A problem horse or not?

Omarkiam

Well-Known Member
Joined
11 November 2010
Messages
148
Visit site
I have just gotten a beautiful gelding on full loan, possibly with view to buy in a years time, but more likely to extend to a longer loan term until the owner is completely happy with the agreement.

I went up to see him in his previous home before loaning him, and rode him. He was a dream, although very nervy at being hacked out alone, (constantly stopping and looking around), he did well, responded to his seat nicely and was patient to be tacked up and groomed. He seemed perfect.

I got him home, he travelled brilliantly, unloaded nicely, and was turned straight out into a large field by himself where although he had view of lots of horses, he could only get head height, and there was electric fencing in between him and the other horses. I bought him in later on that evening, as he arrived very early am, about 10am. I just bought him in to show him around etc, I did expect a fidgety horse for obvious reasons, being new etc.
He was a bit more than fidgety though and would bolt as soon as I undid his leadrope, and given his size, (16.2hh), I cannot hold onto him, he only runs to the first horse he can find though, for comfort, then he stops and he is fine. So I put him back and left him till the next day, bought him in from his field to have his hay and feed, and this time, whichever side I went to groom him, he would shift his weight to the other direction t avoid being groomed, because of this I gave him a tap on the bum, literally just a tap, and told him to stand straight, and pushed him to whatever direction I wanted him, and as a result, he started slamming me into the wall, whichever side I was, he would throw all his weight at me, throwing me against the wall, and it really was a throw, people watching couldnt believe just how hard he was trying to ram me up against the wall! he even did a few times thinking I was there, and gota surprise when it was just the wall! I decided from then on, I would bring him in a couple of times a day, both times being for treats, such as, a few polos, his feed and a haynet, so later on that evening I bought him back out, and this time he refused to come in from field, he just stopped dead in the middle of the road! You have about 4 metres of road to cross to get onto the farm from his field. I tried using his leadrope as a whip, I tried using the polos in my pocket, and the carrots, and nothing could tempt him to cross, I was there a good 25 minutes, luckily the road is so quiet, not to many cars were coming, but those that did, just managed to squeeze past, so after 25 minutes someone who had been watching me struggle for all that time came over and walked behind him, which did slowly but surely egg him on a bit, since then he has been doing this constantly, but to the point where hes doing it IN his field when I catch him, he is easy to catch but then stops continuously in his field all the way to the yard, this is not too much of a problem as I haven't tried using his bridle etc yet but thought I would mention the trouble its caused so far.

Now.. on from there, we have the riding, I decided to tack him up yesterday and ride him, under the saddle he is normally brilliant, however he is ridden bitless, and as a result he knows he has alot of head freedom, and uses this too his advantage, when you ask him to stop, he will throw his head around an awful lot to get you to let go of the reins, and when you want him to turn, its like fighting a rhino, because the bitless bridle has no effect on him and he totally ignores what your asking him to do, so I decided when he kept stopping and starting, which he did whenever he felt like it, I would give him a tap on the bum, and again, it really was just a tap on the bum, and he bucked! I was told he was not whip shy, but I am beginning to disbelieve that because when I used a whip he would buck, so I dismounted, and decided to lunge him using his parelli line instead, when I do so, and I give him a tap on the bum to move forward, he will either buck, or kick out at me, and even went to the extent of rearing at one stage. He wouldnt walk, he would just trot or pull away from the line. I turned him away again for the day and bought him back out today, this time again he is very fidgety, will not stand to be groomed, tries to bolt when I loosen the lead rope, and is always always headthrowing, so it is impossible to brush his forelock or face.
After SIX attempts to get his saddle on, (as he kept throwing his weight about) I managed and I got his bridle on with not too many issues, I lead him to the mounting block where he refused to stand, but eventually I half jumped on while he was walking, and I lead him towards the school, half way there he decided to refuse to move forward, was backing up, and at this point I felt unsafe, so I instantly dismounted to save injury, as I have only just recovered from a serious horse riding accident and didnt want another too soon! At this point I was angry, very angry, so I gave him a damn hard tug on the headcollar, and shouted at him to stand up straight and behave, he seemed to respon because instead of plodding and refusing to move forward, he was very forward going, even trotting. I lead him into the school and after a few attempts, mounted him from inside the school using a bench. I started to walk him round but instantly he started refusing to move, then he started backing up, no rearing, purely just walking backwards at speed, then he headthrew to make me let go of the reins, and once again while he was in walk I jumped off because I no longer felt safe. At this point I was that fuming I gave him a good hard smack on the bum and told him he was very naughty, and he had no treat when returned to the tie up block, no hay, no feed, no polos or carrots. Once home, I was really angry with myself for smacking him because according to his owner whose had him for 5 years, he had a bad past before that, and he reacts badly to people being ''firm''.

