I put my pony to sleep - this is my story.

thistledonicely

Well-Known Member
Joined
27 January 2011
Messages
197
Visit site
Hi - I wasn't sure whether to write all this down, but I'm not coping very well since saying goodbye to my pony and thought getting things off my chest might help me lay her to rest.

It's not something I found easy to talk about at the time and as a result I faced a number of hostile reactions at the yard which haven't helped me deal with the more difficult thoughts, but I'm hoping writing this 'confessional' might help me move on. (There were also many lovely supportive people too who I am very grateful to).

My Little Pony (MLP) had a number of mental and physical complaints that had troubled her all her life. Her stomach problems, while managed as best as possible, were never fully resolved beyond believing them to be genetic. The treatment options left were to medicate and increase the risk of colic or faecal transplant with no way of knowing how long or often it would be effective. She was also a seasonal head-shaker which I managed through a combination of nets, gels and masks but there was no disguising the fact that she was uncomfortable in bright sunlight. I tried a combination of different bridles to minimise discomfort and after consultation with the vet the condition was largely untreatable and manageable at best. So physically, MLP was in some degree of discomfort at different ends of the year: digestion in winter on hay and head in summer.

Being stabled overnight didn’t particularly suit MLP as she tended to become quite boisterous, however it was a compromise to control her fibre intake and minimise her digestive problems. Last summer I turned her out with a grazing muzzle; she was pleasant to ride and seemed happier within herself. Having read that muzzles can affect chewing I had the dentist check her teeth throughout the summer - her front teeth were being worn across the front which could eventually wear right through to the root with prolonged use. I hoped for enough regrowth over the winter to counteract the effects of muzzling, but sadly it hadn’t.

I enlisted the help of a behaviour specialist to address MLP's aversion to loading with a view to having her travelling happily so we could get her to hospital for faecal transplants. A fellow HHOer suggested that endurance riding might help offset some of the living-in effects so I planned to go along to some fun rides. However, despite an (eventually) successful session my attempts to follow it up were a disaster, it was as if we were back at square one again. MLP had been a difficult loader all her life and on one occasion had injured someone which resulted in a trip to hospital, so I knew I was in for an uphill struggle but I had hoped after putting in so much effort we would have got further than we did.

The ridden behaviour was really I suppose the straw that broke the camel’s back. She could be quite strong-willed and had always been nappy but laterally, it was getting increasingly more frequent (both in company and alone) and on the occcasion she reared and fell I had to admit to myself that we were not a partnership that was safe anymore. This was not the first time she’d gone skywards to evade having done it under saddle and in-hand a number of times over the years (intermittently, but always when being asked a question, usually to walk sensibly!). For a long time I held myself responsible for our shortcomings but after continued input from instructors and other professionals, I slowly came to see that MLP was herself quite a tricky mare with strong opinions and sharp reactions to most things that troubled her regardless of her rider/handler.

I know there were avenues that we could have perhaps explored further and I did not dismiss these without careful consideration. However I arrived at the same point, having rebuilt my confidence with MLP once before (after a series of falls in quick succession), I couldn’t be sure I’d be able to again. Taking her health into consideration she was not a pony that was ever going to be sold and without the means or set up to keep a horse in an indefinite retirement that left me with a very difficult decision to face up to. It was a process which took many months to reach the end of.

I felt caught between a rock and a hard place with a horse that wasn’t happy physically living out 24/7 but who wasn’t happy mentally being stabled a portion of the time. With the management options so limited to try to address the boisterous behaviour, I couldn’t knowingly exacerbate a health problem to combat another which was, ultimately, for my benefit ie. riding.

MLP was incredibly special to me and the hardest part of the whole process has been seeing that life was always compromised for her. She couldn’t help her conditions and didn’t ask to be ridden or fiddled about with by a human! I miss her terribly and my heart brakes that I couldn’t have given her better but there is comfort in knowing she had a life of kindness.

She was 12 and absolutely adored for 6 years.

