My naughty gelding is going back to his old owner and I'm gutted

MDB

Well-Known Member
Joined
29 June 2014
Messages
955
Location
Spain.
Visit site
Loooong post. Apologies in advance.

Today I have decided I can no longer deal with my gelding. I bought him precisely one year ago as my first horse. He was to be a happy hacker. Fun rides only, no schooling or eventing but something safe and suitable for a novice.

Within two weeks after getting him he was diagnosed with an infectious disease which the vet thought had been brewing for several months. Queue £1000 in vet fees and two months of medical care. C'est la vie. These things happen. However, he was tough to handle from day one, bolshy and bargy with few ground manners. (With me anyway). I spent a few months doing daily groundwork with him because he lost so much weight and was too poorly to ride.

When eventually he had recovered I tried hacking him but he was nappy and spooky and he would drop his shoulder and spin around and try to bolt home. I put the difficulties down to my lack of experience and confidence and vowed to work through it.

Being alone in Spain with my husband working abroad for most of the year I had nobody to help me with him. I tried short inhand walks, continued groundwork and tried riding him in the fiels. His napping continued and he threw me once.

To add to things he escaped three times from my two metre high electric fence, in the process wrecking my neighbour's fencing. On one occasion he jumped the fence simply because he was hungry and there was lusher grass on the other side. I reinforced our fencing, bought more powerful energisers and resorted to tethering him during the night.

He needed company so we got him two placid docile rescue mares. He was nasty and aggressive and would repeatedly attack them, biting and kicking. I had additional field shelters built because he would refuse to allow the mares inside with him.

Throughout this I still had difficulties hacking.. he now realised that he could add bucking to the equation and he quickly got out of work. He was checked over and was healthy and not in pain. When hacking in company with the other horses we had no bucking or rearing or napping at all but I struggled to control him when I asked him to go behind the other horses. In addition he would continue to spook wildly at random things.

This month we think he bit my mare causing an infected wound and hundreds upon hundred of pounds of treatment. Then yesterday he backed the above mare into a corner and bit her twice on her legs and rump and chased her around the field. And finally today he totally freaked out with my husband when being led to an adjacent field for grazing because the other two got out of sight for a fraction of a second.

I simply cannot trust him and he is too much horse for me. He has been too much since the beginning if I am honest but I put our issues down to settling in and my confidence. I wake up at night worrying that when I get up in the morning my mares will still be ok. I am sure somebody more experinced would have been able to deal with him but i made it clear when i went to view him that he was my first horse and what my level of experience is. I consider myself a confident novice.. had lessons as achild for years and years then pottered with riding on and off since.

I feel gutted having come to this decision. I just don't feel safe anymore, he is costing me an absolute fortune and I am terrified he is going to cause serious injury to my other horses.

So there you have it. A sad day for me today. The only good thing is that he is going back to his previous owner who I am friends with on facebook. Apologies for the long, long post but this forum has given me a lot of support with our issues over the year. So thanks to you all. I did my absolute best foe him but it just isn't working.
 
Last edited:
It sounds like you are doing the right thing for both you and him. Don't beat yourself up. Sometimes things just weren't meant to be, and it takes guts to admit defeat.
 
As above, don't beat yourself up about it. Owning a horse is supposed to be fun. I've been reading your threads for a while and you've done as much as you could. Hopefully you will just enjoy your mares now - I hope the one with wither injury gets better soon. As people often say here - it costs the same to keep a bad horse as a good one.
 
You are doing the right thing. It's so sad when things don't work out as we hope but it can't be helped, and you can't put yourself or your other horses at risk. Don't feel bad about it, there is nothing you can do.
 
as above and above, also been following your threads on your mare and the rescue PRE , you are doing the right thing with this, sleepless nights worrying are not good and you have done your best, i totally understand tho that it is not an easy thing to do. xx
 
I share your pain as I have been in a similar situation, I bet you have cried many tears. My experience was however massively positive months later, we have a difference pony and life is so much easier. You have put up with a lot of grief for something that is meant to be a hobby! I hope that things turn out well for you and your next equine. I am sure you are making the right decision.
 
I really do feel for you. After everything that you have been going through with your mar,e making this difficult decision must have been very heartbreaking. IMO you are doing the right thing, horses are costly beasts and owning them is supposed to be enjoyable!
 
Sounds like it's the right thing for you both...it is meant to be fun and whilst every horse owner knows that there will be times when the fun is interrupted, you really haven't had any respite at all with your boy. I am sure you are heart broken but you really have tried so don't give yourself a hard time over it. Better times are ahead for you, I feel sure. X
 
Hugs MDB. You are definitely doing the right thing. Many people would not have persevered so long (I wouldnt!). Hope you find a lovely riding horse now. x x
 
Ah thank you all. I feel quite emotional reading your messages. My heart want to keep him and persevere, but my head says that I am not going to win this one. There has been a lot of tears over the past 24 hours but I think it is only a matter of time before he injures me or somebody else... and he needs a more experienced hand to get through his issues.
 
You've had a hard time recently! I think you're doing the right thing with this horse. Tbh, he sounds like a total nightmare, not a horse I'd want to handle. This is meant to be fun, not a ruddy trauma! Onwards and upwards with the mare's wither wound and some peaceful and happy times ahead, Chica!
 
Sounds def like the right decision and although you feel sad you may also feel relief. Your mares will probably be thankful too and he will be. Horses are not meant to be so stressful all the time
 
Have been following your story with interest and I really do think it's the best decision for you all.
You seem to have two lovely mares now- who knew they existed!- I wish you all the best with them :)
Things have a funny way of working out!
 
You have done your very best for this difficult horse, and your other two. Definately made the right decisions for all of them now. Brave and sensible. I hope you and the mares have a more tranquil time- you certainly deserve it! Good luck and lots of love.
 
You posted about him before, didn't you? He sounded difficult then & even more now. You have to consider your safety & those around you.
He sounds like a bit of a git & you did what you could.
 
I am pleased you have decided this, OP. I know how hard you tried with him, but it is completely unfair on your mares to keep him. He was obviously unhappy for whatever reason. I hope his old owner will be able to sort out his problems and that he doesn't hurt anyone or any other horse.
 
You posted about him before, didn't you? He sounded difficult then & even more now. You have to consider your safety & those around you.
He sounds like a bit of a git & you did what you could.

yes I did. I posted lots of things asking for advice. I appreciate everybody's kind words... I know it is the right thing to do, even though i find it all quite emotional :) thanks everyone.
 
Well done for being honest with this stuation; I really feel you have gone through enough with this fellow,riding and owning horses are meant to be fun!
I think your mare will be really happy to see this gelding go,thats one big thorn out of her life, imagine being in a field with no way out and having to indure his bullieng.....
He is probably the cause of her wound, I really wish you both a bit of peace and quiet.
The wound is looking alot healthier; well done in keeping up with all the care and love.
 
I am pleased you have decided this, OP. I know how hard you tried with him, but it is completely unfair on your mares to keep him. He was obviously unhappy for whatever reason. I hope his old owner will be able to sort out his problems and that he doesn't hurt anyone or any other horse.

Thanks Wagtail. I am sure it will be a relief when he is gone. As everyone said.. this was supposed to fun but I am just constantly worried and battling with him. His previous owner knows how much I have tried, and has said to me i couldnt have done any more. She knows what she is getting back and I know he will be well looked after. I hope she can work through his issues and I hope that my gelding will be happy there.
 
Top