I am worried about him being ridden bitless, although I didnt think I would find it a problem, he cannot have a bit as the vets came out and said they do not see the point in putting him through the stress of fixing his jaw, as its broken, because its causing him no discomfort, and doesnt effect him in anyway, fixing it would mean rebreaking it in different places etc. I feel very unsafe with him having no bit, because he knows full well that he has total freedom, and if he does not want to do something, he wont, simple as. I just wanted some advice because I know he has potential, I just dont know how to combat these problems at the moment, really upsetting!
 
I don't think he's the horse for you. Talk to his owner and ask them to come and show you how to handle him, that might help.

Whacking a horse you have just got off on the bum is a good way of losing horse into the distance. Punishing him by not giving him treats only makes you feel better, he doesn't understand the concept.
 
Sounds to me like he is very unsettled about the move. I would in the first instance ring his owner and ask her to come and see him at your place. Ask her to get him out of the field, groom him and tack him up herself and to give you guidance about how to handle him.
 
Your description of his behaviour suggests a very insecure horse, who is nervous-aggressive - OR an ill-mannered *****bag who has been getting his own way for years! The fact he behaved well at his former home suggests it IS an insecurity/fear issue.

As you are nervous of a serious injury - understandably so - this is NOT the horse for you because it will take weeks/months of VERY calm and confident handling to get him as right as he's ever likely to be. He is NOT the horse for you!
 
It doesn't sound like a great start. Sounds like you need to talk to the owner and see how they manage him and have a serious think about whether he is the right horse for you.

If you do decide he isn't there is no shame in handing him back.
 
Last edited:
I am the owner of a difficult horse, given the right lee-way you'd likely not be able to do anything with him, but I have always been FIRM and straight with him and we get along just fine. He hates having his belly brushed, having his saddle on and girth tightened. he hates me being in the stable with him... but I'm the boss, so we do it, no big fuss, no smacks, bad behaviour is ignored (unless its really bad in which case he will have a slap) good behaviour is really praised. Now I can do everything with him, he still doesn't like it - but we have an agreement :D
 
Crikey where to start?
Firstly, how long have you actually had him. Some horses take months to properly settle, and this can show in their behaviour. You understand he is running to other horses for comfort, so why not for a while if you can get him across the road with another horse in the lead. This would eliminate the dangerous situation of him stopping dead in the road. He sounds like an anxious boy in all fairness.
Bargy behaviour needs nipping in the bud. If he throws his weight at you, get your elbow in his shoulder and growl "GET OVER" to show him its just not on.
The ridden issues are processes of elimination. Have you had his back/saddle checked?
If its nothing physical, then you can start to address what is effectively a horse taking the P...(which you being firm seems to help?)
Get an instructor out to show you where to start.
But in all honesty (other than the squishing issue) he just sounds like a scare little boy!
 
Sounds to me like he is very unsettled about the move. I would in the first instance ring his owner and ask her to come and see him at your place. Ask her to get him out of the field, groom him and tack him up herself and to give you guidance about how to handle him.

Totally agree with this advice. It's definitely what I would do. Have you talked to his owner about his current behaviour at all?
 
Oh dear, does sound a bit of a problem!

My first worry would be that he was in some sort of physical discomfort, was he vetted when you bought him? How did he break his jaw/what sort of break is it? I would get his back ect checked before you take further action.

As you have lost your confidence due to that accident, are you sure he's not picking up on your nerves and taking advantage? Has an instructor/someone really experienced assessed him? Is he a pushy horse by nature?

Secondly, a bitless bridle like a hackamore is just as harsh as a bridle with a bit, so he shouldn't have total freedom, what type of bridle do you ride him in? When he bolts, is it true bolting (blindly running, don't care what's in their path) or just running away?
 
