Welcome to HHO Towing Clinic

JenHunt

Well-Known Member
Joined
14 November 2007
Messages
7,049
Location
Thirsk, North Yorkshire, UK
Visit site
a different sort of a question....

we currently tow an old wooden ward trailer (with extra thick floor boards), c. 1500kg empty with a Merc M380 (very fuel thirsty, and coming to the end of its life) to carry 2 big horses (650 and 680kg) who don't travel/fit well in an Ifor 511 (one is too wide, the other is too long).

We are looking at the options for as and when the vehicle does get to the end of its life...

What would people advise? All drivers have B+E or are exempt having passed their test in the 70s. Only doing a max of 3000miles a year with horses. Trailer is currently stored under cover, and so would any replacements be.

Not averse to getting a small van type box, but feel it would be cheaper to get a second hand 4x4 and lighter weight trailer for the mileage we do.....
 

ROG

Well-Known Member
Joined
8 January 2010
Messages
8,934
Location
LEICESTER
Visit site
I cannot help with vehicle options so you may be better to post a seperate thread on the site or perhaps take a look at the bottom link in my signature below
 

catherine22

Well-Known Member
Joined
3 January 2006
Messages
1,075
Location
New forest
Visit site
I looked on internet but could not find GVW for your model so well done you

2350 + 2584 = 4934 so well over the 3500 B limit

You could down plate the trailer to 1150 but as it weighs 1000 empty you could only load 150 kg into it !!!!!!!!!!!!!!

ROG, Would I be able to tow this set up (Pajero and 510) empty - for example to take it to be serviced or would that still be over?
 

KdyK

New User
Joined
8 March 2011
Messages
5
Location
Home: Hampshire, Uni: Surrey
Visit site
Hi ROG,

wonder if you can help me. I'm in the market for a 4x4 and trailer. I have not decided on either yet, I would just like to try and get my head around what the rules and regs are so I don't have to ask you every possible combination!!

So far what I have gleaned from skimming this thread is:
* Trailer MAM (5) must not exceed Unladen weight of the Car (2) [is this correct? All the trailers I've seen have MAM around 1900-2400kg, but the unladen weights of all the cars (I have a spreadsheet!) are anywehere from 1490kg(Skoda Yeti) to 1780kg (Hyundai Tucson)]
* GVW of the Car (3) + Trailer MAM (5) cannot exceed 3500kg for a B License [currently all I hold, but I am not against saving up to get my B+E in the future]

Anything else I should be looking at? (Beyond obviously not towing more than the car legally can!!!)

I am so far looking at variations on the Sportage, Qashqai, X-Trail, Tiguan (surprisingly meaty!), Tucson and Yeti. Any other suggestions? Needs to be relatively civilised on fuel as I will most like use it as my main car and I drive ~60miles a day!

Thanks in advance for any help!
 

ROG

Well-Known Member
Joined
8 January 2010
Messages
8,934
Location
LEICESTER
Visit site
Hi ROG,

wonder if you can help me. I'm in the market for a 4x4 and trailer. I have not decided on either yet, I would just like to try and get my head around what the rules and regs are so I don't have to ask you every possible combination!!

So far what I have gleaned from skimming this thread is:
* Trailer MAM (5) must not exceed Unladen weight of the Car (2) [is this correct? All the trailers I've seen have MAM around 1900-2400kg, but the unladen weights of all the cars (I have a spreadsheet!) are anywehere from 1490kg(Skoda Yeti) to 1780kg (Hyundai Tucson)]
* GVW of the Car (3) + Trailer MAM (5) cannot exceed 3500kg for a B License [currently all I hold, but I am not against saving up to get my B+E in the future]

Anything else I should be looking at? (Beyond obviously not towing more than the car legally can!!!)

I am so far looking at variations on the Sportage, Qashqai, X-Trail, Tiguan (surprisingly meaty!), Tucson and Yeti. Any other suggestions? Needs to be relatively civilised on fuel as I will most like use it as my main car and I drive ~60miles a day!

Thanks in advance for any help!

