Abby-Lou
Well-Known Member
I have used both Westgate & Poo Post both very good service, but now with rising costs I will be sticking with poo post
I have not made any allegation against poo post, just a general observation.
They may do just as good a job as Westgate at a fraction of the price, but how would the average punter know?
me too I am sticking to WestgateI'm sticking with Westgate. I have had superb ongoing free advice over the years from them over tricky horses with repeat high counts. I trust them to do a professional job. I am very suspicious of a new company who pops up significantly undercutting a main competitor.
I trust Westgate not to cut corners.
Re the Westgate 4 count kit, which is the one I buy, you don't have to get all the 4 counts done at the same time. You can send them off one at a time if you want to.
I don't think that you can be sure of the accuracy of any testing procedure whatever the firm unless you are actually there and have the knowledge to check the results. So you basically have to trust whoever you send your samples to.
The equipment is a basic light microscope, McMasters chamber and centrifuge. I do my own (working in a lab has to have SOME perks!). Nothing more fancy than that unless they have automated counters which I doubt (there's always debris in the sample, so it would be nigh on impossible to be accurate).Lol, no i don't. I have used westgate for the last 8 years and never had an issue with their service, always speedy and good advice. It was only because i was asked to order online that i ended up shopping around and found poo post at half the cost. When everything is going up in price i thought i would give them a try but i just wondered how the " same service" was twice the price is all. More accurate equipment.... Or just because....
Westgate are also trying to be responsible with their packaging etc to reduce plastic waste. That can put the price up a bit.
I noticed too late today that poo post re-use their pots as the leafletsaid not to write on them. Unfortunately i had already marker penned them all with ponios names ready to collect samples so theybdidn't get muddled in my pocket. I will say the lids are much better than westgates as there was no fallouts in my pocket because they properly shut ?Westgate are also trying to be responsible with their packaging etc to reduce plastic waste. That can put the price up a bit.
I used Poo Post for the first time recently and very pleased.
I'm sure Westgate are fab too but I'm watching my pennies with multiple horses.
I think anyone insinuating dodgy results based on cost of service is on very shaky ground; an expensive service doesn't guarantee quality either.
I use saturated epsom salts.For those of you who do their own FECs, what floatation solution do you use?
With regards advice, you have google and you have a forum like this - you can easily get advice if needed. I personally wouldnt normally think to ask the company I got worm counts from, I would normally find the information myself or ask my vet for advice if I wasnt sure.
Performing a FEC is easy and quick if you have access to a microscope, so it is unlikely a company would use poor practice or knowingly get results wrong (as opposed to accidentally mixing up samples/results). The only way they could do that is if their staff can't count, or they are just making up a number and not bothering with any test. The tests don't take long so falsifying the results (or not bothering to count carefully) would not be worth the risk of being found out.
The more complicated bit is whether a company has staff with enough appropriate and in-depth education to advise customers on how to proceed once they have the result. But, again, a company would soon be found out if their staff were making errors or spouting rubbish. The 'advice' part is the only bit I could possibly see being responsible for a price difference between companies, but equally one company may just be cheaper than another because they have lower profit margins.
I'm not involved with any testing company, but I used to carry out tests for a vet practice when I was a student. I use my own vet's for my horses' FECs now.
I'm sticking with Westgate. I have had superb ongoing free advice over the years from them over tricky horses with repeat high counts. I trust them to do a professional job. I am very suspicious of a new company who pops up significantly undercutting a main competitor.
I trust Westgate not to cut corners.
.