Looking for help/ideas on what is going on with my collie.

Status
Not open for further replies.

p87

Well-Known Member
Joined
10 March 2013
Messages
724
Location
Central Scotland
Visit site
This is very long, please bear with me!

I have a female border collie, 3 years old. Before I am hit with the usual 'she isn't exercised enough' comments that I see on 90% of collie related posts, yes she gets plenty of exercise and that has nothing to do with it. She is very happy out on walks and shows none of what I am concerned about while out on a walk. Although I honestly don't believe a collie can ever have 'enough' exercise, I would love to borrow some of her energy for myself :)

About a year ago she developed a limp on her right hind, she wouldn't put her foot on the ground at all. We couldn't find ANYTHING physically wrong and she was given painkillers as she was obviously in pain. They didn't seem to do anything and it went away after a couple of months. She wasn't hopping lame this whole time - she would go through phases of being hopping lame, just looking a bit stiff and being completely fine.

A year on it's started again, same as the above, though this time she is yelping in pain while she is hopping lame. But again, one minute she is in clear excruciating pain, and the next is 100% fine, bounding around, her usual self. She has gone off her food (fussy eater anyway, read on to see why) and is being sick more than a few times a week. No blood or bits of food, more like bile.

In the past 6 months or so she has become unbelievably needy, and has gradually turned into a nervous wreck. She won't even make eye contact, she looks away as if she has been caught doing something wrong. She snarls at people she has known all her life, though doesn't make any noise, just lip curls, but as soon as she is given a clap she is fine again. I don't condone this behaviour whatsoever, I don't want her thinking she has to snarl to get attention, so when she does it people are told to ignore her until she stops, which she does after a couple of minutes.
She slinks and creeps around the place, like she is tip toeing so as not to be heard, and to be perfectly honest if you saw her you would think she is abused from the way she is behaving. She does this thing where if someone comes in who she loves and is desperate to speak to she will curl her lip, wag her tail, have a pleading 'please touch me' look in her eyes and make a strange chirping noise - all at the same time. When she eventually creeps over while doing all of this she will bury her head in the person and lie all of her weight on them, as if something terrible has just happened and she is 'leaning' on them for safety. So she is showing all the signs of nervousness, fear, happiness and excitement all at once. It's bizarre to watch.

She isn't abused, neglected or had an accident or a frightening experience. She lives in the family home with myself and my three year old, with my boyfriend staying over a couple of nights a week. She doesn't snarl at me or my son, but will at my boyfriend (who she has known for most of her life) if she hasn't seen him in a while. She is then visibly devastated when he ignores her and promptly stops it. She is well socialised with people and other animals, and only behaves like this when people approach HER.
She won't leave her bed unless it's to go out, she doesn't behave like a normal dog any more, it's like she doesn't want to be part of the family.

It's suddenly got EXTREME. She is a completely different dog to the one she was a year ago. She doesn't even prick her ears up with excitement any more or look remotely interested in anything. Her eyes say - nervous, unhappy, dull.

The only thing I can think of that may have triggered it is about a year ago I stopped a couple of friends from taking her walks. They would take her quite a lot, treated her as if I neglected her and completely spoiled her. I am fairly strict with her, I don't allow jumping up, pulling on the lead, running off wherever she likes on walks, sitting on furniture, I expect her to follow a command on the first command, not think it's hysterical that she is ignoring me etc and when she went out with them she was sickeningly babied and allowed to do whatever she wanted. They fed her full of utter rubbish, to the point that she stopped eating her dog food and essentially starved herself so she could binge when she went out with them - at Greggs apparently. Hence why now she has become a fussy eater. I explained this to them and made it clear she was not to be fed a single thing except from me, but as soon as I mentioned the fact she was starving herself until she saw them that made me the bad guy again and so she was fed even more.

