a lot of books and read a lot online to top up what I already know - of course that doesnt prepare you for owning a youngster (especially when he decides to jump a huge metal gate out of the field and cause a huge injury!), but every little helps!
If I hadnt ever been near a youngster before and didnt have my Y/O around to help I wouldnt have done it - I'm sure in some people's eye's I've still not had enough experience to own a youngster but it felt like the right time to me and I've been lucky to choose very carefully based on breeding & temperament which has meant I have the best 2 year old ever and he is just a dream.
The people who treat them like babies are the worst, and these are often the ones that lunge their 2 year olds on tiny circles......takes all my strength to walk past our outdoor school sometimes and not shout at them!
Really interesting thread!!
Totally agree about over handling! I bought my lusitano foal last summer she came to me straight off mum at 6 months and spent 2 months on the livery my big mare is at. She was turned out with big mare and two other mares where I believe she learnt a lot about how to behave herself. In that time she was taught to lead, tie up, pick out feet had farrier and as when I got her she wouldn't let me past her tummy I got her in a month letting me touch her everywhere without batting an eyelid.
She was grumpy and bargy around her feed to start off with and she reprimanded in the same way big mare would be. We did a walk out on the roads and around the little show my yard had. We did loading and I basically installed the manners I expect my big mare to have.
I then last November shipped her down to Devon to live out on 20 acres with a herd of 6 including matriarchal maresup until 2 weeks ago she was out 24/7 but it was noted she had a massive a growth spurt and dropped A LOT of weight so she is in at night now until the grass comes through then back out. And guess what I am happy to report that she is still the same lovely mannered young lady she was when she left
![]()
I am happy to admit that I am a novice youngster owner. Pearl is my first baby and my reasons for that was I lost my other mare due to too much to soon and I wanted a blank canvas. She is a year old next week and well over 15hh she is going to be a big girl and where she is the people looking after her are very experienced and I know when she comes home she will come home a lovely animal to be around because of their correct handling.
I don't think people just send horses away to professionals because they have messed up. I have already sent mine to professionals because I want a lovely riding horse in the future. I also know I won't back her she will be sent away for that or I will have a professional come to me. Again because I want a lovely a riding horse and I am not willing to allow my own novice self to mess her up![]()
With your attitude there's no way you're going to mess up.
There are some experienced people on this thread, so I was just hoping to get an answer on this (if ok!)
I take my rising 4 yr old for 2x short weekly walks down a quiet lane to get used to sights and sounds and the odd car that passes us. So far so good. However, I feel that I may be creating a future issue.
On the way home, she really picks up the pace, but never leaves my side -I just have to walk quicker!. She just wants to get home quicker.
She is led in a bridle with couplings.
I have tried leading her out with my very steady retired horse, but it doesn't make any difference, she still tries to jog until I slow her back down to walk.
Do I ask her to stop to compose herself when she speeds up, or turn her and do a few steps away from home, then forward again?.
I do not have a hacking buddy (on own yard) so I need her to be confident going out on her own for when I start hacking her, but I want good experiences for her at the same time.
Any input appreciated.