Another fatal dog attack

conniegirl

Well-Known Member
Joined
3 November 2004
Messages
9,113
Visit site
As I understand it the man just walked into her house, how many of us with guarding breeds would expect exactly the same response from our dogs.

One of my friends has 2 gun dogs one a Springer the other a Labrador and both bit a local farmer who walked into their house, obviously being the breeds they are he didnt need hospital treatment and he fully accepts responsibility for what happened.

Because XL Bullies have such tremendous bite power they are going to do serious damage but the fact he stopped when called back IMO wasn't a serious attack. I cant help feeling sorry for her , she had her dog pts humanely too. I dont like these dogs and cant understand anyone who wants one but I dont think everyone who owns one is irresponsible either.
The video makes it seem that he was invited in and did nothing more offensive than walk through the door
 

CorvusCorax

'It's only a laugh, no harm done'
Joined
15 January 2008
Messages
59,473
Location
End of the pier
Visit site
The video makes it seem that he was invited in and did nothing more offensive than walk through the door

Doors/entries are very common flashpoints (how many posts have there been on here about even small fluffy dogs barking or going nuts at the front door/window/mail person/person walking past) and it's unfair to expect a dog to discriminate if a complete stranger coming into their territory is a friend or foe, or to understand what an 'invitation' is.

I'm not disputing that the TikToker was an idiot but understanding dogs and their reactions is important.
 

CorvusCorax

'It's only a laugh, no harm done'
Joined
15 January 2008
Messages
59,473
Location
End of the pier
Visit site
I know doors are flash points but imo someone with an invite is very different to someone just walking in.

If you invite someone in then your dog absolutely should be under control and either not inclined to take a bit out of someone or contained in a cage/room with sturdy door.

I absolutely agree with your second point but it is a big ask to expect a dog to know the difference between someone being invited in and just walking in. Those are human conventions.
 

Jenko109

Well-Known Member
Joined
13 July 2020
Messages
1,824
Visit site
If I had a dog capable of easily killing someone, then nobody would be able to just walk in. My door would be locked.

There is a bloke on TikTok. Think hes called Sam the dog man. He has about 5 XL bullies in kennels in his back garden. He posted a video recently about how two of his XL bullies had got out into the street as they had managed to knock the catch on the back gate open. Seriously? Why on earth would you not keep the gate locked?

Also. A few months ago I went round a friends early one morning to drop something off. I had not been to her new house before but we are close enough that I can just walk into her house. Well, I tried to walk into the wrong house, which thankfully was locked! It would only need to take a simple mistake like that to bring me face to face with a dangerous dog, by a completely innocent mistake.
 

Landcruiser

Well-Known Member
Joined
13 May 2011
Messages
3,237
Location
Wiltshire
Visit site
I spent a long time last week talking on the phone to a potential new client at the vets where I work. He called to book a first vacc for a 9 wk pup he was planning to pick up that evening. What started as a friendly enquiry regarding the breed turned into me giving the poor chap the third degree and lots of food for thought, and then very strongly advising him not to buy the pup and why. I hope he listened. How many red flags does it take?

First time dog owner
Small child in the house
9 week pup with no vaccs and unknown worming history
Pup in it's 3rd home already
Not chipped
"Photos" of lovely parents seen.

Oh, and the breed of those parents?
Staff x Corso:oops:.
 

sarah.oxford

Well-Known Member
Joined
29 November 2011
Messages
271
Location
Oxfordshire
Visit site
I spent a long time last week talking on the phone to a potential new client at the vets where I work. He called to book a first vacc for a 9 wk pup he was planning to pick up that evening. What started as a friendly enquiry regarding the breed turned into me giving the poor chap the third degree and lots of food for thought, and then very strongly advising him not to buy the pup and why. I hope he listened. How many red flags does it take?

First time dog owner
Small child in the house
9 week pup with no vaccs and unknown worming history
Pup in it's 3rd home already
Not chipped
"Photos" of lovely parents seen.

