Well if a judge at a show won't stand up fir the ponies welfare what chance does anyone else have?
Disappointed and ashsmee
Disappointed and ashsmee
Lunged for 3 hour's!
- Thread starter Gingerwitch
- Start date
- Joined
- 28 March 2011
- Messages
- 41,874
I could not read the whole story but it seems strange that a horse could in a condition of turnout for the ring after three hours mainly cantering .
I don’t know what to think about it .
I don’t know what to think about it .
https://www.horseandhound.co.uk/new...s-up-after-pony-lunged-for-three-hours-785730
A showing judge who saw a small pony at an event being lunged for some three hours says such “utterly disgusting” sights make her wonder what else is going on at home
She told H&H she caught sight of the pony being lunged while she was in her first class, which started at 11am. It was still being “chased around in canter” on the circle at 2.45pm.
A showing judge who saw a small pony at an event being lunged for some three hours says such “utterly disgusting” sights make her wonder what else is going on at home
She told H&H she caught sight of the pony being lunged while she was in her first class, which started at 11am. It was still being “chased around in canter” on the circle at 2.45pm.
But this judge didn’t do anything, or ask anyone else to do anything? And 11-2.45 is nearly four hours…
- Joined
- 13 November 2009
- Messages
- 1,316
Ridiculous, why didn't the judge ask what they were doing .This is exactly why people carry on with unacceptable behaviour, no one says anything x
- Joined
- 15 January 2022
- Messages
- 73
I dont get the point. What class is it going to win after being lunged for three hours? Must have been a right sweaty, tucked up mess. Poor bugger.
She was judging, was she really in a position to say that pony was lunged continuously?
Maybe it was lunged at 11 to exercise it and then just popped back on the lunge before its class?
It sounds pretty crazy to me, I can't see how the pony would be fit to show.
.
Maybe it was lunged at 11 to exercise it and then just popped back on the lunge before its class?
It sounds pretty crazy to me, I can't see how the pony would be fit to show.
.
- Joined
- 28 March 2011
- Messages
- 41,874
But does the story say she saw the horse lunged for the whole time
Seems a bit odd? Also who in their right mind would want to stand their lungeing for 4 hours?!
I thought this too. I mean, what on earth would be the point of lunging a horse for almost 4 hours? Even the hottest horse in the world would be utterly exhausted after that and you certainly wouldn't have something that was fit to be seen in then show ring.
Presumably it remained in her eye view whilst she was in the ring judging. She did do something- she raised it with an official. The lungeing however continued, though the pony was moved further away. She's also raised it with H&H (and who knows, who else) .
For the judge to raise makes me think something wasn’t right. But that’s why I don’t like showing anymore. Something isn’t right. Obese animals. Ponies ridden by adults at event or at home. Where is the true child ridden pony. Just my thoughts.
- Joined
- 28 March 2011
- Messages
- 41,874
She judged for three hours non stop !!!! Is that normal
I read that article - if it's true, and it was really lunged for 3hr straight, that is utterly abhorrent behaviour. But I don't understand why, if the judge is really so well-respected, they didn't go up to them and say 'oi, the way you're treating this animal isn't actually acceptable'.
Also I would fall asleep on my feet of sheer boredom if I had to lunge for that length of time.
Also I would fall asleep on my feet of sheer boredom if I had to lunge for that length of time.
- Joined
- 28 March 2011
- Messages
- 41,874
My legs would not take it neither will the ponies in the long term .
Back when I worked as a groom in the states the head trainer was a tiny guy with a massive ego. The horses were all big high powered warmbloods but doing hunters where they basically have to be foot perfect. The trainer refused to sit on any of them to show them until there wasn’t a hope in hell that they would play up and make him look anything other than the perfect rider. So he would make the grooms ride them for hours before his class times. One particular mare, my favourite of the lot, had an incredible engine and her trot and canter were phenomenal and appeared tireless. I remember her doing at least 2 hours of trot and canter before her classes. It was horrible, She was so genuine she just never powered down (and she was the same after 20mins or 2 hrs so It was competent pointless) My point being, I can believe that this happens and that some Duracell powered horses would just keep going.
- Joined
- 29 July 2009
- Messages
- 2,555
Vile! Lungeing shouldn’t be allowed at shows. It’s not allowed at dressage is it?
- Joined
- 15 February 2018
- Messages
- 1,341
Call me old fashioned ,Lunging , 20 minute4s tops then a serious rest.
It's a bit vague as to whether she actually saw it during the time in between, or just saw it again at 2.45 and assumed it had been lunged for that entire time. I don't know. Obviously if someone was lunging for that entire time, then that is utterly horrendous. But it just seems so unlikely. We've all lunged - would any of us actually manage to keep lunging for that amount of time? I know I wouldn't, I can do about 10 mins before I'm incredibly bored.
- Joined
- 28 March 2011
- Messages
- 41,874
Ok so it’s vague , then I don’t think we should judge until we know the actual facts .
I can see it being perfectly possible that they may take a horse off the truck when then arrived lunge it to settle it and then take it off and do that again a few times.
Still may be damaging but it’s a different thing .
Once upon a time horses that where unsettled at shows where ridden quietly around the show until boredom set in .
If it was being lunged because it was so explosive they can’t get on it without doing then then for its simple it’s not a show horse find it a job it’s likes and that suits it temperament .
I can see it being perfectly possible that they may take a horse off the truck when then arrived lunge it to settle it and then take it off and do that again a few times.
Still may be damaging but it’s a different thing .
Once upon a time horses that where unsettled at shows where ridden quietly around the show until boredom set in .
If it was being lunged because it was so explosive they can’t get on it without doing then then for its simple it’s not a show horse find it a job it’s likes and that suits it temperament .
I had a mare that needed to be lunged before you got on it for 2 years as a youngster — everytime — even if she was ridden put on the wagon and then got off again for another class — otherwise it ended very badly
I heard of a horse being ridden continuously around the NEC from its allotted warmup time at 18:30, until it was in the ring at 07:00 the next day.
Horses being left out all night the night before a show (no problem with that) - with NO water ( i DO have a problem with hat!!)
Lungeing for 2-3 hours apparently isn't unheard of, I was personally told of one at the last Royal Show at Stoneleigh being lunged for over 2 hours on rock hard uneven ground.
Strangely, it disappeared without trace the year after having won all before it in that year ..
Horses being left out all night the night before a show (no problem with that) - with NO water ( i DO have a problem with hat!!)
Lungeing for 2-3 hours apparently isn't unheard of, I was personally told of one at the last Royal Show at Stoneleigh being lunged for over 2 hours on rock hard uneven ground.
Strangely, it disappeared without trace the year after having won all before it in that year ..
Last edited:
Chances are it was just lunged a few times through the day and she just happened to see it both times, I know of people that will do this at a show its not uncommon.
- Joined
- 6 January 2008
- Messages
- 3,372
Totally normal in showing, along with feeding huge amounts of feed, cruel practices for measuring in, strapping heads down for hours on end, over-rugging and many more questionable practices. For thousands of show horses around the country, they are silently and behind closed doors living a life of abject misery.
- Joined
- 18 January 2021
- Messages
- 3,538
I've seen some of these practices at a yard I've visited a friend at, and its totally vile. Poor horse had his head tied down 'to create more topline' - have you ever heard of anything more despicable??