Thank you for reading.
 

ozpoz

Well-Known Member
Joined
31 August 2010
Messages
2,677
Visit site
She was obviously one of the lucky ones, loved and cared for till the end, the hardest part for any owner.

I feel so sorry that people at your yard weren't supportive to a fellow owner. Only lack of experience on their part can excuse them. x
 

Spottyappy

Well-Known Member
Joined
5 September 2008
Messages
3,596
Location
Home counties
Visit site
So sorry to read this.
I feel There is no way should you feel you have to explain or justify your decisions to other livery owners. They would no doubt allow their horse to suffer because they weren't brave enough to make the right decision for the animal and not themselves.
You absolutely exhausted all suitable forms of keeping the mare happy, and made the right decision for her.
As to the liveries, I hope if you decide to get another horse, you will consider a move to a much more supportive yard.
Thinking of you at this time.
 

Magnetic Sparrow

Well-Known Member
Joined
1 November 2010
Messages
2,017
Visit site
There will always be someone who will accuse you of giving up on a horse, but to me it sounds like you did far more than most people would have done to try and get your mare comfortable and happy. It wasn't to be and you decided that the kindest thing was to say goodbye. I think you made the right call from the best of motives.
 

JackJill

Well-Known Member
Joined
27 January 2009
Messages
321
Visit site
All I can say is you did your absolute best for your pony, it's sad others can't see that. Time is a great healer believe me. I'm so sorry for your loss.
 

Emilieu

Well-Known Member
Joined
25 August 2011
Messages
3,488
Location
up near Glasgow
Visit site
I totally agree about lack of experience being the only excuse. Before i knew what it was to properly love a horse i might have judged someone with a story like yours, now I understand the bravery. Bless you. Have a hug xx
 

numptynoelle

Well-Known Member
Joined
26 July 2009
Messages
6,753
Location
North of the Wall
Visit site
You absolutely did the best thing for your pony. It might take time for your heart and head to reconcile that fact, but you totally did. Any pony would be lucky to have you as an owner - it really is the greatest power we hold, and the greatest kindness that we can bestow. Be kind to yourself.
 

mytwofriends

Well-Known Member
Joined
11 June 2010
Messages
1,381
Location
SW
Visit site
You absolutely did everything humanely possible for your little pony. How unfair of people not to be supportive. What gave them the right to be judge and jury?

You know you did everything right, and no-one can take that away from you.

Your pony had the best owner. Treasure your happy times together, and like a poster above has already said, if you decide to get another, maybe consider whether your current yard is right for you.
 

AdorableAlice

Well-Known Member
Joined
24 October 2011
Messages
13,051
Visit site
If only every horse had an owner like you. Thoughtful, caring and prepared to go to the ends of the earth to do the right thing. Rise above anything that is said. Be proud of the love and care you gave your mare, she would have known you loved her and helped her. It was the right decision and a very brave one. She is out of pain and at peace.

When the time is right there is another horse somewhere crying out for a lovely owner like you.
 

honetpot

Well-Known Member
Joined
27 July 2010
Messages
9,435
Location
Cambridgeshire
Visit site
I am very fortunate that I own my own land and can tinker with management regimes but its so tough on a livery yard where you have to fit in to a norm with 'the experts' putting in with their opinions. For most of us its in our nature to want to fix things and the hardest thing is to realise the problem is unfixable. I am sorry that you had to make this decision but you are not alone and quite a few of us will be making the same call. Hugs
 

Spilletta

Well-Known Member
Joined
11 November 2013
Messages
509
Location
Oxfordshire
Visit site
I really don't like hearing how some people give responsible owners a hard time for putting a horse to sleep. OP, I think it sounds like you couldn't have reasonably done anything else. Your horse is safe, you know where she is - she can rest in peace. Take care, OP.
 

SatansLittleHelper

Well-Known Member
Joined
27 December 2011
Messages
5,762
Location
Shropshire
Visit site
OP I'm really sorry for your loss.
Your pony was incredibly lucky to have had you and FWIW, I think you did the right thing. I hope you are getting support from somewhere, you don't deserve to be judged harshly. Huge hugs xxx
 

thistledonicely

Well-Known Member
Joined
27 January 2011
Messages
197
Visit site
I'm very touched to read all the replies, thank you. What a lovely bunch!

