horse communicators and reason out the window

M

Mr Nick

Active Member
Joined
11 December 2012
Messages
39
Visit site
how is it that normally sane and rational people let their reason go out of the window when it comes to horse communicators?

Now Ive heard about a lot of rubbish spouted by these people but one has told someone I know (and have a lot of respect for) that their horse is homophobic. REally. And I think she may be buying it.:eek:
 
Mr Nick said:
how is it that normally sane and rational people let their reason go out of the window when it comes to horse communicators?

Now Ive heard about a lot of rubbish spouted by these people but one has told someone I know (and have a lot of respect for) that their horse is homophobic. REally. And I think she may be buying it.:eek:
Click to expand...

At an old yard a woman had this done, my dad deciding to be hilarious crouched behind back then my mums horses stable and shouted " she's talking out her arse" followed by a neigh :o

true though, it's all about money.
 
oh god yes - I know someone else who sent a photo and had a consultation over the phone. I'd forgotten about that particular madness
 
Because they are either at the end of their tether with said horse and grasping for straws or like to think their horse is not normal when sometimes just good handling sorts it out take your pick.:)
 
tessybear said:
At an old yard a woman had this done, my dad deciding to be hilarious crouched behind back then my mums horses stable and shouted " she's talking out her arse" followed by a neigh :o

true though, it's all about money.
Click to expand...
How very rude!
What on earth has it got to do with your father how this lady spends her money? Would he behave in that manner if any other visitor came to the yard? I imagine YO would have something to say if it became a habit!
 
Pearlsasinger said:
How very rude!
What on earth has it got to do with your father how this lady spends her money? Would he behave in that manner if any other visitor came to the yard? I imagine YO would have something to say if it became a habit!
Click to expand...

Oh terribly was great though if you have a sense of humour :rolleyes: of course not because normal visitors do not pay stupid amounts to spew bs at people :)
 
Someone on our old yard was told that her horse (lovely thing) was distraught from having been separated from her foal. Horse had never had a foal and owned since a foal. Communicator then said she'd lost a foal. Owner started concocting stories about stallions escaping, having their way and then losing foal.

Reminds me of seeing a medium. I was open, but the questions coming out and clutching at straws was awful... Friend with me fell for it hook line and sinker.
That being said I've seen one who was genuinely incredible whether a cold reader or more... He earned his money.
 
Always have been doubtful regarding this, i mean if they really could communicate with animals why are they not vets ? or working alongside vets and do something useful with it rather than telling an owner their horse is gay ?:confused:
 
Because to be a vet they'd have to put time and effort into getting onto a course and gaining some exams, whereas as a communicator they can charge money for nothing....
 
Honey08 said:
Because to be a vet they'd have to put time and effort into getting onto a course and gaining some exams, whereas as a communicator they can charge money for nothing....
Click to expand...

so painfuly true :) but hey that's my opinion if people want to spend their money on a communicator be my guest i know it would be better spent on feed, bedding, treats for said horse IMO :)
 
Pearlsasinger said:
How very rude!
What on earth has it got to do with your father how this lady spends her money? Would he behave in that manner if any other visitor came to the yard? I imagine YO would have something to say if it became a habit!
Click to expand...

Of course fleecing the desperate and the credulous is not rude, merely taking the piss out of those fleecing the desperate and the credulousis rude! :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
tessybear said:
Always have been doubtful regarding this, i mean if they really could communicate with animals why are they not vets ? or working alongside vets and do something useful with it rather than telling an owner their horse is gay ?:confused:
Click to expand...

laughing at this TB - she didnt say the horse was gay, she said he was homophobic!
For gods sake dont tell him we think he's a big ole gayer
 
I had an experiance with one I am a serious non believer but this was a wierd experiance .
I was having an awful problem with a horse who I was considering having PTS a very serious competitor ( as in has won medals ) said he had used one and it had been a good experiance and he felt I should give it a go his view was it cost £50 which was nothing in comparison with what I had spent on the vets so far.
So I thought what the hell and rang I told the woman that the horse was not right etc etc that she was a homebred that was all.
I sent her a photo from my home and a chq I thought better not tell my OH this .at the allotted time she rang me told me various things about the horse which where interesting including that she fell down on the concrete while she was away and that it hurt which was interesting as that's what thevets and physio thought the injury they where trying to fix was most likely caused by as lip and fall on the hard.
Then as the consultation finished she said I don't know if you are open to this but some horses are here that have passed over recently they want to tell you things are you open to this I was a bit surprised but thought what the hell I had had two put down just before ( bad year that) so I said what do they say she said its a grey mare and a chestnut gelding ( spot on ) they say they are together and we are fine and the gelding said I can see ( he was PTS as he went blind) now I was a bit spooked by this when she said suddenly they say they are going another more important is coming then she said when you sit on the wall in the evening and think of me I am there .
I was so shocked I could not talk my horse of a lifetime had a stable where you could sit on the wall and talk to the horse I often sit on it in the evening when I am alone and listern to the horses eating and yes I think of her .
I ended the call quickly and headed for a darkened room .
I still don't know what to make of the experiance , I never gave her any details about these horses or the sitting on the wall thing which was something I did alone no one knew about it .
 
yeah you're about as good as me. Let me see....yes he likes hay, likes his field ...but he does like to come in at tea time. £50 please?
 