She was allowed up on furniture, allowed to jump up on people, allowed to sit on the car seats WHINING with excitement about where she was going - basically everything I asked them not to allow was ignored. I don't think I am being mean, but dogs need discipline, and they need to know their place within the family and around humans. Two years worth of work from when I got her as a pup was completely destroyed. She wouldn't even come to my call any more, and when I spoke to her she would turn her head away from me and blatantly ignore me. She started rolling on her back and peeing whenever I spoke to her as if she was expecting to be battered - I have never lifted my hand to her - and would NOT move from off the floor.

Her behaviour got so appalling I put a stop to them taking her out, after several ignored warnings. As far as I'm concerned I done the right thing, everyone was so shocked at how badly behaved she had become, it was so noticeable.
This was when the constant whining, crying and refusing to leave her bed started. The way I see it is she had been given a taster of the life she preferred and so refused to be 'my' dog any more. This was over a year ago, so surely by now she should be getting over it, if that is the cause behind all of this?

I went back to square one with the training, having to start from scratch after all my hard work was devastating. We used to be stopped out on walks by 9 people out of 10 to be complimented on how well behaved she was, people would even ask where I got her professionally trained, so you can imagine my upset at having to start all over again - this is how bad she had become.
She DOES see me as her master again, she is back to being a good, well behaved, (almost!) impeccably trained dog and she protects us. She knows her place in the family and apart from when she is having these nervous wreck episodes she seems happy. It's almost as if she has periods of being her happy self and the rest of the time she behaves like an abused and neglected bag of nerves.

We can't see anything physically wrong with her, even though she is off her food she isn't losing any weight. She has been given a calmer (to help with nerves) and something to line her stomach in case she maybe has an ulcer (being sick, off her food, fidgets a lot as if she is uncomfortable or sore). The vet can't find anything which could be causing the severe lameness. I've wondered if maybe she has a knot or something in her back which is intermittently pressing on a nerve to make her so lame? Looking at the way she behaves when she slinks/creeps/snarls/wags her tail/chirps all at once I'm thinking there might be something neurologically wrong? It is the strangest thing and I've never seen it before.

I genuinely believe that this is a mental issue, not a physical one. I think it is behavioural since it all started after I stopped my friends taking her out, but instead of getting better she is getting worse.

Has anyone got any ideas or been through similar? I've to take her back to the vet in three weeks and if there is no improvement then we will go down the route of scoping/x-rays, testing for food intolerances and whatnot. She doesn't need to see a behaviourist, I am perfectly capable of training her and having her behave by myself, these are just random episodes she is having. And I am certainly not going down the route of having her get attached to another person for fear of what happened with my friends happening again. She doesn't get to pick and choose who she prefers and behave accordingly with each person!

Sorry for such a long post, but I am at my wits end with it all! I'm hoping someone might be able to help!
 
I'm not sure if these photos might help, the first one is her before all of this started over a year ago, she was the happiest, most content wee thing, ears always pricked and so full of the life

274_zps8993fbc1.jpg


The second one is an example of the strange things she does now. I had been calling on her to go out for a pee and I found her pressed up against the wall like this. She wouldn't look at me, it was creepy.

072_zpsd6e5f190.jpg


She is not aggressive in the slightest, when she is curling her lip at people she looks at me as if to say "I don't mean to be doing this but I can't stop it" she has only ever snapped at me once, but that was long before any of this started. I have a three year old child, so if she was at all aggressive she would be gone, it just would not be worth the risk.

She is a good dog, she takes her role of looking after my son very seriously. If he is out playing in the garden she goes with him and if anyone stops to talk to him over the fence (or he tries to make a run for it out the gate!) she barks until I come out to see what is going on. When he was a baby she would put herself between anyone who came up to talk to him and the buggy until she felt they were OK and would step aside. When he was learning to walk/run if he strayed too far away out a walk she would circle him and herd him back to me - I even tested this once by running a bit away form them (in a deserted field!) and calling on her, she wouldn't leave his side.

