eggs
Well-Known Member
Video is not currently in the public domain
CDJ withdrawn from paris
- Thread starter Zoeypxo
- Start date
StigOfTheMuckHeap
New User
If it had been released 4 years ago it would have sunk without a trace.
Lady Jane
Well-Known Member
I hope all you have said 'I'm not surprised' can hand on heart say you have never had a angry moment with a horse and behaved out of character for you.
This is malicious timing by the'whistle blower' but bearing in mind the grief that people in the UK have given some of the Dutch riders they must be delighted with themselves.
I don't condone this sort of behaviour but what I see at some local and national shows makes me cringe - and some times it ignorance and pure bad riding because they can't ride any better, but that doesn't make it OK.
This is malicious timing by the'whistle blower' but bearing in mind the grief that people in the UK have given some of the Dutch riders they must be delighted with themselves.
I don't condone this sort of behaviour but what I see at some local and national shows makes me cringe - and some times it ignorance and pure bad riding because they can't ride any better, but that doesn't make it OK.
AWinter
Well-Known Member
I don’t agree that the timing is malicious, I feel it is strategic to have maximum impact when the sport is most in the public eye, so the FEI can’t just brush it under the rug and we can hopefully start to see real change regarding the welfare of horses within the sport.
If you’re not out there abusing horses nothing to worry about is there.
If you’re not out there abusing horses nothing to worry about is there.
Rowreach
Adjusting my sails
I think "people in the UK" have questioned more than just Dutch riders - the other Charlotte, for instance??
TPO
Well-Known Member
Reporting all of the libelous comments.
What is it about things like this that makes people want to act like they're in the know when they don't know the first thing?
Every so often it's questioned why all the good, experienced and knowledgable posters have left HHO. Threads like this are why. Barely a voice of reason left.
I hope Carl's team go after HHO for hosting the libelous drivel being spouted by know nothings.
What is it about things like this that makes people want to act like they're in the know when they don't know the first thing?
Every so often it's questioned why all the good, experienced and knowledgable posters have left HHO. Threads like this are why. Barely a voice of reason left.
I hope Carl's team go after HHO for hosting the libelous drivel being spouted by know nothings.
eahotson
Well-Known Member
You have a point.However people at the top have a duty to set an example.Riding at lower levels can be lack of knowledge as the riders there haven't had the top riders excellent coaching and they may well have day jobs and ride in limited spare time.It can be cruel as well of course.
reynold
Well-Known Member
Lead story on MailOnline
States that the video appeared first on a Dutch website...... interesting timing if that is true from a 'rival' country for medals.
As above reports multiple hits on horses legs during training
States that the video appeared first on a Dutch website...... interesting timing if that is true from a 'rival' country for medals.
As above reports multiple hits on horses legs during training
eahotson
Well-Known Member
They will have to go after the Telegraph as well.
TPO
Well-Known Member
The telegraph hasn't presented as fact that CH has witnessed, endorsed and turned a blind eye to anything.
There's this little thing known as facts.
Burnttoast
Well-Known Member
This is why I have a problem with horse sport at all levels. The competitive element rarely brings out the best (most humane) in anyone, and while the riders at the top of their sport can make things look harmonious in public we're all aware of the pressures very often exerted behind the scenes (not to mention the biologically inappropriate husbandry); equally at the lower levels people may love their one horse and keep it in a very horse-friendly way (or they may not) but that frequently won't stop them trying to ride beyond their ability or succumbing to frustration in a competition (me included, back in the day).
Forum Admin Team
Forum Administrators
Users who raise or continue this subject elsewhere may find their forum access restricted.
Several posts have been removed.
Please be circumspect when commenting. Users posting content that is considered to be problematic may have their access restricted.
Last edited:
Beausmate
Well-Known Member
And rightly so.
eahotson
Well-Known Member
By CH I assume you mean Carl Hester.I did not mention him in my post and no you are correct,neither did The Telegraph.
alibali
Well-Known Member
Thank you FAT for allowing this thread to continue. I hope those commenting will stick to the known facts (of which there seems very few).
