Cody James Hoof Rasp Review

PurBee

Well-Known Member
Joined
23 November 2019
Messages
5,791
Visit site
I decided to try the Cody James rasps recently, as i’ve always been disappointed with how quickly the sharpness goes of traditional leading brand rasps.

Cody is a farrier and was equally annoyed at the traditional design so went ahead and deisgned a completely different rasp.
Judging by positive reviews all over the net, i decided to buy one in ‘medium’ rasp. There’s a ‘fine’, ‘medium’ and ‘aggressive’ file to choose from. The rasps are set into a steel holder, so once youve bought the whole rasp - you only have to buy replacement teeth mesh to insert into your existing cage.
Here’s a pic:

1618242612559.jpeg

So my review is basically = it’s brilliant!

The teeth design criss cross so you get many more teeth per square inch compared to traditional rasps:

1618242689919.jpeg
The tooth design are like thin hooks instead of oval ’cups’ of traditional rasps - and due to the different tooth design, it makes running the rasp along the hoof wall much easier, shaving off much more per stroke.

Also the filings can fall through the diamond rasp matrix of teeth so the teeth never clog.

Many reviewers commented that they’re not very physically strong in the arms/wrists and find it so easy to use this design compared to traditional designs. Although im strong-armed, i still found this rasp much easier on my wrists and arms - managed to do 6 feet in 1 session! Normally all the bending over and heavy rasping im wanting to quit after 2 feet and push to 4 - but 6 feet was easy and if it wasnt for having to quit due to other stuff, i would have happily carried on doing 8 feet without a break! That really is something as traditional rasps have me loathing trimming due to them blunting so quickly and i practically have to buy them annually, i use 2 a year for just 2 horses.

The downside for those with particularly weak wrists/strength - the rasps are wider and longer than traditional rasps. I was surprised to receive mine and instantly thought ‘wow thats big!’ - but they are a bit lighter than traditional rasps.
Cody = 560grams
Traditional = 630grams
However, upon use, and adjusting my rasping style to just glide rather than press and push/pull, i’ve got used to the size/weight of this rasp.
The first try i was miffed about the size, but the fact it rasps so easily, and remains so sharp, the size of it doesn’t matter.

112078E8-0B30-477A-8BE7-961A9D84C497.jpeg

They do a ‘half size’ version for those wanting something very compact.

If you want a rasp to just tidy up flares, roll the walls, i’d recommend the ‘fine’ rasp teeth. The medium teeth are so sharp that they ‘catch’ the outer wall when hoof held facing you and you want to run along the outer side wall. You have to use really fine light sweeping action to shave bits off. Any pressure added and the teeth catch, so ’fine‘ rasp teeth would be best for that job. I still have to get used to the sharpness and might fine my technique improves to do outer wall with medium teeth. The medium would work best on outer wall flare if you rasped the wall flare straight on with the hoof right way up on a hoof stand - if you use that method.

Im thinking about buying the ‘little foot’ rasp in fine teeth to use soley as a side wall rasp:


1618244789452.jpeg


I’m highly encouraged by professional farrier reviews saying they get many times use out of these compared to other rasps. Certainly having used them, i can see how they would. The sharpness has not dulled at all from the use i’ve given mine, whereas brand new ones would have with the tiny grit hooves are prone to picking up.

I’m so chuffed with them, i just had to share this with all of you who have found, especially during lockdown, you’ve rolled up your sleeves and attempted to trim your own. This new design IS an improvement on traditional rasps. I rarely do reviews as most things are gimmicks, but i have to hand it to Cody James, his design far outweighs for ease of use and performance of any other rasp on the market. I’ve bought and used most leading rasp brands over the years. Theyre all the same really. None truly out-shines another with the ‘cup’ teeth design.

The best bit is - you can use this rasp on the muddiest, grittiest feet and they don’t blunt! Not that we ever do trim feet this muddy but the video shows it doesnt clog and will still rasp in extreme conditions:


I bought mine from uk amazon with free prime delivery. Best price i could find. I dont make any profit by recommending this website or brand - i am purely doing an unbiased review as its worthy of one!
 