Everything you describe is him testing the boundaries with you. He doesn't seem to be finding any and now thinks he's boss.

Have you had a horse before? Do you have experience of groundwork?

There's no reason why you can't ride sweetly with a bitless bridle, but if you feel you don't have control and hold on too tightly any horse will fight for their head. They're not fluffy devices to get rid of the "nasty" bit, they are just as effective if you know what you're doing.

For planting, make standing uncomfortable for the horse by a short sharp tug on the lead. Then loosen immediately and step forward. Repeat if he's still standing and don't stand in front of him or face him as he won't know where to go. Don't keep pulling because you'll never win a tug of war with 500kg of horse. No need to hit, shout or anything else, walking with you is the best option for the horse so keep things calm.

Use your elbow if he tries to barge, he'll soon learn that elbows are sharp and uncomfortable.
 
Everything you describe is him testing the boundaries with you. He doesn't seem to be finding any and now thinks he's boss.

Have to say I agree with this. Coupled with the fact that he does sound very anxious you do NOT want to allow this behaviour to escalate any further. I don't think he knows what you want him to do so he's decided to do as he pleases! I would definitely contact his owner and ask her to come out and see you. Also, like someone else said, taking his hay/feed away as 'punishment' will not work as he has no concept of this at all.

If you still want to continue with the loan, watch the owner and see how she gets him to behave (or not!) I would also hack out with company if you can for the first wee while.
 
From what you have written the horse sounds very unsettled several we have bought have been awful in stable and field when they first arrived it can take time to settle,and if i am honest the horse could be confused with the treats then whacking approach i know you need to be firm but i would try to avoid hitting a new horse especially if he really resents the whip i would have given him a bit more of a chance to settle.
You also say when he was crushing you against wall in stable sometimes he thought you were there but was surprised when there was only the wall the horse would have been well aware of where you were so may have just been barging and moving around because he was stressed we have had new horses doing the wall of death when they were first put in their stables.

I would try and work through one thing at a time ie the leading in first get the horse settled and trusting you but if you are nervous to begin with this will make the horse worse and a big horse on its toes may not be the right one for you.

As others have said asking the owner to come down and help you may help if you can see them handling the horse in your enviroment and may help you over the initial settling period it may give the horse a bit of confidence too as it is all very new for him as well good luck.:)
 
Secondly, a bitless bridle like a hackamore is just as harsh as a bridle with a bit, so he shouldn't have total freedom, what type of bridle do you ride him in? When he bolts, is it true bolting (blindly running, don't care what's in their path) or just running away?

Everything you describe is him testing the boundaries with you. He doesn't seem to be finding any and now thinks he's boss.

all of the above! Really sounds like he is just trying it on with you. You need to be much firmer with him before it get really dngerous.
 
Firstly, thank you to everyone who has replied, I have taken into account what all of you have said, but as for saying he's not the horse for me, I don't believe that for one minute. I haven't lost my confidence completely, but I am more wary of a situation that I know could turn nasty.

I have spoken to the owner, that was the first thing I did today, she has said he was very much the same with her, and she had no confidence, but with time, and alot of groundwork he came round, he seems to want the attention, and definately wants to please but isn't too sure how to go about it.
I have had horses before, and have had problem horses but they were all fairly good with groundwork, ground problems are a new thing to me at the moment,I have been quite lucky with previous horses! I am going to leave him longer to settle, as have not had him for months, I have been doing what alot of you said, giving him a tug on the leadrope when he stops, then moving forward and he seems to follow that quite well. He has been allowed to walk over his previous owner, I can tell that from the way she treats him, hes more of a pet than a ''horse''. So I guess he doesn't understand ''manners''. I think the reason I have not coped with the situation well is because it was a foreign thing to me, and I definately after seeing how good he was at previous home, didn't expect quite so bad behaviour. After sitting back and reading through what I posted I have made more sense of what's been happening. I want to continue to ride him but I think from now on I shall mount him in the school, but before doing so I shall walk him around, let him see whats about, and let him take in that nothing is there to hurt him. When he is naughty he gets a tug or a tap, when he is good, I give him lots of praise, scratches, and pats. I am hoping with time this will help. I had a friend come see him with me today and she has alot of experience with naughty horses, and was an instructor for many years, she said he has no manners atall, and that being firm shan't hurt him, do you guys agree with this, given his past? Do you think its possible that if I am firm with him, and give him an elbow when he invades my private space, that it will upset him and make him worse?