Oh, and the breed of those parents?
Staff x Corso:oops:.

3rd home at 9 weeks!!!
As a sbt person I don't agree with them being crossed with anything. A well bred sbt is a fantastic dog, and I have yet to meet a sbt x that has been improved through crossing.
The thought of the type of sbt owner that would cross with a cane Corso doesn't bare thinking about. 2 breeds that you need to know what you are getting.
I'm glad you have had a realistic chat. I really hope they listen. So many red flags there.
 

conniegirl

Well-Known Member
Joined
3 November 2004
Messages
9,113
Visit site
I absolutely agree with your second point but it is a big ask to expect a dog to know the difference between someone being invited in and just walking in. Those are human conventions.
I think you are deliberately miss reading my posts. There was only one point there not 2.

If you just wander into someones house you should expect to face an unhappy dog, if you are invited then that dog should either be friendly with others or should be suitably restrained.

One point, not 2!
 

maisie06

Well-Known Member
Joined
31 March 2009
Messages
4,784
Visit site
I spent a long time last week talking on the phone to a potential new client at the vets where I work. He called to book a first vacc for a 9 wk pup he was planning to pick up that evening. What started as a friendly enquiry regarding the breed turned into me giving the poor chap the third degree and lots of food for thought, and then very strongly advising him not to buy the pup and why. I hope he listened. How many red flags does it take?

First time dog owner
Small child in the house
9 week pup with no vaccs and unknown worming history
Pup in it's 3rd home already
Not chipped
"Photos" of lovely parents seen.

Oh, and the breed of those parents?
Staff x Corso:oops:

I remember seeing something which showed photos of different dogs all showing different behaviours to small children. The children were then asked what the dog was feeling eg scared happy cross etc. The that was clearly snarling was identified by all the children as happy. Because it was smiling.....
That's why unsupervised kids and all dogs should not mix.
I have heard owners describe a snarling dog as "smiling" so I'm not surprised children think that too
 

Ambers Echo

Still wittering on
Joined
13 October 2017
Messages
10,909
Visit site
I'm not disputing that the TikToker was an idiot but understanding dogs and their reactions is important.

I have a friend who is clueless about her own collie dog. She was riding, dog was in the landrover which was unlocked. She had forgotten her whip so asked me to get it from the vehice. With the dog in it. The dog growled as I approached. I went back and said 'I cant get it'. She said 'oh don't be ridiculous he won't do anything' . So I went back thinking surely she knows her own dog and and got closer. Hackles were up, dog started snarling so I walked away. NO WAY was I opening that door. And my friend thought I was the idiot for refusing to stick my arm into the space he was defending.
 

GSD Woman

Well-Known Member
Joined
9 December 2018
Messages
1,567
Visit site
Also. A few months ago I went round a friends early one morning to drop something off. I had not been to her new house before but we are close enough that I can just walk into her house. Well, I tried to walk into the wrong house, which thankfully was locked! It would only need to take a simple mistake like that to bring me face to face with a dangerous dog, by a completely innocent mistake.

This really hit me in the way our 2 countries are so different. Walk into the wrong house, or even ring the bell, and you may be shot. Especially if you aren't white.
 

Red-1

I used to be decisive, now I'm not so sure...
Joined
7 February 2013
Messages
18,437
Location
Outstanding in my field!
Visit site
As I understand it the man just walked into her house, how many of us with guarding breeds would expect exactly the same response from our dogs.

One of my friends has 2 gun dogs one a Springer the other a Labrador and both bit a local farmer who walked into their house, obviously being the breeds they are he didnt need hospital treatment and he fully accepts responsibility for what happened.

Because XL Bullies have such tremendous bite power they are going to do serious damage but the fact he stopped when called back IMO wasn't a serious attack. I cant help feeling sorry for her , she had her dog pts humanely too. I dont like these dogs and cant understand anyone who wants one but I dont think everyone who owns one is irresponsible either.
I have an airlock system for our dogs, as one will nip (17yo terrier). I say nip as he knid of barks too close, rather then biting and taking hold.

