Rodolfo E.
Active Member
Hi guys, I'm new to the forum, I'm getting reacquainted to jumping after 16 years
and kind of excited about it lately. So much that I bought a new bates caprilli close contact saddle.
English is my second language so please bear with me.
I've had many great western saddles over the years but this is my very first english saddle; 16 years ago I used to borrow trained horses and saddles from friends or barns.
The reason I'm posting this is to ask you guys who have had much more experience on saddles how normal is it for them to get stitching, stirrup leathers and billet markings and scratches after the first half an hour ride?
I know it was not going to look like new forever but after spending the money on all the necessary equipment, from saddle pad to stirrup leathers, to girth, to saddle; I must admit I feel kind of let down by the quality of the leather and I'm beginning to wonder if the saddle is going to last much.
I wish I could send pictures but I don't really know how.
When you look at the leather bates uses in their saddles from pictures It looks good, that is why I ordered it after reading many reviews on them and prioritizing on quality/price value. After receiving the saddle I noticed the leather they use on the flaps has, or at least they look as if they had a plastic like coating but I didn't pay much attention to that since I was dying to use it.
I went through the mandatory bates conditioning with their own balsam, which came with the saddle. left it on all night and I buffed it the next morning.
I rode on it for half an hour at the most, and it got all kind of markings. the worst ones are under the skirt, the flap that covers the stirrup bars, it got marked by the saddle's own stichings to the point that it peeled off or chipped off the saddle flap's coating forming the pattern of the skirt's stitching on it.
I bought this saddle from Dover Saddlery a big tack store in the US and they are supposed to have excellent return policies, I wouldn't know because it's the first time I buy from them.
The question is, is this normal? Or should I dover a call and return it?
Thank you very much for your patience and advise guys.
English is my second language so please bear with me.
I've had many great western saddles over the years but this is my very first english saddle; 16 years ago I used to borrow trained horses and saddles from friends or barns.
The reason I'm posting this is to ask you guys who have had much more experience on saddles how normal is it for them to get stitching, stirrup leathers and billet markings and scratches after the first half an hour ride?
I know it was not going to look like new forever but after spending the money on all the necessary equipment, from saddle pad to stirrup leathers, to girth, to saddle; I must admit I feel kind of let down by the quality of the leather and I'm beginning to wonder if the saddle is going to last much.
I wish I could send pictures but I don't really know how.
When you look at the leather bates uses in their saddles from pictures It looks good, that is why I ordered it after reading many reviews on them and prioritizing on quality/price value. After receiving the saddle I noticed the leather they use on the flaps has, or at least they look as if they had a plastic like coating but I didn't pay much attention to that since I was dying to use it.
I went through the mandatory bates conditioning with their own balsam, which came with the saddle. left it on all night and I buffed it the next morning.
I rode on it for half an hour at the most, and it got all kind of markings. the worst ones are under the skirt, the flap that covers the stirrup bars, it got marked by the saddle's own stichings to the point that it peeled off or chipped off the saddle flap's coating forming the pattern of the skirt's stitching on it.
I bought this saddle from Dover Saddlery a big tack store in the US and they are supposed to have excellent return policies, I wouldn't know because it's the first time I buy from them.
The question is, is this normal? Or should I dover a call and return it?
Thank you very much for your patience and advise guys.