--Oh and forgot to say, cant bring another horse in with him, as 99% of the other horse owners are young so at school, or working! so noones ever there when I am!
 
Last edited:
I asked the owner to come down and see him, and do the things I would normally do, but she said she would like not too confuse him, she wants him to know I am ''mummy'' first?


-So sorry to post again, I keep reliasing things I forgot to post!!!

As for vetting, yes done, saddle had just be tailor made, and fitted to him, and hes just had his teeth and back done. So health wise, not a problem!
 
He has been allowed to walk over his previous owner, I can tell that from the way she treats him, hes more of a pet than a ''horse''. So I guess he doesn't understand ''manners''.

I had a friend come see him with me today and she has alot of experience with naughty horses, and was an instructor for many years, she said he has no manners atall, and that being firm shan't hurt him, do you guys agree with this, given his past? Do you think its possible that if I am firm with him, and give him an elbow when he invades my private space, that it will upset him and make him worse?

Defiinatly agree with the firdst paragraph!
Being firm with a horse is not the same as being hard or cruel to a horse. You HAVE to be firm! If you let the horse walk over you you WILL get hurt.
What is his past exactly?
 
I had this with my mare bless her. She had been shunted from dealers yard to dealers yard. She was worried all the time and just wanted to go home really:(

All forgotten now. She turned out to be a one to one horse, she owns me completely and I can't fault her.

She's my horse of a lifetime, I gush about her all the time and I am so so proud.
It just takes a lot of time and a lot of patience too.

Keep safe and Good luck with him.
 
Well in answer to the title of your post, probably yes.

Its up to you really what you do about this. Me personally - well, its a loan with view to buy you have, horses are supposed to be fun, not a stressful trial, wondering all the time if he's about to try and kill you again.

I'd be sending him back if I was in your position and looking for something easier and more chilled. Life really is too short...

Poor horse though, makes you wonder why he's the way he is...

No I don't think telling him off for invading your space is a bad thing, horses are like kids, they need clear boundaries and routine. The most mannerly horses are usually that way because they have clear routines, are treated consistently by all humans they come into contact with. In other words they know what is going to happen next.
 
Last edited:
Hi OP - whereabouts in the country are you? I think you and the horse could benefit from some lessons and training from someone with experience with these sorts of issues. It certainly does not sound like he's being intentionally aggressive - he lets you catch him, he doesn't rear so it doesn't seem like he's saying "get off me leave me alone" etc.
There is a lady i know of but she's in yorkshire (sarah ussher) who does a lot of groundwork and riding work/lessons with horses who sound like yours. I do think it needs to start from the ground so he understands where you are coming from and what exactly you are asking of him.

it may be worth giving her a call and, if you're not in the area then maybe she could suggest someone who could help you in your area who uses the techniques she does. I am not talking about a person who is wishy washy with horses either. She competes as does her daughter successfully eventing etc BUT she works at understanding the horse and getting the horse to understand its rider as opposed to trying to force the horse to 'behave' as some may do.

You certainly want to nip this in the bud and this horse needs to understand what behaviour is acceptable and what is not. He does sound unsettled and confused and, if you say his previous owner was rather nervy then I would say the issue stems from there. I think nervy owners = nervy horses, simple as.

I wish you the best of luck but I do think you need help from someone who is is experienced with these behavioural issues.
 
When I tried my horse she was very green schooling wise (she wasn't lively at all or spooky, just didn't really know anything... but neither did I!) but was as quiet as a mouse to handle. Got her home and we have had all kinds of problems, nothing really really awful but things that I didn't expect from the quiet horse we had seen! I was looking for a happy hacker and was unprepared.

In her time with us, Belle has refused to be caught, broken back (a million times) when tied, broken a bridle, refused to be tacked up, refused to be brushed, bucked, spooked, reared, spun, stopped etc. The list goes on, hehe. Now, after a year of patience, she seems to have finally come good, really good. :) I only really started riding her properly in March or April due to the weather and even then it has only been 2 or 3 times a week at most. I have been firm with her but never smacked her, except for a few taps with a whip when necessary when I've been on board.