If I have workmen round, the door is locked if the dog is loose in the house. I have 2 doors between strangers and the dogs.

If he had permission to enter, the door should have been locked while the dog was out. Because, yes, I would expect that a dog may bite if a stranger walks in unexpectedly. I do think that was irresponsible. Very sad though.
 

Landcruiser

Well-Known Member
Joined
13 May 2011
Messages
3,237
Location
Wiltshire
Visit site

May have previously been on here but that poor baby. Wouldn't have stood a chance
"Sudden and unanticipated."
Like almost all dog attacks then. But actually anyone knowing anything about the breed and with any common sense whatsoever would keep babies well away from them...you'd think.
 

slimjim86

Well-Known Member
Joined
5 May 2010
Messages
526
Visit site
The stupidity of people never fails to surprise me, stupid people who can't see the massive amounts of evidence that show no matter how friendly an xl bully has been in the past their indiscriminate breeding makes them too big a threat to keep in existence any longer ( I do agree that the ones already here who have not shown aggression should be allowed to be kept by responsible owners who adhere to a strict set of rules), stupid people who keep putting themselves and their kids in danger coz they won't learn about dog behaviour and symptoms, stupid people who won't listen to a dogs owner who tells them to keep their distance, the list goes on. Many years ago my partner and I were away at a family event from about 5pm till midnight, so we booked a dog walker to come over and feed our 2 malamutes and give them a toilet break in the garden. She had a 4year old child so I made sure to tell her the red and white one was not to be trusted anywhere near a child, the other one is good with kids but obviously not when he's eating. She said it was fine, her kid was at her mums anyway. I said if the plans changed just to make sure child was in the sitting room watching TV away from the dogs, anyway I got a call just after 9 saying she was in hospital with her kid because the red and white dog had bit his face!!! Obviously she hadn't as he had a bust lip that didn't even need stitches and I'm pretty sure a bite from a 45kg dog would do more damage than that, but why oh why after being told so strenuously not to let him near that dog was he in a position for anything yo happen!!!!
 

SaddlePsych'D

Well-Known Member
Joined
15 December 2019
Messages
3,624
Location
In My Head
Visit site
I've not seen any proper XL bully for ages but today saw one and it was the size of a small bear, running across a main road as I was driving, no muzzle, lead trailing and idiot owner chasing. It proceeded to tow said owner down the road once he'd picked the lead up again. Terrifying. Just really scary to see still out in public.
 

ponyparty

Well-Known Member
Joined
15 October 2015
Messages
2,319
Visit site
Yes... Well. That is what is making me genuinely nervous at the moment, where I live.

There is a bully type in the flats next door to me that recently attacked the lady in the flat below - see my post https://forums.horseandhound.co.uk/threads/irresponsible-owners.814204/post-15717569

I thought the dog was gone, but no, it's still there. I saw it looking through the window the other day.

I have subsequently heard (on the grapevine, and I have no way of verifying this so I am taking with a pinch of salt, but still...) that it's also attacked 3 other people on separate occasions. And that the reason it launched at the woman was because she came through a gate into a communal area - apparently current owner "rescued" it from its previous life as a guard dog for a weed grow, so as she opened the gate it went into guarding mode. Also don't know how true this is of course.

I have complained to the housing association that owns the flats, and they responded instantly to say they've added my complaint to the case log, and that she has been ordered to keep the dog muzzled and on lead in their communal areas, but they don't know about on public land. I have seen the police attend her flat, but I don't know what the outcome was. I haven't seen the dog out and about at all since all this happened - not once. I don't know whether to report my concerns to the police (even the RSPCA - unsuitable environment for the dog?). I just really REALLY don't want it living next door to me :( I'm haunted by the thought of it ragging my 6yo son around. I'm actually considering moving house (not just for this reason, but it's certainly up there!).
 
Top