Tiddlypom

Carries on creakily
Joined
17 July 2013
Messages
23,880
Location
In between the Midlands and the North
Visit site
I've the dymondback rasps too, in fine and medium. Brilliant things - very effective, and they don't clog up.

That's a good price from Amazon, think I'll get an aggressive rasp to complete my set.

I finish off by running a Radius Rasp Pro round to leave a smooth bevelled finish, which might be cheating a bit, but it works for me :).
 

PurBee

Well-Known Member
Joined
23 November 2019
Messages
5,791
Visit site
Great review... as I'm getting older, speed is of the essence before my back gives in completely

The speed i was able to do 1 hoof in comparison to the usual rasp was amazing. I’d begun to loathe trimming, mainly due to blunting rasps!... but this has really made it more a joy again! I didnt even have aching shoulder/biceps/wrist the next day either which really is fabulous, showing im not having to use as much muscle to get the job done.

They dont require much pressure to use, so initially i started off using it like a normal rasp, and it sticking a lot....then i adjusted to lighter strokes to get the rasp moving, and thats the technique that works best. With blunt rasps they require quite a bit of pressure, huffing and puffing...and im so happy those days are long gone! ??
 
Last edited:

ycbm

Einstein would be proud of my Insanity...
Joined
30 January 2015
Messages
58,796
Visit site
Thanks for that. I have two spares to get through but I'll be trying that after they've gone, I'm finding rasping feet hard as I get older.
 

tallyho!

Following a strict mediterranean diet...
Joined
8 July 2010
Messages
14,951
Visit site
It’s always my shoulder and lower back and thought I had the Heller or diamond but ok I might try this.
 

TPO

Well-Known Member
Joined
20 November 2008
Messages
9,997
Location
Kinross
Visit site
My back is ruined and even light rasping leaves me crippled.

The whole thing isn't helped by the cob having the hardest hooves ever. He blunts every rasp and they barely make a dent on his hooves.

I'd been toying with the idea of one of these rasps and @Tiddlypom 's reviews encouraged me. I bought mine from Amazon prime too.

Meanwhile I found a new farrier who's a massive improvement on previous two trimmers (did have a good trimmer originally but she stopped travelling dec 2019) so the urgency for me to go back trimming is gone. Regardless I tried out the rasp on cobs hooves and wow!

I have the medium grade and it made light work of cob's hooves. Much better than any traditional rasps I've ever used including high end brands
 

PurBee

Well-Known Member
Joined
23 November 2019
Messages
5,791
Visit site
I'm new to trimming, I doubt that I could hack it with a traditional rasp. These make it pretty easy work.

The dymondbacks are very sharp to handle, though, if you catch the rasp side on bare skin. Make sure that you have some decent gloves.

Good point TP, ? i forgot to mention gloves are quite essential with these unless youre super skilled at throwing rasps across hooves like seasoned farriers. I caught my gloves with this rasp and was thankful id remembered to put them on.
 

PurBee

Well-Known Member
Joined
23 November 2019
Messages
5,791
Visit site
My back is ruined and even light rasping leaves me crippled.

The whole thing isn't helped by the cob having the hardest hooves ever. He blunts every rasp and they barely make a dent on his hooves.

I'd been toying with the idea of one of these rasps and @Tiddlypom 's reviews encouraged me. I bought mine from Amazon prime too.

Meanwhile I found a new farrier who's a massive improvement on previous two trimmers (did have a good trimmer originally but she stopped travelling dec 2019) so the urgency for me to go back trimming is gone. Regardless I tried out the rasp on cobs hooves and wow!

I have the medium grade and it made light work of cob's hooves. Much better than any traditional rasps I've ever used including high end brands

Glad you liked them too TPO - i was pleasantly surprised when the rasp made light work on the harder hooves of my horses fronts...such a difference i just had to review.

Sorry i missed your review TP - if i had caught that im sure id have bought them earlier! Exasperated, the other week i googled ‘best farrier rasp’ and cody james came up. What a find...am super pleased! ?
 

