ElleSkywalker
As excited as Kitty about to be a bridesmaid
Well, that's the only time I've ever enjoyed Tuckers commentary 
Badminton XC day
- Thread starter JennBags
- Start date
Honey08
Waffled a lot!
Aww, commentators getting emotional!
Colivet
Well-Known Member
As an Irish person who normally moans about the lack of coverage of Irish riders, I thought it was great this year. I'm also very proud that all but one of them completed. Wouldn't that little mare of Cathal's break your heart - such a stinker in the dressage and storms round clear the xcountry with very few time penalties
Very exciting competition this year.
Very exciting competition this year.
mypegasus
Well-Known Member
After tea am going to sit down and look at the faults around the course time etc
Should be interesting!
Should be interesting!
Fidgety
Well-Known Member
I liked Zara, but I can't explain why, I found Harry really irritating (sorry you fans
)
Tiddlypom
Carries on creakily
Cracking commentary this year. Mike Tucker, who usually drives me nuts, was excellent, am going to miss him after all.
Fools Motto
Well-Known Member
Does anyone have any footage of the birch corners that Sam Griffiths and PAULANK BROCKAGH 'faulted' at? Please get in touch with him via his eventing page - He's sure he shouldn't get the penalties.
mypegasus
Well-Known Member
Will be interesting to see what they do with regard to the faults - but watching the footage on the BBC red button was abit unsure whether It would be classed as clear or not
only_me
Well-Known Member
So, who do you think will withdraw before sj?
Fidgety
Well-Known Member
Astier
Alec Swan
Well-Known Member
She's of the every day, and me too.
Zara Tindall comes from a decent mare line, I think.
Alec.
Mule
Well-Known Member
Lol
Honey08
Waffled a lot!
It looked clear as daylight that he missed it on the BBC.
Fidgety
Well-Known Member
ycbm
Einstein would be proud of my Insanity...
The BBC got it head on, he won't need private video.. Clear as daylight he faulted. The horse broke the flag with his left foreleg.
AmieeT
Well-Known Member
Definitely!
And the lass who's horse came out lame at the finish- can't remember her name or her horse's!
Rowreach
👀
After years of enjoying watching the XC coverage I found most of that very uncomfortable to view. Few combinations looked happy going round, nothing really flowed and they were darned lucky not to have a disaster from one of the excessive number of rotational falls on course. I hope a few questions will be asked when today is reviewed.
The Fuzzy Furry
Getting old disgracefully
Escapade
Well-Known Member
Don't think he has much of a case really
Shooting Star
Well-Known Member
It's on his FB page that the jury have decided that the penalties will remain, which IMO is right - I really can't see how that could ever not have been a fault
mypegasus
Well-Known Member
So I've started to look at numbers for cross country day - don't know if anyone is interested:
82 horses completed the dressage, one of those withdrew before cross country today - so there were 81 starters.
Of those:
49 completed the course
16 retired
16 were eliminated
Of the 49 completions:
32 completed with no jumping penalties (2 within the time)
1 completed with 1 frangible pin breakage
12 completed with 1 refusal
2 completed with 1 refusal and 1 frangible pin breakage
1 completed with 50 penalties for jumping outside flag
1 completed with 2 refusals at the same fence
The slowest completion was 173 seconds outside the optimum time for the course.
I'll be analysing the problems on the course and the movements up and down the leaderboard.
Hope you don't mind me posting on here!
82 horses completed the dressage, one of those withdrew before cross country today - so there were 81 starters.
Of those:
49 completed the course
16 retired
16 were eliminated
Of the 49 completions:
32 completed with no jumping penalties (2 within the time)
1 completed with 1 frangible pin breakage
12 completed with 1 refusal
2 completed with 1 refusal and 1 frangible pin breakage
1 completed with 50 penalties for jumping outside flag
1 completed with 2 refusals at the same fence
The slowest completion was 173 seconds outside the optimum time for the course.
I'll be analysing the problems on the course and the movements up and down the leaderboard.
Hope you don't mind me posting on here!
Last edited:
teapot
Well-Known Member
Similar numbers finished and/or had problems at last year's Badminton. It's not meant to be a dressage competition, every horse got up from its fall (if it fell rather than unseated), and one rider in hospital as a precaution. Don't forget there were 25 Badminton first timers, or was it 25 first timers at 4*, can't quite remember which, but worth considering.
Escapade
Well-Known Member
Not at all, the stats would be really interesting!!
stencilface
High upon a hillside
Scoti1420
Well-Known Member
What a photo!!
AmyMay
Situation normal
I agree. The water combinations were particularly 'meh'. I only managed to catch a few rounds, but found thought most of it looked really sticky.
smellsofhorse
Well-Known Member
I haven't read the whole post but did anything come of the horse that fell at the last fence?
Perhaps it should have been pulled up as it did look tired before the finish.
What I didn't like though was the fact the rider got up and walked away and ignored her horse.
Yes I expect she was shocked, winded, disappointed etc
Plus her grooms were on the way.
But I felt it was a total lack of caring,
She could have checked if the horse was ok and immediately got it moving to cool it down until the grooms got to her.
Maybe I'm too soft and forget she is a professional rider.
Perhaps it should have been pulled up as it did look tired before the finish.
What I didn't like though was the fact the rider got up and walked away and ignored her horse.
Yes I expect she was shocked, winded, disappointed etc
Plus her grooms were on the way.
But I felt it was a total lack of caring,
She could have checked if the horse was ok and immediately got it moving to cool it down until the grooms got to her.
Maybe I'm too soft and forget she is a professional rider.
Fidgety
Well-Known Member
That's a brilliant photo! What a monkey though, I bet he gave her a fright bogging off like that
AmyMay
Situation normal
It should have been stopped. I do think the rider was winded after the fall though. And the horse received immediate attention from the ground crew them it's groom.
smellsofhorse
Well-Known Member
I agree the ground crew arrived quickly loosening tack etc and the grooms were running to get to them as they were obviously further away at the finish.
But I still think she showed a lack of care.
I would have grabbed horse and got it walking at least until the grooms arrived.
But perhaps I'm being to hard.