* Trailer MAM (5) must not exceed Unladen weight of the Car (2) [is this correct? = NO as that rule was revoked on 19/01/2013 so you can ignore all the unladen weights

For B licence towing you need the vehicle GVW added to the trailer MAM not to exceed 3500kg so the lower the vehicle GVW the greater the trailer MAM can be

GVW and MAM mean exactly the same thing = the maximum something can legally be when fully loaded

I am not very up on various vehicle suggestions apart from one which is the Skoda Octavia 4x4 as it seems to cover all the bases from towing to commuting and along with a lightweight trailer such as a Bateson Derby, down plated via contact with manufacturer, so the set up makes for a good B licence combo

Octavia GVW = about 2100
Derby MAM 1400 (down plated from 1700)
Leaves 725 for the trailer load
 

KdyK

New User
Joined
8 March 2011
Messages
5
Location
Home: Hampshire, Uni: Surrey
Visit site
* Trailer MAM (5) must not exceed Unladen weight of the Car (2) [is this correct? = NO as that rule was revoked on 19/01/2013 so you can ignore all the unladen weights

For B licence towing you need the vehicle GVW added to the trailer MAM not to exceed 3500kg so the lower the vehicle GVW the greater the trailer MAM can be

GVW and MAM mean exactly the same thing = the maximum something can legally be when fully loaded

I am not very up on various vehicle suggestions apart from one which is the Skoda Octavia 4x4 as it seems to cover all the bases from towing to commuting and along with a lightweight trailer such as a Bateson Derby, down plated via contact with manufacturer, so the set up makes for a good B licence combo

Octavia GVW = about 2100
Derby MAM 1400 (down plated from 1700)
Leaves 725 for the trailer load

Thanks ROG. It's such a minefield when trying to do the right thing!

So if I had a Yeti with a GVW of 2130kg, I would have 1370kg to play with as a trailer MAM (almost OK with your Derby example!)? To stick on a B license? Like I said, happy to do my B+E but it's a longer term plan, would like to be able to transport somehow sooner rather than later :) I'd only be taking my ISH at ~550kg or my youngster anyway, neither together, certainly not yet!

The octavia unfortunately leaves me with the problem that I need something beefier for the roads, the samller cars are struggling both suspension wise and too much waterwise, but good to know what I can go on!

Thanks again!
 

ROG

Well-Known Member
Joined
8 January 2010
Messages
8,934
Location
LEICESTER
Visit site
Thanks ROG. It's such a minefield when trying to do the right thing!

So if I had a Yeti with a GVW of 2130kg, I would have 1370kg to play with as a trailer MAM (almost OK with your Derby example!)? To stick on a B license? Like I said, happy to do my B+E but it's a longer term plan, would like to be able to transport somehow sooner rather than later :) I'd only be taking my ISH at ~550kg
You got it !

With something like a HB401/3 it could be down plated from 1600 to 1370 and as its 780 empty that would leave 590 for the trailer load
 

KdyK

New User
Joined
8 March 2011
Messages
5
Location
Home: Hampshire, Uni: Surrey
Visit site
You got it !

With something like a HB401/3 it could be down plated from 1600 to 1370 and as its 780 empty that would leave 590 for the trailer load

Fabulous ROG, thank you! :)

One final question, then I'll leave you alone. How do you find out what each trailer can be down plated to? Is it a question of contacting the various companies and asking?

Was hoping I would be able to hire for a bit of this year, but probably not if I will need to down plate to stay within my license. Another goal! :)
 

ROG

Well-Known Member
Joined
8 January 2010
Messages
8,934
Location
LEICESTER
Visit site
Fabulous ROG, thank you! :)

One final question, then I'll leave you alone. How do you find out what each trailer can be down plated to? Is it a question of contacting the various companies and asking?

Was hoping I would be able to hire for a bit of this year, but probably not if I will need to down plate to stay within my license. Another goal! :)
The trailer manufacturer is the only place where a trailer under 3500 kg MAM can be legally down plated so hiring one is unlikely to be an option
 

Chloeap

Well-Known Member
Joined
2 September 2015
Messages
220
Visit site
Hi I am trying to work out whether I would be able to tow with my Peugeot 407.
Any help is appreciated as I'm finding it all so confusing!