I would say that this horse of yours needs a lot more time to settle and that you just have to get a method and stick to it, patience is a virtue! I don't know how to solve your problems exactly but I think it sounds as though it could really pay off if you are willing to persevere. :) Good luck!

ETA: I had my instructor come to the field and give me some pointers on handling her and tacking up. It really brought my confidence back and helped me to approach the issues with new eyes. Sometimes I thought she Belle been acting out of fear when in fact, she was taking the micky. I would recommend this course of action!
 
He really does sound as if he is taking the Pi ...... and using his height etc

I would get a control head collar (Parelli type) and a 12foot rope. This will give you more control over him.

The first thing I would be doing is teaching him to respect your space. I would carry a schooling whip (Not to hit him but to make sure he does not crowd you) teach him to stop and start when you ask him to.

When he is in the stable carry a short piece of stick and again if he invades your space just give him a prod asking him to move over.

Omarkiam where do you live If you prefer you can PM me.

I have had several horse that I have had to teach manners to.
 
Your horsey sounds quite similar to mine when I first got him, though mine wasn't quite as bad ridden. I was inexperienced and lost all my confidence and ended up in hospital, so be careful.
I would persevere if you have the experience, knowledge and support you need for such a difficult horse. If you are in doubt regarding your abilities, or you are worried you may lose confidence, there is nothing wrong with sending him back. He will be unsettled and nervous, and he will be trying you out. He may have learned to scare his previous rider by bucking when the whip is used, or threatening to rear (my boy did that) so be careful you're not rewarding his bad behaviour by dismounting when things get sketchy as he'll only do it all the more. One trick an instructor taught me when the horse is throwing himself around is to trot him in small circles, figure 8s, to get control of his feet. It certainly worked with my little monster. And as for groundwork Michael Peace's books helped me the most. Good luck whatever you decide to do.
 
i havnt read all the replies , but your horse sounds like he has been very unsettled by the move and is insecure.
i wouldnt say he is a problem horse just one that gets very upset with things changing and his insecurity comes out as bolshyness.
spend time getting to know him :)
id give him time to settle down before you think about sending him back .
 
Last edited:
i wouldnt say he is a problem horse just one that gets very upset with things changing and his insecurity comes out as bolshyness.
spend time getting to know him :)
id give him time to settle down before you think about sending him back .

i agree. I have a horse here on diy livery, which has turned into me bringing them in every evening. Thats not a problem, just the fecker is 17.3hh, and he knows it. it took me weeks to get the hang of bringing him in, without being dragged around the place. at the start, he just wouldnt come in for me, end of story, but when his owner turned up, straight in. I'd give the horse a chance to settle and to get to know you, but would prob contact owner for his/her advice.
 
i agree. I have a horse here on diy livery, which has turned into me bringing them in every evening. Thats not a problem, just the fecker is 17.3hh, and he knows it. it took me weeks to get the hang of bringing him in, without being dragged around the place. at the start, he just wouldnt come in for me, end of story, but when his owner turned up, straight in. I'd give the horse a chance to settle and to get to know you, but would prob contact owner for his/her advice.

Thank you, I do agree now I have thought about it a bit more, talking it through with my other half as he is not horsey at all, so its quite nice to hear what he thinks, from watching Omie and not knowing why he does it. I think I may have worded some of my post wrong, because I haven't lost any confidence, I would get on a horse now that I know would try and throw me off, as long as I know what its going to do, I can deal with it, the problem is with Omie, he was so good when I went to try him, that I wasn't expecting any trouble, (which was silly of me I know), and because I had a nasty injury, I would rather not make the injury worse, prevention is better than cure afterall, hence why I got off as soon as I felt there may be a bad outcome. Once I am better again, ill ride him like a rodeo until I come off! I am sure he will be fine with time, I feel silly for having posted but I always lurk on H&H and look at peoples questions and answers, and your all so good with your answers that I thought there'd be no harm in posting!

Thanks again everyone, I am going to start leading him in with his bridle, showing him that coming in doesn't always mean work.
 
He really does sound as if he is taking the Pi ...... and using his height etc

I would get a control head collar (Parelli type) and a 12foot rope. This will give you more control over him.