Suffice to say I don't care how famous and successful or how inexperienced someone is if they resort to force in their training or competition then they deserve to be held accountable. Regardless of how strategic or inconvenient the timing of their coming to light
Suffice to say I don't care how famous and successful or how inexperienced someone is if they resort to force in their training or competition then they deserve to be held accountable. Regardless of how strategic or inconvenient the timing of their coming to light
lynz88
Well-Known Member
I was about to write exactly this
Also agree with this but I also believe, at the end of the day, no matter who you are or what level you ride at, we are all HUMAN and sometimes emotions get the best of us. Is it right? No. But it happens. To everyone.
Of course not knowing the details of the video, it's all just speculation.
FieldOrnaments
Well-Known Member
appreciate this may be a how long is a piece of string question but what is the time frame on the investigation likely to be?
Fjord
Well-Known Member
I'm disappointed to hear this, although I'm glad it's being investigated. I'd be interested to see the video when everything is over.
Crazy_cat_lady
Well-Known Member
I'm glad the thread has been allowed to continue these things need to be able to be discussed
Christmascinnamoncookie
Fais pas chier!
Interesting timing. Does this mean an end to her career, effectively? There have been other complaints about other riders (OT, for example) and he’s still competing.
misst
Well-Known Member
I have no idea what's in the video anymore than most. But I do know someone doesn't withdraw from a competition like this for no reason. I really hope it was a one off problem and I am sure CDJ isn't the worst culprit by far but sadly she is widely admired and held up as a great example. She certainly is a hard worker and usually comes across as a "nice" person on TV etc. I do feel sorry for anyone enduring this kind of scrutiny it must be almost unbearable. Unfortunately horses don't get given choices and the older I get the more disillusioned I become with horse sport. I have stopped enjoying flat racing, don't watch jump racing, dressage, I used to love but now feel uncomfortable a lot of the time. Showjumping I have felt for years uncomfortable a lot of the time and eventing, my favourite sport is also looking more and more wrong :-(. Maybe we should all just enjoy looking at them in the field :-( although I don't really believe this either...
FieldOrnaments
Well-Known Member
won't it depend on if owners keep horses with her?
Sandstone1
Well-Known Member
The older I get the more I question the way we use animals in sport, and that includes riding for fun. ( yes I do ride but should we?)
NinjaPony
Well-Known Member
Not going to speculate about the video content re CDJ but it’s notable that there are plenty of top riders with absolutely atrocious videos who still compete at the highest levels of the sport, to the shame of the sport. A reckoning is well overdue I fear and that means accepting that riders we look up to might be part of the problem.
ihatework
Well-Known Member
No I doubt it will be the end of her career, unless she gets so much hate that she chooses to end her career. She has taken British dressage to levels we could only have dreamed of 15 years ago - unfortunately the higher your pedestal the greater the fall. She will have a hell of a lot of support behind the scenes and I very much doubt she will loose any/many owners over this. Her visibility is huge and I feel sorry for her in one way (whilst not condoning anything), she is a product of the system
Equi
Well-Known Member
I’m going to take everything with a pinch of salt until I can watch the video myself. PR teams will do damage limitations regardless of what it actually shows. She didn’t have a choice as she can’t compete when it’s being investigated but we have to trust that the FEI will due diligence and release their own statement in time. Until then I’m neutral. Or possibly in denial.
eahotson
Well-Known Member
Agree and if say 90% of anyone's training and horsemanship is kind the odd slip under pressure can be forgiven.I just wonder about the reasons behind this video.The FEI know about concerns over animal welfare in sport and particularly the Olympics.They have not confirmed at the moment whether horse sport will be in the next Olympics.pics
Bellaboo18
Well-Known Member
Very sad and shocked to read this.
I'll wait to watch the video before passing judgement but I can't *imagine* it's going to be pleasant watching given her statement and withdrawal.
I'll wait to watch the video before passing judgement but I can't *imagine* it's going to be pleasant watching given her statement and withdrawal.
equinerebel
Well-Known Member
If we’re “all human” and have apparently all behaved badly around horses at some point out of anger or frustration, then maybe we shouldn’t be around horses. Period.
eahotson
Well-Known Member
Point taken.