Dressage Something to think about whilst the storm rages

oldie48

Well-Known Member
Joined
15 April 2013
Messages
7,056
Location
South Worcestershire
Visit site
This popped up on my FB (thanks to Shellie Harris) and I thought I'd share. As you probably have guessed I have huge respect and admiration for AK, I've spent hours watching him train riders at all levels on all types of horses. So much of this resonated with me but not everyone will agree however I love to hear other's opinions. That's how we learn.
Adam Kemp presented the flatwork section alongside Barrel racer Nicole Aichele.
Here are the top 12 Kemp Quips from the International Eventing Forum 2020
1) ‘It takes 7 years to become a rocket scientist and I have been trying to be a horseman for over 40 years and I am still not there yet. Horsemanship is difficult because you are dealing with an animal that has its own brain. Understanding horses is science, understanding an individual horse is for me, horsemanship.’
2) ‘There is a difference between common sense, experience and horsemanship. Experience is not enough. We have all been kicked clipping, that is experience and horsemanship is when you have the experience and realise what it is that sets that horse off to kick you.’
3) ‘People are so busy doing dressage, that they are not remembering that they need to ride. They are so busy jumping fences that they have forgotten that they need to ride their horse. We have lost a lot of basic riding skills.’
‘Riding Grand Prix test – the difference between 86% and 46% is basic riding skills applied at the right time on a well-trained horse to produce results.’
4) ‘Everyone thinks they have the most intelligent horse in the world to match their kid. What they have is 600kg of dumb animal like we have all got. You might have one who is more intelligent than another horse, but its still a horse. A horse is academically stupid but they are reactively bright. So, you need to capitalise on what they can do, which is react. What they cannot do is problem solve because they are herd animals. The herd makes a decision. They cannot help being flighty or spooky as you bought a flight animal.’
‘If you cannot get a flight animal to go forward then something is wrong as that is what they do.’
5) ‘An awful lot of people we teach are not capable of educating a horse because they have not actually learnt how to ride one. Until you can do the right thing, at the right time, in the right language then you cannot be an educator.’
‘The reins are there to communicate your wishes to the horse, your legs are there to tell him to do something else. What you need your horse to learn early on is that when you move your body there is something that your horse is not doing that you would like him to be doing and that is the beginning of communication.’
6) ‘The horseman will be told by the horse how to ride him. The non- horseman will be told by social media how to ride him. Jumping is easier because the horse can see the jump. A dressage riders job is harder because they cannot see the size of a circle or how steep a half pass is until its too late. Jumping has a slight advantage as the horse can see the jump and as long as the rider enables the horse to do its job and think for itself then its going to be ok. A horse cannot do a canter pirouette on its own because it doesn’t know how small the circle needs to be. Your job is to say to the horse there is a problem coming and this is the solution.’
7) ‘If a horse was intellectually our equal, you would not be up there on top, we would not get a foot through the door. Why would they do this? Its utterly pointless, 25 minutes cantering around to end up back where you started! We are good at saying to ourselves oh but they really love it, do they? They like to please us.’
? ‘Horses are not unpredictable, they are just unpredicted.’
‘If I could invent a new sport I would call it horse influencing. At a certain point in a rider’s career we could upgrade it to dressage.’
9) ‘The animal you are educating is very simple. That is not easy to ride. Your pupils are always looking for the reason they cannot do it. They have been to the vet, the physio, they have the new saddle and the horse is just as confused. I say to them now is that the reason you are struggling is because its difficult. They might have physical issues; every horse has physical issues and lameness but either they incapable and lame so stop trying or accept what he is and make him better at it. But you cannot do that if you cannot ride.’
10) ‘The thing that stands in the way of 99% of the people I teach is that when they are struggling the thing that would stop them struggling the most is for them to ride better. A new saddle will help you ride better, the physio makes it possible to ride better. But you still need to ride better.’
‘That’s the message I want to give out, you are not riding well enough because if you were then you would get the same score as Charlotte.’
11) ‘This horse has just started competing at PSG, but as you see when he gets tense he misses the odd change and makes mistakes, we just need to ride better, or have his back X rayed. I think riding better will be cheaper.’
‘Every time I am on a horse, I am educating and trying to improve our partnership.’ Eric added that he sees far too often horses hacking and not paying attention on the aids. The next day they are asked to concentrate. The thought process of every time you ride the horse it should be on duty is the right one.
Pammy Hutton asked if Adam could give his view on how to improve riders and what he is going to do?
12) ‘I would like people to remember what riding means and what that is. I have so many riders who say I want it to feel like this, or that, or the other. I tell them that’s not what riding a horse feels like. Its like saying I want to dance but I don’t want to move. Riding a horse doesn’t feel how you think it does. The first time you have a good medium change, they don’t like it. The first time they do a correct flying change, they like the one which is late behind and slips through because it feels nice. I tell them nice isn’t one of the scales of training. Riding a horse – the front-end bites, the back-end kicks and the middle is uncomfortable. That is where you start. Teaching a rider what it means and how to influence is important. Teaching what is correct and incorrect is difficult because we keep changing what we think of as correct. I learnt to influence horses on the worst horses possible because without intervention it would have ended up in tears. Teaching riders that dressage and riding is not the same thing. Dressage is defined as a highly skilled variation of horse riding and that is not what I see all day in the arena. It is largely people that are not brave enough to ride, so they do dressage instead and we have spent 20 years developing that into a sport that we can no longer actually tolerate. We have to find a way of getting to people riding correctly before they qualify for this championship and that championship and thinking they have a right to ride at the Nationals. We have told too many people they have a right to ride at the National championships and instead we should be telling them that you need to ride better and when they can do that they will get to the Nationals.’
 