I have a B licence (passed my test in 2011) and kerb weight of car is 1635kg
I can't find some of the other info needed but found the braked towing weight is 1600 kg (not sure if this is relevant?!!) sorry I'm new to this!
I don't have a trailer yet so open to suggestions - but would probably look for a single horse trailer and think i might need to down plate it?! Help!

Thank you in advance!
 

ROG

Well-Known Member
Joined
8 January 2010
Messages
8,934
Location
LEICESTER
Visit site
Hi I am trying to work out whether I would be able to tow with my Peugeot 407.
Any help is appreciated as I'm finding it all so confusing!

I have a B licence (passed my test in 2011) and kerb weight of car is 1635kg
I can't find some of the other info needed but found the braked towing weight is 1600 kg (not sure if this is relevant?!!) sorry I'm new to this!
I don't have a trailer yet so open to suggestions - but would probably look for a single horse trailer and think i might need to down plate it?! Help!

Thank you in advance!
which 407 model ?
GVW or maximum permissible mass is on the V5 keepers document and is the top of four figures on the weight plate usually hidden under the bonnet or in a door frame ...... I need the GVW before going any further
 

greeneyebrow

New User
Joined
13 April 2016
Messages
4
Visit site
Hi, I am new to the forum and I am after some advice. I have asked the question on other forums but haven't had a clear answer with regards to law.
My wife is wanting to buy a small horse box and we need to know if we can use out mpv to tow it with.
Our motor is a Nissan Elgrand, 2003 model E51. it is a JDM model and has no GTW on the vin plate or on the log book.
Nissan japan say they never issued weights for towing as they never homologated it for towing.
Watling towbars sell a towbar for this model and claim that type approval doesn't apply to a JDM which is fair enough, it doesn't, but how can you tow with a car if the manufacturer doesn't issue towing weights? How would you calculate the towing limit? Surely as soon as the train weight goes over the MAM of the Elgrand 2570KG you will be overweight? or have I got it all wrong?

I cannot seem to find anything online to verify this, the DVLA and the DVSA seem to either miss understand or just don't know.

Many thanks in advance to anyone that knows the legal position regarding this.

Rob and Kerry
 

ROG

Well-Known Member
Joined
8 January 2010
Messages
8,934
Location
LEICESTER
Visit site
Hi, I am new to the forum and I am after some advice. I have asked the question on other forums but haven't had a clear answer with regards to law.
My wife is wanting to buy a small horse box and we need to know if we can use out mpv to tow it with.
Our motor is a Nissan Elgrand, 2003 model E51. it is a JDM model and has no GTW on the vin plate or on the log book.
Nissan japan say they never issued weights for towing as they never homologated it for towing.
Watling towbars sell a towbar for this model and claim that type approval doesn't apply to a JDM which is fair enough, it doesn't, but how can you tow with a car if the manufacturer doesn't issue towing weights? How would you calculate the towing limit? Surely as soon as the train weight goes over the MAM of the Elgrand 2570KG you will be overweight? or have I got it all wrong?

I cannot seem to find anything online to verify this, the DVLA and the DVSA seem to either miss understand or just don't know.

Many thanks in advance to anyone that knows the legal position regarding this.

Rob and Kerry
They only way is to contact Nissan UK https://www.nissan.co.uk/customer-service/contact-us.html
 

ROG

Well-Known Member
Joined
8 January 2010
Messages
8,934
Location
LEICESTER
Visit site
Thankyou very much for the speedy reply.
Nissan UK state that as it is a JDM I would have to contact Nissan Japan on postoffice@nissan.co.jp who sent back the reply about them not homologating the Elgrand for towing hence no weights were issued.

