Another fatal dog attack

The general direction of discussion is little beyond my knowledge base, but I am following the thread still with interest as I 'think' I am learning something new from people who actually know what they are talking about. Thank you for that, you know who you are.😉

Just a small observation, the straw man method of debate seems hard wired in all areas of debate as I have found out on other threads. I no longer engage - it's just too exhausting for no satisfactory outcome.🙄
 
JFTDWS said:
Nice straw man argument there - I didn't say identifying genetic markers would "solve" anything. I said that it might prove useful in directing legislation and breeding - there's nuance and you missed it. I also didn't say that the threat wasn't a concern - another straw man of yours. I said that it is entirely irrelevant to the act of researching genetics associated with aggression in dogs, which it is. If you want some further nuance you've missed, it's that it's not "impossible" to identify markers of behaviours in humans at all - but it's a bit of an ethical nightmare to do much about it.
Click to expand...
#whyscientistssticktomiceinsteadofhumans
 
The social aspects of why people get certain dog types does really interest me. Does Maisie with 6 kids in a 2 bed really think Blade the XL is going going to thrive in that environment and be a nanny dog because she’ll train it, despite 0 experience? If so why have you called it Blade? At all levels most dogs are ultimately chosen based on fashion, be that social media driven or otherwise.
 
misst said:
Not quite the same potential for unprovoked attack as xlbs. GSDs are reputable working/guarding dogs. I've yet to see an a working Xlb. GSDs are usually carefully bred, though of course, not always.
Click to expand...

Actually I was responding to the couple getting the Cane Corso. I may not have been clear. I've been around several well bred and trained Cane Corso to paint them all with a broad brush.
 
rara007 said:
The social aspects of why people get certain dog types does really interest me. Does Maisie with 6 kids in a 2 bed really think Blade the XL is going going to thrive in that environment and be a nanny dog because she’ll train it, despite 0 experience? If so why have you called it Blade? At all levels most dogs are ultimately chosen based on fashion, be that social media driven or otherwise.
Click to expand...

I chose my dogs for my lifestyle and I do choose what I find pleasing to the eye. Don’t think fashion has anything to do with my choice, terriers and lurcher. There are loads of poodle mixes round here and none of them appeal to me so I suppose they could be called fashion choices. I doubt many on here have chosen for fashion either
 
rara007 said:
The social aspects of why people get certain dog types does really interest me. Does Maisie with 6 kids in a 2 bed really think Blade the XL is going going to thrive in that environment and be a nanny dog because she’ll train it, despite 0 experience? If so why have you called it Blade? At all levels most dogs are ultimately chosen based on fashion, be that social media driven or otherwise.
Click to expand...
I would also be interested in name choices for dogs (or other pets). I didn't name any of my dogs, they came with names and two of them are already on their second names. But Monster's real name is a name that appears often in GSD / malinois / rottweilers used in bitey sports (along with similar names). I wouldn't have associated his name with that type of sport before I joined a dog club that did some. I also doubt it was his previous owner's intention to put him into the "bitey" category.
 
splashgirl45 said:
I chose my dogs for my lifestyle and I do choose what I find pleasing to the eye. Don’t think fashion has anything to do with my choice, terriers and lurcher. There are loads of poodle mixes round here and none of them appeal to me so I suppose they could be called fashion choices. I doubt many on here have chosen for fashion either
Click to expand...
I question myself regularly about how much fashion influenced my choice on dog breeds. I have two of the most popular breeds over here in France (australian shepherd and malinois (cross)) that are also the two breeds most likely to end up in rescues. But then I like medium sized, athletic, intelligent breeds. T the terrier was unplanned and needed somewhere to land. He is more the type of dog I imagined myself getting in a couple of decades.
 
You don’t think terriers and lurchers are fashion based but what proportion of horsey households have those. They’re pretty high up there after the classic Labrador or spaniel. The animals we chose are an extension of our image, even the ropey street dog of no definite breed is a choice to take on.
I say that with a rehome spaniel that goes on a rope but doesn’t work…! (And even if he did work in some capacity beyond companion, that’s again another choice…!)
 
Last edited:
rara007 said:
You don’t think terriers and lurchers are fashion based but what proportion of horsey households have those. They’re pretty high up there after the classic Labrador or spaniel. The animals we chose are an extension of our image, even the ropey street dog of no definite breed is a choice to take on.
I say that with a rehome spaniel that goes on a rope but doesn’t work…! (And even if he did work in some capacity beyond companion, that’s again another choice…!)
Click to expand...
Jack russells are practically a feature at every horse competition. You can't go anywhere without stepping on one. I find it interesting that depending on the venue, some breeds are more popular than others. Where I go, at one it's staffies, at another, it's malinois (I jokingly asked if they'd got a group discount on them, it turned out the RS owned a female that they bred from and sold the pups to their clients), aussies are pretty much ubiquitous and preferably blue merle.
 
I'm Dun said:
I read a paper last week about the huge influence the media has. I guess with XLs its all the idiots calling them nanny dogs.
Click to expand...

And the influence of the social media algorithms which push similar content toward people who have shown interest in a certain type of content, creating an echo chamber. You could easily be innundated with influencer posts about "nanny dogs" and never see the content about attacks, if you consume media primarily through those channels.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top