Tiddlypom

Carries on creakily
Joined
17 July 2013
Messages
23,880
Location
In between the Midlands and the North
Visit site
That's a good price from Amazon, think I'll get an aggressive rasp to complete my set.
Just to update and to add to the review :). I did buy an 'aggressive' grade rasp (which is a scary sounding description) from Amazon, and I used it today for the first time.

I trimmed 8 x feet, inc the IDx, and it was brilliant. It only needs a light touch, and it does the job easily without taking chunks of foot off. Today I only needed to use the aggressive rasp, the radius rasp pro (for finishing) and the hoof knife (to remove a couple of ragged ends of dead frog).

I also have a pair of good hoof nippers, but I've never yet needed or wanted to use them.
 

PurBee

Well-Known Member
Joined
23 November 2019
Messages
5,791
Visit site
Just to update and to add to the review :). I did buy an 'aggressive' grade rasp (which is a scary sounding description) from Amazon, and I used it today for the first time.

I trimmed 8 x feet, inc the IDx, and it was brilliant. It only needs a light touch, and it does the job easily without taking chunks of foot off. Today I only needed to use the aggressive rasp, the radius rasp pro (for finishing) and the hoof knife (to remove a couple of ragged ends of dead frog).

I also have a pair of good hoof nippers, but I've never yet needed or wanted to use them.

Thanks for the update tp, i did wonder if the aggressive would be ‘too much’ rasp for me! I’ll definitely be getting the whole set of different grades. I’m still really enjoying the medium rasp. It’s hilarious - i look at it with fondness, unlike the snarly glances my other rasps would get! ?
 

Red-1

I used to be decisive, now I'm not so sure...
Joined
7 February 2013
Messages
18,370
Location
Outstanding in my field!
Visit site
Thank you, Rigsby's feet are like rocks, I have ordered the fine one as I do them a couple of times a week and thought the fine would take enough off.
 

Reacher

Well-Known Member
Joined
24 February 2010
Messages
9,041
Visit site
Very interesting review thanks - my 2 blunt my rasp and their feet grow like mad - i had been considering buying nippers but these sound like an alternative idea
 

PurBee

Well-Known Member
Joined
23 November 2019
Messages
5,791
Visit site
Thank you, Rigsby's feet are like rocks, I have ordered the fine one as I do them a couple of times a week and thought the fine would take enough off.

Let us know how you find the fine grade rasp on hard feet, i’m yet to try the fine.
 

PurBee

Well-Known Member
Joined
23 November 2019
Messages
5,791
Visit site
I use these. They are a quarter of the price and look to be the same

https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/284032372479

That’s a really similar blade design! Great find!
It’s a lot smaller than the cody, but perfect for those that find the cody too large/heavy. I might order one of those as a comparison.

Overall i think that blade design is best for hoof rasps than the traditional ’cup shaped’ teeth of traditional rasps.
 

PurBee

Well-Known Member
Joined
23 November 2019
Messages
5,791
Visit site
Very interesting review thanks - my 2 blunt my rasp and their feet grow like mad - i had been considering buying nippers but these sound like an alternative idea

I dont get on well with nippers, due to lack of practice really. Theyre ideal for taking off majority length rather than be rasping for ages With a traditional rasp. Yet the cody medium for me, made light work of taking off my mare’s seasonal growth spurt, so a good option if you dont use nippers.
 

paddy555

Well-Known Member
Joined
23 December 2010
Messages
13,654
Visit site
I use these. They are a quarter of the price and look to be the same

https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/284032372479

I have a shinto and it is fine for taking half a dozen strokes over the toe but I wouldn't like to trim the whole foot with it. I don't find it anything like as accurate or with the same degree of finesse as an ordinary rasp. I am not sure what you do to round the wall edges, presumably you need another rasp for that?.

If the cody is similar in principle to the shinto then I think I wouldn't get on with it.

I use nippers rather than endless rasping as it is a lot less hard work.

There was a comment somewhere about grit hooves pick up blunting rasps. A good wire brush around stops that problem. Rasps are far too expensive to blunt with grit.
 