She protects me too. She is terrified of the horses but one day I was poo picking in the field, something spooked them and they came charging towards me. While I stood there laughing and looking for my camera she ran out from her hiding spot in the hedge, put herself between me and the horses and barked at them until they turned and fled back the way they had just come! She's not a barker either, when she does bark you know there is something to be taken notice of.

It's horrible seeing such a drastic change in her.
 
She is beautiul.
I'm sure people more experienced than me will reply but if she is in constant, even low grade pain, could that not effect her whole demeanor? If Ihave a tooth ache I am grumpy all over.
 
My first thought is that she is in pain, and if she has been in pain for some time that could be making her behave like this.
If she was mine I would be taking her back to the vets, maybe even a different vet for a second opinion as she clearly isn't right.

The strange behaviour she is exhibiting could well be related to the pain - eg maybe she snarls her lip because she is in pain and although is excited to see someone associates them stroking her with more pain?

It might be worth consulting a very good behaviourist if you rule everything out physically, just to be sure you aren't accidentally reinforcing the behaviours and to just get an outside pair of eyes.
 
Personally, my first thought is that everything doesn't have to be connected to each other, maybe they are, but maybe there is several unrelated things behind her problems.

Had you lived in Sweden, my first advise would have been to check her for any of the diseases that they can get from ticks. When I read about the problem with her right hind, it made me think of two things. Both about a time a few years ago, when one of my bitches sprained a toe. She also had symptoms that came and went a little, and for some months after that she was well again, she could have days when she inexplicably could take some limping steps now and then. It also made me think of, that extra bone growth on the spine or somewhere else, can cause problems that comes and goes, depending on whether the bone growth pinches or not.

I'm also thinking that if it turns out to be something that have gone mentally wrong with her, then it wouldn't be the first time I've heard of a smart dog with mental problems. Smart dogs can be incredible, but sometimes it is as if they think too much.

She looks like such a sweet dog (the second photo really tugs at my heart strings), I wish I could do more than just hope that you and the veterinarian can find something that solves her problem.
 
pain can do terrible things.What sort of investigation has the vet done? has she had xrays taken? bloods? full neurological exam? shes screaming pain to me from ur description. .weather spinal joint or something unusual like meningitis it could hard to know...
 
Thanks everyone for your replies, and thanks to those who have PM'd me, I will get round to replying!

I think it's a unanimous verdict that she is in pain, and even though we haven't found anything as of yet - she has only had physical exams, no bloods etc yet - I think I should give the vet a call and say to go ahead with more extensive tests, I don't want to leave her three weeks on the calmer and the stomach liner as I really don't think that's the problem.
I'm worried that it could be something neurological, but it would explain such strange behaviour. It's interesting samlf that you mentioned she could be associating being touched with pain and this would explain the lip curling.

She could have done something simple like tweak her back while haring around out on a walk, it's gone unnoticed and could now have caused more problems for her. The woman who does my horses backs is fab and she does dogs so so I'm wondering if I should get her out to give her a once over and see if she can find anything wrong with her back. She might have a knot or something pressing on a nerve which could explain why she gets so severely lame at completely random times. A good deep massage could be very beneficial as it would knock her out and keep her calm for a while!
 
Did she undergo x-rays?

My own view is that yes it's probably pain related. I would suspect a cancer that has now progressed to her brain.

Sorry if that sounds totally ott. But those are my thoughts.
 
Funnily enough AmyMay I have been thinking it's a brain tumour or similar. But being a complete over-reactor at the best of times I've told myself not to be so stupid, but it's still in the back of my mind. I can't explain how drastic and bizarre the change in her is.

She has had nothing done yet except physical exams, as the severe lameness comes and goes and nothing can physically be found anywhere on her body to explain it. And with the behavioural side of it, because it started around about the time I stopped my friends from taking her out I assumed this was just her way of showing how unhappy she was at not getting to see them any more. So I persevered with re-training her etc but a year on and it's much, much worse, no better, so I'm now going down the line of thinking that something is seriously wrong.
 