He's my regular trainer and I find him the complete opposite of condescending, I take all my wacky projects and he trains everyone with an open heart and total focus.

I think one of his great strengths is being able to de-mystify a discipline that some other people seem to make great efforts to over complicate. When all is said and done it can't be complicated because you can achieve amazing things with an animal that doesn't talk, all by wiggling your arms, legs and bum ?
 
He's my regular trainer and I find him the complete opposite of condescending, I take all my wacky projects and he trains everyone with an open heart and total focus.

I think one of his great strengths is being able to de-mystify a discipline that some other people seem to make great efforts to over complicate. When all is said and done it can't be complicated because you can achieve amazing things with an animal that doesn't talk, all by wiggling your arms, legs and bum ?


I didn't say he was condescending MP, I don't know the chap at all. It's just how that statement seemed to me...

It reminded me of an SJ trainer here, who was patently fed up at having to reach Mr fluffy legs and I at a clinic last year.

Fiona
 
I have always absolutely loved the words of Littlelegs' (HHO'er's) employer; 'If you don't sit in the right place, how will the horse know what you want? And if by some miracle it happens to do what you want, how will it know thta's what you wanted?'
It was interspersed with several swear words which HHO used not to like, so they had to be taken out and it doesn't quite have the same impact without them but I'm sure you get the gist.
 
I think it’s so true. I strive to ride better as only then can my horse go as well for me as he can for better riders. I am guilty though of not working him out hacking just dossing a long. Must try to remember that.
 
I really did hesitate to share this because they are notes taken from a demo. I wondered if I should edit, but I wasn't there so felt I shouldn't. However, there is so much there that is worth thinking about and which tie in to a number of threads that have been on the forum recently. And no, condescending is the last word I'd use. Honest, funny and supremely talented as a trainer and as engaged with an elderly lady on a fat pony as an international rider competing at GP.
 
I was at the demo and the notes accurately reflect what he said!

I know and have trained with AK so I know he is one of the least condescending trainers out there - and he is bloody good.

What he said in the demo had me chuckling because a) it’s true b) I’m one of them and c) it resonates with my slightly dry and self-depreciating sense of humour.

But there was a point at which I thought ‘careful, you are at risk of belittling your main source of income’
 
It’s just a more adult/complicated version of what I repeatedly say to my children - it isn’t the pony, it’s you! Give the poor creature some instructions it can follow, in a language it understands, and praise it when it does what you want, so it knows that was the right response! And...everything you do is teaching your pony. You can teach it to snatch for grass or canter a wonky circle or refuse to go, just as much as you can teach it to do the right things!
 
Oh, I cannot tell you how much I agree with what he said, although it will make an awful lot of people quite uncomfortable, I would think :):cool::oops::cool::cool:
I think good training should make you uncomfortable at times, there are too many people out there who are willing to tell you that you're doing OK (when you are not) and are happy to take your money. Training needs to challenge you, make you think and on occasions get you to do things you think you can't. TBH if people can't accept they need to ride better to improve their horse then they should stop doing dressage because done properly it is a very difficult discipline (it did take me a while to appreciate this!).
 
I dont train with Adam, but I do know him, and he couldnt be further away from condescending if he tried, it really is the last thing I would ever think of in conjunction with him.

Whilst I agree with Tristar, and I dont ever call horses either dumb or stupid, I do really agree with everything else he says, yes, its not comfortable, and I'm sure quite a few people may be offended by it, but its basically true.
 
I watched a bit of a video clip of the demo the day after, and while it's not a nice word to use, objectively a horse is "academically" stupid ;) they are clever in their own ways but I think it's helpful to remember that they think in different ways to us and understand things differently.