I know little on this type of law but I seem to remember that if no GTW is shown then no towing can be done with it - BUT NOT SURE
 

greeneyebrow

New User
Joined
13 April 2016
Messages
4
Visit site
Thanks again for the prompt reply. It seems a very grey area and with tow bar manufacturers happy to produce tow bars it could lead people into a whole heap of trouble, possibly, it id very difficult to find someone at the DVSA who knows the rules.
I am wondering wether to rock up at a vosa weighbridge with the motor and see what they say there.
Thanks again..
 

Molly_Magic

New User
Joined
29 December 2015
Messages
8
Visit site
1 - Pre - 1997 licence
2 - 1678
3 - 2200
4 - 2200
5 - 2340
6 - 905

I currently tow one small pony <500kg. Am interested in what additional weight I could tow.
Many thanks in advance
 

ROG

Well-Known Member
Joined
8 January 2010
Messages
8,934
Location
LEICESTER
Visit site
1 - Pre - 1997 licence
2 - 1678
3 - 2200
4 - 2200
5 - 2340
6 - 905

I currently tow one small pony <500kg. Am interested in what additional weight I could tow.
Many thanks in advance

You can load a max of 1295 into the trailer (2200 towing capacity minus 905 empty trailer = 1295)
 

Joyous70

Well-Known Member
Joined
4 August 2010
Messages
1,944
Visit site
ROG

I have a quick question if you don't mind?

I have a Nissan X trail, which I use for towing max towing capacity 2000kgs

Am I right in thinking that I am breaking the law if the maximum weight of the trailer fully laden exceeds my vehicle's towing capacity even if I am not towing up to the full weight?

Thanks in Advance
 

ROG

Well-Known Member
Joined
8 January 2010
Messages
8,934
Location
LEICESTER
Visit site

ROG

Well-Known Member
Joined
8 January 2010
Messages
8,934
Location
LEICESTER
Visit site
that link did not go directly to the post so .....

There is no law or rule which states that the towing capacity of a vehicle must be able to accommodate a trailer plated MAM but there are plenty of internet myths on this

This is legal
B+E licence
vehicle towing capacity 2000
trailer plated MAM 3500
trailer empty weight 1000
trailer loaded with 1000
 

Joyous70

Well-Known Member
Joined
4 August 2010
Messages
1,944
Visit site
that link did not go directly to the post so .....

There is no law or rule which states that the towing capacity of a vehicle must be able to accommodate a trailer plated MAM but there are plenty of internet myths on this

This is legal
B+E licence
vehicle towing capacity 2000
trailer plated MAM 3500
trailer empty weight 1000
trailer loaded with 1000[/QUOTE

ROG

this is great thank you, I am looking at an Ifor which mgw 2600 Unladen 920, only taking one horse at around 500 to 550kgs so looking at max of 1500kgs and I have a B+E licence as passed before 1997.
 

ROG

Well-Known Member
Joined
8 January 2010
Messages
8,934
Location
LEICESTER
Visit site
Hi folks can some smart cookie help me out?
I have a Kia Sportage 1.7 and am wondering if I can legally tow without B+e as I passed my test in 1999 :(

Gross weight 2000kg
Max trailer load braked 1400kg
I want to tow an ifor Williams single trailer at 767kg + horse no more than 550kg

Is it possible & legal?? I will only be going to local events so max 30 mile journeys once per month. If you need any other vehicle stats I can give them too you if it helps work it out :)

Car GVW 2000 ???? are you certain that is the 'maximum permissible mass' on the V5 keepers doc or the top figure of 4 on the weight plate usually hidden under the bonnet or in a door frame ????
ASSUMING 2000 is the correct GVW then contact IW and they will guide you through the down plating from 1600 to 1500

With the trailer at 1500 MAM but the towing capacity at 1400 means that a max of 633 can be loaded into the trailer (767 + 633 = 1400)

2000 vehicle GVW + 1500 trailer MAM = 3500 = legal for B licence towing
 

pinkypug1

Well-Known Member
Joined
6 October 2008
Messages
401
Visit site
I got the 2000 from the online specs of the vehicle not under the bonnet. Is 2000 low or high?? Will have a look there later. Mare is def below 600kg
 
Top