That sounds like a good idea. Collies can be very difficult when they get something into their heads! I know, I have two myself!

A friend of mine has had and bred collies for over 30 years, she was telling me about her first collie puppy many years ago. Happy and healthy normal puppy. All of a sudden completely refused to eat for over a week. Took him to vet who checked him and said hes fine just being temperamental, keep offering food but take it up if not eaten. Anyway this continued for a little while longer, and after trial and error they realised he actually didn't like being fed in the same room at their landline phone. As soon as they fed him in another room, or took the phone away he was fine. The poor dog almost starved himself for no reason!

Anyway, the point of my story is that it may not be something as extreme as cancer (although that is possible), that they are very very reactive dogs and she may just be in a lot of pain, or reacting to cues she is accidentally being given.
 
A tumour in the back legs will make a dog lame - but sometimes intermittently.

Your first port of call has to be a vet, not a physio, and ask them to xray the area in which she's lame. If it is cancer and has progressed to essentially stage 4 and entered the brain there's nothing you can do. But at least you'll know and can give her a peaceful passing.
 
A fear of a landline phone! Haha that made me laugh, poor thing!

She certainly can be a fussy thing, very much has her own routine and strong belief system! She is funny with her food as well, I finally found a brand that she likes (after the hassle of being given human food and so starving herself until she could get some more) she is on Skinners Field and Trial, orange bag, but if she goes to eat or is eating and the cats come into the kitchen she won't eat again until the next day. It's odd, she isn't scared of the cats, doesn't have any reason to react like this just because they walk into the room, and they aren't ganging up on her to get the food for themselves!

Such a quirky breed.
 
A tumour in the back legs will make a dog lame - but sometimes intermittently.

Your first port of call has to be a vet, not a physio, and ask them to xray the area in which she's lame. If it is cancer and has progressed to essentially stage 4 and entered the brain there's nothing you can do. But at least you'll know and can give her a peaceful passing.

Yes I'm definitely not going to wait three weeks for the calmer and stomach liner to perhaps show an improvement, will call the vet first thing Monday morning and start the ball rolling with more extensive tests.
 
Good luck with the vet, I'm sure it's the right way to go. I don't think for an instant it has anything to do with the previous walkers, that's a red herring. Pain can make humans and animals behave in very strange ways...
 
Several thoughts from me - first would be chronic pain somewhere, second would be ?brain tumour/neurological issue.
To me the pain seems the most likely - her behaviour reminds me of my collie (although she's not as extreme) who can be funny about going out in the garden if the other dogs have gone out before or at the same time, I think because she's worried about being knocked, same as she won't jump out the car if my sister's dog is hanging around (Meg had severe arthritis in both hips so gets much sorer/stiffer if knocked over)

Leg wise - given the come and go nature could she have injured her stifle and the patella is slipping in and out? Would cause pain and while it's out they are extremely lame, it slips back in and they run off (previous dog used to slip her patella out occasionally)

Given your location, the length of time and extreme behaviour I would go straight to the Dick Vets at Edinburgh, they will be able to do a full work up and are superb vets, you can self refere as they operate like a normal vet or you can ask your own vet for a referal.
 
Not much to add but good luck and keep us posted. They are such amazing dogs that it's heartbreaking when things change. Your second picture make me want to weep for you and her.

Thank you. The second pic still makes my blood run cold, she just wasn't there. I was calling and calling her and she was pressed up against the wall like this staring at nothing, I was getting no response from her. I ended up grabbing her collar and dragging her out which shook her out of it, was like some sort of trance she was in. I've never seen her do anything like it since, otherwise I would think it was some sort of epileptic fit she was having?

