Rug preference- neck /no neck?

[ILuvCowparsely]

So all you lovely people, I am about to buy a new set of winter rugs as my old ones are looking rather tired and my mare has grown out of her hand-me-downs.
Do you prefer a neck on a rug or not? Most of the ones I have are combos but I don't think the necks really ever fit properly. Obviously I'd like some sort of neck for turnout since she's a muddy beast.
Also if anybody has any reviews of the four seasons boots of le mieux for drying legs overnight?
Much appreciated

I prefer fixed neck every time and fold back underneath the neck on dry days, so two in one.

I don't like detachable ones as:

1. the zippers often bung up with mud so you cannot undo it or zipper it back up
2. d rings often come unstiched.

Rugs I like are Shires and Maxima as they are light weight on the horse and dry quickly they are also very roomy for horses with big chests

 

[milliepops]

I prefer fixed neck every time and fold back underneath the neck on dry days, so two in one.

I don't like detachable ones as:

1. the zippers often bung up with mud so you cannot undo it or zipper it back up
2. d rings often come unstiched.

Rugs I like are Shires and Maxima as they are light weight on the horse and dry quickly they are also very roomy for horses with big chests

The ones that velcro on are great though IMO, I really like being able to take them off for cleaning. Never had a zip-on or one that fixes with D rings.