One of the things I like about Adam is how he translates the issues each rider brings into the horse's language and unpicks a problem from the POV of the horse. Telling a rider to do x y or z is only part of the puzzle, it's also helpful to remember what motivates the horse underneath them or why it might be reacting the way it does. With my tricky welshie, he is always quick to point out that she thinks she's in the right, and that she IS because it's us trying to get her to do stuff that is totally un-natural. Personally I have found the 2 pronged approach to be fairly uncommon. I've had a lot of transactional type instruction, and I have worked with people who "speak horse" but to get the 2 from one person is what makes lessons so productive.

I agree that a good trainer should be able to give home truths. I have had that from other people but in a format that left me basically so confused that I didn't know how to ride any more and took all the pleasure out of it. I don't mind being told I just need to do it better (that was the gist of my lesson last week!) so long as it comes with clear instructions of how to achieve that :)
 
Good rider, good horse trainer. A whole other thread probably! A supremely good rider can get on almost anything and make it look amazing. A really good trainer can make that same horse look just as amazing for any reasonably competent rider, working round any physical issues along the way.
 
I was about confused about this quote "People are so busy doing dressage, that they are not remembering that they need to ride. They are so busy jumping fences that they have forgotten that they need to ride their horse. We have lost a lot of basic riding skills."
Isn't dressage and jumping part of learning how to ride? In the sense that low level dressage tests whether the horse does what you tell it to and jumping small fences helps with balance and helps someone learn with to ride with impulsion.
 
Last edited:
Horses are not the deep thinkers of the animal kingdom: they are reactors. So in that sense, yes they are "stupid", but they are awfully good at being horses, so it is up to us to figure out how to communicate with them and deal with the "horseness".
 
I was about confused about this quote "People are so busy doing dressage, that they are not remembering that they need to ride. They are so busy jumping fences that they have forgotten that they need to ride their horse. We have lost a lot of basic riding skills."
Isn't dressage and jumping part of learning how to ride? In the sense that low level dressage tests test basic riding ability and jumping small fences helps with balance and helps someone learn with to ride with impulsion.
I would not want to put words in his mouth but when we have had similar discussions it was meant in the wider sense of riding being more than getting from A-B over a fence, or doing a movement in dressage. More about properly understanding your horse, it understanding you, successful training and communication etc. Horsemanship rather than piloting.

Anyone can steer round a dressage test - I did that yesterday. But it wasn't really *riding*. I was sitting on his back and going walk-trot-canter in more or less the right places but it wasn't particularly skillful or effective. How often do we watch Badminton and have a thread on here where someone is riding by the seat of their pants, and the next person makes it all look super easy. I think that's the difference.
 
I would not want to put words in his mouth but when we have had similar discussions it was meant in the wider sense of riding being more than getting from A-B over a fence, or doing a movement in dressage. More about properly understanding your horse, it understanding you, successful training and communication etc. Horsemanship rather than piloting.

Anyone can steer round a dressage test - I did that yesterday. But it wasn't really *riding*. I was sitting on his back and going walk-trot-canter in more or less the right places but it wasn't particularly skillful or effective. How often do we watch Badminton and have a thread on here where someone is riding by the seat of their pants, and the next person makes it all look super easy. I think that's the difference.
I understand now. I'm definitely guilty of piloting when jumping courses. I find stuff like my attention to corners deteriorates because I'm so busy staring at the jumps :D
 
Last edited:
I understand now. I'm definitely guilty of piloting when jumping courses. I find stuff like my attention to corners deteriorates because I'm so busy staring at the jumps:D
I think that is exactly the point :) and we all do it and we all have to work at it ;) it's something I find really really fascinating about riding and training myself and my horse. training the mental discipline and the muscle memory etc as well as learning the exercises or (in a past life) jumping the fences.
 
I think that is exactly the point :) and we all do it and we all have to work at it ;) it's something I find really really fascinating about riding and training myself and my horse. training the mental discipline and the muscle memory etc as well as learning the exercises or (in a past life) jumping the fences.
Absolutely, I've heard people say that jumping is just dressage with fences. I understand what they mean but if my show jumping rounds were judged like a dressage test the marks would be hilarious :D
 
I think good training should make you uncomfortable at times, there are too many people out there who are willing to tell you that you're doing OK (when you are not) and are happy to take your money. Training needs to challenge you, make you think and on occasions get you to do things you think you can't. TBH if people can't accept they need to ride better to improve their horse then they should stop doing dressage because done properly it is a very difficult discipline (it did take me a while to appreciate this!).


TBH, if people can't accept that the way they ride influences their horses' way of going, they should stop riding, never mind doing dressage. They would be better off with a bike!
 
Top