I think its a load of codswhollop if you ask me!
It is completely unregulated and to be able to communicate over the phone or from a picture is rediculous!!!

A yard i was at told me my elderly stallion missed the company of mares....I hadnt asked them to come out but someone at the yard did. I politely informed them my 4 year old mare was just fine and dandy. :)
 
I've never paid to have an animal communicator but by strange coincidence on 3 occasions Reiki healers have been around and offered to do some Reiki, twice on horses and once on my dog.

Each time, they have told me things about the horses and the dog that I'd completely forgotten about and seemed of no consequence at the time.
There was also quite a remarkable physical or behavioural response after being seen.

I still wouldn't look for and pay for any type of communicator but my experiences have been very odd, in a positive way.


BTW, I also find Tessy bears father very rude. Embarrassing someone because you disagree with them isn't funny.
 
Delicious_D said:
I think its a load of codswhollop if you ask me!
It is completely unregulated and to be able to communicate over the phone or from a picture is rediculous!!!

A yard i was at told me my elderly stallion missed the company of mares....I hadnt asked them to come out but someone at the yard did. I politely informed them my 4 year old mare was just fine and dandy. :)
Click to expand...

:D what did they say after out of interest ?
 
They told me they were just telling me what the horse was telling them. I muttered under my breath the horse was telling me she was bats but wish i had said it louder!

Said communicator then instructed my friend to put their two horses on a long course of a certain herb as they were very anxious and feared they might lose said friend as their owner....
 
If the communications were damaging their horses, I could see the need for people to voice their concerns. How others spend their money in ways which are none invasive is none of anyone elses business. If they were spending their money on training methods which they didn't understand, spending a fortune on over molassed rubbish feeds etc, then I could see the point of making comment, although hopefully not of the 'she's talking out of her backside' type, which isn't humerous, just obnoxious and childish, but how others spend their money in a way which causes no harm, is none of anyone elses business.
 
Delicious_D said:
I think its a load of codswhollop if you ask me!
It is completely unregulated and to be able to communicate over the phone or from a picture is rediculous!!!

A yard i was at told me my elderly stallion missed the company of mares....I hadnt asked them to come out but someone at the yard did. I politely informed them my 4 year old mare was just fine and dandy. :)
Click to expand...

Of course it's ridiculous but my experiance is ture and was genuinely very very strange .
What regulation has got to do with it I am not sure people should spend their money as they choose no need to regulate everything.
 
I dont think i am obnoxius or childish. I dont believe in it, but can understand why some might. our brains look for patterns and i suspect if we are desperate for a solution or reason, we will cling onto any hope of an answer.

ETA - i added regulations because the only communicator i came across constantly prescribed herbs etc for owners horses.
 
Delicious_D said:
I dont think i am obnoxius or childish. I dont believe in it, but can understand why some might. our brains look for patterns and i suspect if we are desperate for a solution or reason, we will cling onto any hope of an answer.
Click to expand...

The comment about obnoxious and childish was in respons to the comment by Tessybears father.
 
Evil father :rolleyes: :D Must add though she was, told woman her horse had been badly abused when 5 for a period of 6 months, owner had horse since a a yearling till she was 7 :p Owner also agreed with evil fathers comment later
 
horserider said:
BTW, I also find Tessy bears father very rude. Embarrassing someone because you disagree with them isn't funny.
Click to expand...

He wasn't embarrassing someone because he disagreed with them, he was calling them out for being a fraud.

Imagine for a moment that you can communicate with animals, what would you do with this ability?

- you could help find all the stolen horses by just asking them where they are

- you could help avoid loads of welfare cases by having the horses report their owners straight to the welfare authorities

- you could have any horse involved in an accident give you the location of its unconscious rider

the list goes on. Instead you decide to charge people to tell them inanities - you are either a fraud or immoral.
 
Delicious_D said:
I dont think i am obnoxius or childish. I dont believe in it, but can understand why some might. our brains look for patterns and i suspect if we are desperate for a solution or reason, we will cling onto any hope of an answer.

ETA - i added regulations because the only communicator i came across constantly prescribed herbs etc for owners horses.
Click to expand...

She did not perscribe anything she suggested that someone feed dried plants to their horse not the same thing if the person was fool enough to feed them that's their choice .
I was not desperate for a solution more curious because the man who persuaded me to try was no ones idea of a desparate fool .
It is still one of the most spooky strange experiances I have ever had.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top