Leg wise - given the come and go nature could she have injured her stifle and the patella is slipping in and out? Would cause pain and while it's out they are extremely lame, it slips back in and they run off (previous dog used to slip her patella out occasionally)

Given your location, the length of time and extreme behaviour I would go straight to the Dick Vets at Edinburgh, they will be able to do a full work up and are superb vets, you can self refere as they operate like a normal vet or you can ask your own vet for a referal.

The patella slipping sounds like it would cause the amount of pain she screams in. Though would the vet not have felt something by now? I am not far from the Glasgow Vet School, they are my nearest out of hours vet so given the extensive tests I want done chances are I'll be sent there.
 
Nothing new to add, I'm glad you're getting it checked out as it does suggest to me to be pain related. Whilst it may be something drastic with it being a collie it may be something small that over time she has worked her self up about.
They can be complicated dogs
 
Can I ask if you have had a physio look at her? I am just saying because my parent's GSD x Collis kept going intermittently lame on her front a few years ago and the vets prescribed anti inflammatories etc. They didn't work long term and, if I remember rightly we eventually had her x-rayed thinking something must be going on. Vets found nothing. We then had our physio guy look at her (he treats our horses) and he diagnosed that she was in pain in her lower back/pelvis. he treated her (cue a fair bit of yelping from the dog!). Two days after she was fine again there was no more lameness

Just a thought really. Ours wasn't exhibiting any of the behaviour yours is (she was just down really) but all dogs react differently. I just do find vets don't seem to be able to diagnose some things - if they can't see it on x-rays/scans and nothing shows in the bloods or other tests then they do seem to get rather stumped!

Worth a try anyway if you've not already been there.
 
Can I ask if you have had a physio look at her? I am just saying because my parent's GSD x Collis kept going intermittently lame on her front a few years ago and the vets prescribed anti inflammatories etc. They didn't work long term and, if I remember rightly we eventually had her x-rayed thinking something must be going on. Vets found nothing. We then had our physio guy look at her (he treats our horses) and he diagnosed that she was in pain in her lower back/pelvis. he treated her (cue a fair bit of yelping from the dog!). Two days after she was fine again there was no more lameness

Just a thought really. Ours wasn't exhibiting any of the behaviour yours is (she was just down really) but all dogs react differently. I just do find vets don't seem to be able to diagnose some things - if they can't see it on x-rays/scans and nothing shows in the bloods or other tests then they do seem to get rather stumped!

Worth a try anyway if you've not already been there.

Yes I've been thinking about getting out the physio who does the horses, as well as going down the route of more extensive tests.

I would just like my happy wee dog back!

f417f7d0-b635-4da0-b4d2-26931e995896_zps032afa95.jpg


522702_10150845171897751_1349895031_n_zps7714dd06.jpg
 
The vet will only feel something if the patella is out while at the vets. If she goes really lame again and it ista slipped patella the to.put it back you simply flex the leg up and it should slip back but this can be painful for them. Glasgow is a good vet school as well.
 
Your comment about her being im a trance makes me thinknof a typenof seizures humans have called abcense seizures where he person basically goes into a trance so ut maybe something along those lines as well.as a pain thing.
 
From the photo I see pain -or perhaps fear?
The lameness and the behaviour may be unrelated issues. It is not something for an out of hours vet service but I would be starting a diary of episodes, food, triggers or just about everything and getting her eyes tested as blindness or tunnel vision can, rarely, induce a fear like response.
It could be a form of seizure, could be a tumour or even an inner ear or tooth infection.
PL could cause that type of intermittent lameness. Watch for any change in gait as well as actual limping.
 
I would definitely rule out anything physical first. My girlie has a brain tumour but it has not affected her behaviour at all, she is nearly blind and has become more and more ataxic over the last few months, but no aggression or odd behaviour, she will be given peace soon. If nothing can be found physically, then I would consider a veterinary behaviourist, there may be some drugs that can help her. Going to a vet school is a good idea, they will be more thorough in their investigations. Good luck.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top