The folk with negative reactions were the minority but when you're feeling vulnerable it's often the most harmful words that stick and then take the longest to wrench off the memories isn't it? There were a lot of kind words too and I have support from lovely friends and family.

It's really helped to see it all in black and white. As someone said it's awful when you realise things aren't fixable... But MLP was very loved and taught me ever-such-a-lot.
 

Remi'sMum

Well-Known Member
Joined
6 February 2015
Messages
451
Visit site
Hugs to you OP, you are clearly a kind, thoughtful and very knowledgable owner. As others have said, lack of experience is the only excuse for any negativity you've had to endure, coupled with an appalling lack of tact and sensitivity. Rest in peace MLP x
 

fabbydo

Well-Known Member
Joined
8 June 2015
Messages
541
Visit site
I usually find that those who criticise a pts decision either have never been in that situation themselves or don't have the full facts. Don't be hard on yourself. It really, really hurts but you know you were right. Couldn't read and run. Sending hugs x
 

YorksG

Over the hill and far awa
Joined
14 September 2006
Messages
16,201
Location
West Yorkshire
Visit site
While it was hard for you it was the last kindness you could do for you pony. I wish all owners were as kind as you, I heard today of a thin, toothless 30 year old pony, with severe laminitus, whos owners are currently not taking the advice of their vet and farrier, to put an end to the suffering of the pony, I wish the owner in that case were as kind as you have been.
 

JJS

Well-Known Member
Joined
10 September 2013
Messages
2,045
Visit site
As you probably already know, both napping ('glass wall syndrome') and rearing in hand and under saddle are often symptoms of head shaking, so it seems likely that her condition may well have been deteriorating. I have a head shaker of my own, and horses with this condition are almost always on borrowed time, with their comfort steadily deteriorating, and their range of triggers increasing as the years pass. It is a truly horrible illness, and many others have made the same choice as you when confronted with it. Although my gelding is currently retired and turned away with minimal handling, I'm fully aware that one day in a year, or two, or even ten, I might have to make the same decision, and it's not one that I envy you for facing. You did what you felt was best for her, as the person who loved her most in the entire world, and no one should ever judge you for that.
 
Last edited:

LadySam

Well-Known Member
Joined
14 August 2016
Messages
857
Location
South. Very south.
Visit site
I'm so sorry you've had people put you through the wringer over this when the situation is difficult enough as it is. There's no doubt you did the right thing for your pony. Your thoughts were only for her quality of life and your decision was a brave and loving one.
 

turkana

Well-Known Member
Joined
2 July 2009
Messages
1,147
Visit site
How very sad, I had tears in my eyes reading it, the poor pony and poor you.
Take no notice of the people at the yard, you did nothing wrong, she was lucky to find herself in your hands.
Stay away from that yard, they are idiots.
 

Dolsey1

Active Member
Joined
13 March 2010
Messages
41
Visit site
Oh gosh, I could have written this myself. It's heartbreaking but I know we did the right thing, even if others don't agree. Most people would have bred from her, but not knowing whether her issues were caused by something hereditary it was not worth the risk of inflicting the same problems upon another horse.
 

pansymouse

Well-Known Member
Joined
11 May 2012
Messages
2,736
Location
Amesbury, Wiltshire
Visit site
You are a responsible and compassionate owner who after doing everything practically possible for your horse made the hardest and bravest decision. People who don't understand that are not worthy of your time or consideration.
 

KAZJAZ

Well-Known Member
Joined
11 December 2009
Messages
168
Location
South West Scotland
Visit site
Sorry for your loss, you absolutely done the right thing by your pony, you put her welfare/quality of life first, its easy for others to say they would do different, they aren't the ones living in your situation day in/day out.

Its the hardest & yet bravest thing you can do although it wont feel like it now and it will take a long time to recover from, it does get easier x
 
Top