PurBee

Well-Known Member
Joined
23 November 2019
Messages
5,791
Visit site
I have a shinto and it is fine for taking half a dozen strokes over the toe but I wouldn't like to trim the whole foot with it. I don't find it anything like as accurate or with the same degree of finesse as an ordinary rasp. I am not sure what you do to round the wall edges, presumably you need another rasp for that?.

If the cody is similar in principle to the shinto then I think I wouldn't get on with it.

I use nippers rather than endless rasping as it is a lot less hard work.

There was a comment somewhere about grit hooves pick up blunting rasps. A good wire brush around stops that problem. Rasps are far too expensive to blunt with grit.

Ive ordered a shinto so will review that here when ive tried it.

the shinto has coarse one side, and fine teeth on the other side, so im expecting the fine side to be able to deal with the wall edges....we’ll see.

The issue with grit, in my climate, is the hooves are rarely bone dry to make the use of a wire brush useful. The moisture and grit means the wire brush just swirls the grit around without brushing it off. So i’ve before now, got a bucket of water, brush, wash each foot while ive got it held, to remove grit, then rasp....just to preserve the sharpness of my rasps!

I’m on a hardcore base, which has a pea gravel/grit layer - rather than cleaned brushed concrete. Inside their barn with rubber mats is too dark to rasp without headtorch, but if i walk them in there, the grit on their feet, tiny teeny pieces like sand im talking, still would need washing off, drenching their bedding.

I cant be using tools that are so delicate that sand-like particles blunts them, especially dealing with feet of outdoor animals like horses. The cody isnt so easily blunted, so im a convert.

Youre lucky to be adept with nippers - that would help massively - hopefully one day i’ll get to grips with them.
 

paddy555

Well-Known Member
Joined
23 December 2010
Messages
13,654
Visit site
i don't find the fine side of the shinto gives anything like the quality of finish that the fine side of a rasp does. I also have a wet climate and a lot of grit and sand. I never wash the feet, I dry towel them underneath. That way they are dry to wire brush.
 

PurBee

Well-Known Member
Joined
23 November 2019
Messages
5,791
Visit site
I've just ordered a Shinto too. I was thinking about a Cody James but the price was putting me off. I only need to do a small amount with it so hoping it will do the job.

Let us know how you get on with it. It sounds perfect for the smaller, more refined rasping jobs.
The cody price made me gulp a bit but now i have it, and the size of the blade being really large, means it’s the size of 3 shinto blades. Perfect if taking off a lot or doing more than one horse.
My shinto will arrive soon so eager to give it a whirl ?
 

Errin Paddywack

Well-Known Member
Joined
20 June 2019
Messages
6,869
Location
West Midlands
Visit site
I have now had my Shinto rasp for a week or so and am delighted with it. I haven't done much with it yet, just a bit off the inner edge of her hoof but it was so easy. I held hoof in one hand and ran rasp across the side that was flaring out. Most effective rasp I have ever had. My sister has now ordered one as so impressed.
 

PurBee

Well-Known Member
Joined
23 November 2019
Messages
5,791
Visit site
I have now had my Shinto rasp for a week or so and am delighted with it. I haven't done much with it yet, just a bit off the inner edge of her hoof but it was so easy. I held hoof in one hand and ran rasp across the side that was flaring out. Most effective rasp I have ever had. My sister has now ordered one as so impressed.

ER - thanks for the reminder to update about using the shinto rasp!

As you said, its great for swiping off side-wall wonkiness and ’mustang roll’ finishes.
BUT,
in comparison to the Cody...it took me ages to do a full trim with it.
In fact, i threw it down and reached for the Cody!

The difference is the size and weight. On the Cody you have a much wider/longer larger blade, so per stroke you’re taking off loads.
Also the Cody is weighty, and the shinto very lightweight. This aspect is important with rasps as the weight allows you to just push the rasp. The lightweight Shinto had me pressing down and pushing to get it to rasp any decent amount off, which soon fatigues the wrists. This was with a brand new sharp shinto blade, so i dread it blunting already.