The first thing I would be doing is teaching him to respect your space. I would carry a schooling whip (Not to hit him but to make sure he does not crowd you) teach him to stop and start when you ask him to.

When he is in the stable carry a short piece of stick and again if he invades your space just give him a prod asking him to move over.

Omarkiam where do you live If you prefer you can PM me.

I have had several horse that I have had to teach manners to.

Hiya, I do have that 12ft leadrope and headcollar! He is better with that but still will bolt if I untie him, etc, and still wont walk forward!
I am trying to teach him using a whip, lunging him to make him respect my space, and also have been walking him around, making him halt when I say, and go when I say, I try to predict when he is going to halt, and do it just before, so in some senses I have made it easier for myself, and he has the natural thought for it. He has been getting good at this, but its not helping with bringing him in.

I am in Dorset, Bournemouth.

Thanks for reply!

P.S - not stabling him, have tried putting him in stable to tack him up, and he goes crazy, snorts like a wild horse, and does everything in his power to keep away from me by shifting his weight over, and if I open the stable door to get out, he pushes past me, last time managed to do that with all his tack on, found him in the yard with his reins round his legs, how he had managed to untie himself I do not know!
 
Last edited:
I have a horse like this on my yard, he was NH trained badly and has been a large bad mannered, lout. He is seriously bright and a lovely horse, but no manners at all. He has been allowed to get away with everything. HE has no respect for people as he has never been taught boundaries. As a result he would simply refuse to go forwards, he didn;t want to be groomed, he wouldn;t tie up, he wouldn't be led.

His owner was a novice, she was shown by the seller how easiliy she could make the horse go backwards just by facing him and waving lead rope.

As a reult of teh NH training the horse has a phenomenal back, trouble is he uses it everywhere.

I have been handling this horse now for several weeks, I have forced him to go backwards everytime he stops. I refuse to stop grooming him when he gets bargy, I have put several serious boundaries and standards in place that he must adhere to. And he must behave when handled. As a result he is actually a far far nicer horse, he now accepts being groomed, he is far more respectful of people and their space. Don;t try and win his love, be firm but fair. Don't accept bad behaviour. make yourself big and scary in his box widen your shoulders and don't be afraid to make him back away and give you space, I growl loudly when this one here barges. Now I can put him in his stable with his hay and make him stand without eating it until I take his head collar off.

Why is he in a bitless bridle, is that for a real reason or because of a fluffy bunny reason, because bitless can be far far more severe than a gentle bit. Has he been handled like a large dog, and allowed to get away with it. Get tough, be his leader. i have never yet had to put a horse in it's bridle to lead it. My personal choice would be a dually with a lunge line, and carry a schooling whip and the horse is made to walk forward, reverse, stand and walk on every time I lead.

Yes it is tough love, but it won;t take long and once he has boundaries I am sure he will be a happier horse.
 
Would your instructor friend come and give you some lessons on the horse? If not, you could do with finding a good local instructor - doesn't have to be a fancy groundwork/parelli instructor - any instructor should be able to help with groundwork as well as riding.

Could he be introduced to another horse, so that he is turned out with it, and then with the herd - it sounds like he is insecure and desperate to be with the other horses.. To be honest, the yard doesn't sound ideal - he could do with a yard with more back up - people you could ride out with. A good yard routine to make him feel secure, other horses to come in and out with until he is used to everywhere, and you are used to him...
 
I have a new horse who I addmit may not be as bad yours but has got away with murder for ages. When I got him, he had seen a farrier twice in 9 months because he refused to stand still for the farrier and their farrier wouldn't tolerate him being a tit! He was sedated for his teeth. He wasn't stabled because he was a loon.
So far with him, I have had the farrier out (slightly fresh for him but that was a week in), Brownmare may say he is a complete git still next week. I had his teeth done on Tuesday and he was a completely saint. He is now stabled over night with no problem and 9 times out of 10 is a saint to turn out!
I think you need to start working with him on the ground and start to learn each others boundaries.
Ollie and I haven't quite got the boundaries figured out, he has started trying to hug people and be the centre of convo :D He does however now fall asleep on your shoulder whilst you stand gassing with ya friends :D
 
Top