The comparison of the teeth of the 2 blades was very similar in size - but performance differed. Medium Cody blade V Shinto large teeth (the shinto has fine teeth on the other side....but that really is for minute fine polishing work imo)

I kept trying with the shinto to do main wall rasping, but much prefer the Cody for speed, ease, and also accuracy as it lays evenly/squarely across the hoof, allowing a much even rasp all round.
The Cody blade is double the width of the shinto.
I’ll upload a size comparison pic later.

The Shinto, in comparison to Cody, for speed and ease of trimming main wall is far inferior.
For tidying-up edges of hoof, or rasping small hooves like shetlands would be more suited, so i’m glad i have it for side-wall work as the cody is large!
The shinto would be good for a beginner to trimming to use as its lightweight, easy to handle - but the wrist work required to get a full hoof done would soon have a well-practiced beginner wanting something more substantial to complete a quicker/easier full trim of 4 feet.
 

Red-1

I used to be decisive, now I'm not so sure...
Joined
7 February 2013
Messages
18,370
Location
Outstanding in my field!
Visit site
I have used the Cody fine one. Not sure I would pay the extra again. I mean, it does better than my old one, but then my old one is... old... so I would expect it to do better.

It also leaves grooves that I then use the old one to smooth off!
 

paddy555

Well-Known Member
Joined
23 December 2010
Messages
13,654
Visit site
ER - thanks for the reminder to update about using the shinto rasp!

As you said, its great for swiping off side-wall wonkiness and ’mustang roll’ finishes.
BUT,
in comparison to the Cody...it took me ages to do a full trim with it.
In fact, i threw it down and reached for the Cody!

The difference is the size and weight. On the Cody you have a much wider/longer larger blade, so per stroke you’re taking off loads.
Also the Cody is weighty, and the shinto very lightweight. This aspect is important with rasps as the weight allows you to just push the rasp. The lightweight Shinto had me pressing down and pushing to get it to rasp any decent amount off, which soon fatigues the wrists. This was with a brand new sharp shinto blade, so i dread it blunting already.

The comparison of the teeth of the 2 blades was very similar in size - but performance differed. Medium Cody blade V Shinto large teeth (the shinto has fine teeth on the other side....but that really is for minute fine polishing work imo)

I kept trying with the shinto to do main wall rasping, but much prefer the Cody for speed, ease, and also accuracy as it lays evenly/squarely across the hoof, allowing a much even rasp all round.
The Cody blade is double the width of the shinto.
I’ll upload a size comparison pic later.

The Shinto, in comparison to Cody, for speed and ease of trimming main wall is far inferior.
For tidying-up edges of hoof, or rasping small hooves like shetlands would be more suited, so i’m glad i have it for side-wall work as the cody is large!
The shinto would be good for a beginner to trimming to use as its lightweight, easy to handle - but the wrist work required to get a full hoof done would soon have a well-practiced beginner wanting something more substantial to complete a quicker/easier full trim of 4 feet.

that's all what I found. I would drop dead with exhaustion after one horse and I usually do 2 or 3 at the same time. I thought the Shinto was great the first couple of times I used it on the toe wall but it very soon went blunt.
 

paddy555

Well-Known Member
Joined
23 December 2010
Messages
13,654
Visit site
I have used the Cody fine one. Not sure I would pay the extra again. I mean, it does better than my old one, but then my old one is... old... so I would expect it to do better.

It also leaves grooves that I then use the old one to smooth off!


the price really puts me off trying the Cody. I would need a fine one and a more aggressive one so that is 2 rasps and having to change rasps rather than just flipping it over. I wouldn't like grooves.
The blades seem very expensive at £57.
A single save edge on equine podiatry is £27.

I buy by the box and I can get 2.5 save edge rasps including post for one Cody blade.

It is nothing to do with the rasps but one thing that puts me off is the Cody video. They smear the foot with mud and them start rasping a mucky foot. I like to have the foot immaculately clean and brushed out so that I can see every tiny deviation, hole or anything else before I start.
 
Top